4 ms·
There is a quite common "design feature" in official functions which says if you stick to a rulebook you can be covered for indemnity and if you divert from a r
by ggm 3y ago
There is a quite common "design feature" in official functions which says if you stick to a rulebook you can be covered for indemnity and if you divert from a rulebook you are on your own. It stops risky behaviour. It is designed to stop things like Chernobyl.
In some situations, it turns into a flaw. "Computer says no"
This played out in Queensland over a flood which had a dam release issue, and went to law between 2 agencies, the government overall, and the affected businesses and householders who were flooded. The case had to be tried in another states courts, to avoid systematic bias issues.
Of course you need to stick to the rulebook. But the rulebook needs to be written to handle unforseen situations, which might be hard, but not impossible. Put it up the food chain, or provide from some limited relief from risk.
So, the emergency sirens weren't used because "they aren't for this function" and now we have "can't approve the water release" -Sounds like the reaction of somebody who is concerned they will answer for a decision not explicitly covered in the rulebook.
Or, they simply didn't understand their role, and their authority to act. Which of course, should be explained in the rulebook.
[edit: people are pointing out there were huge risks in using the sirens, and the rulebook was really explicit, and the community understood their narrow intent. So, its probably a bad example of my hypothesised "rulebook says no" thing]
- threeseed 3y ago> So, the emergency sirens weren't used They weren't used because the website [1] specifically says that in the event of a siren you should "if you in a low laying area near the coastline; evacuate to high grounds, inland". This would directly route people towards the fire not away. And given that tsunamis can sometimes trigger fire it easily could have caused confusion in some. It definitely wasn't a clear decision as some like to make out. [1] https://dod.hawaii.gov/hiema/all-hazard-statewide-outdoor-warning-siren-system/ https://dod.hawaii.gov/hiema/all-hazard-statewide-outdoor-wa...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ggm 3y agoNone of these rulebook cases are. It's clear that some of the risks here were real, but it's also likely some of them are hypothetical. This will be argued out for a long time. What often happens is the rulebook is amended. Add a new siren-tone, modify the instructions to turn on a radio or TV and get more specific advice, something changes, to reflect the new understanding. Or not. Sometimes, you can't fix this. The sirens are for tsunamis and some other system is needed for wildfires. Which risk do you think is more likely, and more consequential in the medium to short term? I don't know, I don't have the answers here. But I do believe, people in Lahaina probably wanted to be alerted, somehow to the risk.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoSo why is this case noteworthy enough for you to elaborate on?
- ggm 3y agoBecause it formed part of the legal defence of a decision to release water, and incur flooding, in consequence of which people went to law. I would imagine, perhaps wrongly, that in the case of Lahaina people who have suffered catastrophic loss will be considering if there was a state, or town, or other official who had a duty of care, and who may be taken to law, or their body taken to law for failure to act. What do you think?
- MichaelZuo 3y agoWhat are you asking me to think in regards to? Can you clarify your first paragraph and separate out each claim?
- ggm 3y ago> So why is this case noteworthy enough for you to elaborate on? What did this question mean?
- 3y ago
- jjcm 3y ago> > So, the emergency sirens weren't used > They weren't used because the website [1] specifically says that in the event of a siren you should "if you in a low laying area near the coastline; evacuate to high grounds, inland". +1 to this. Everyone on the island knows those sirens. I was there in 2011 when the sirens went off to warn about the incoming tsunami from the Tohoku earthquake[0]. We packed sandwiches and water, and headed for high ground along with everyone else. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_T%C5%8Dhoku_earthquake_and_tsunami#Elsewhere_across_the_Pacific https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_T%C5%8Dhoku_earthquake_an...
- zarzavat 3y agoMisuse of the sirens on one occasion might also cause people to hesitate in the future if there were to be a tsunami. And you really don’t have time to hesitate in that situation.
- fsckboy 3y agoit's too bad when they were going to the trouble to install sirens all over "the last mile", they didn't think to have more than one alarm meaning.
- ScoobleDoodle 3y agoThe sirens are only along the coast. Not mountain side.
- fsckboy 3y ago> The sirens are only along the coast. Not mountain side. the better to lure sailors onto the rocks! (the word Siren comes from Greek mythology, Siren's were "humanlike beings with very alluring voices, they appear in a scene in the Odyssey in which Odysseus" stops "the ears of his crew with wax so that they were deaf to the Sirens. Odysseus himself wanted to hear their song but had himself tied to the mast so that he would not be able to steer the ship off its course." in latin languages such as Italian, "mermaid" is "la sirena")
- cameldrv 3y agoI think it’s normal procedure in California when an evacuation is ordered for the police to go door to door making sure everyone is out. Regardless of the sirens, depending on mobile phones, which in this case did not work, is not good enough. Even if the network were running, not everyone has a phone or it’s turned off or the battery is dead. You can’t just leave those people to die. Even just driving around town with a bullhorn would have saved a lot of lives.
- dylan604 3y ago>depending on mobile phones, which in this case did not work, is not good enough Hawaii's use of mobile phone notifications do not have a good track record for those of us only hearing about how they don't work. At least they did not receive incoming nuclear attack messages to throw even more chaos into the situation
- somat 3y agoThis, I think the reason for the large number of deaths in the event was that because there are no wild fires in Hawaii the government and people were unprepared for it. they have lava(which is not the same) but are used to dealing with that. This will happen whenever an infrequent event happens. A large earthquake hits the British islands, complete clusterfuck, japan, they handle it. A hurricane hits Florida, they are used to it. southern California, everybody goes insane.
- ryathal 3y agoExactly, we see this almost every year when a southern state gets a light dusting of snow.
- TeeMassive 3y agoTrue, wild fires are known to not emit light and not emit anything visible. People wouldn't have known.
- vel0city 3y agoWildfires can move incredibly quickly when you're in the path and can change direction extremely rapidly. If you're inside it could be very easy to not know one is coming until it's too late.
- Johnny555 3y agoPower was already out, people had no communication, distant earthquakes have no signs until the tsunami comes… so what will people do when the Tsunami sirens go off? Evacuate along the coast where they are safer from fire but at risk from tsunami, or evacuate inland into the fires?
- macinjosh 3y agoNot Tsunami sirens. Emergency sirens. Their rules said it could be used for any calamity.
- Johnny555 3y agoWhen I lived on Oahu, my landlord told me that if the sirens go off, follow the evacuation route and head to higher ground. I've never heard anyone talk about them in the context of any other emergency warning.
- more_corn 3y agoThat will change. Emergency protocols are written in blood. The sirens will be used next time and people will be trained in the different meanings.
- jibe 3y agoThat page also specifically calls out wildfires as one of the uses of the sirens. I agree it wasn’t a clear decision, but still a mistake not to use them. The all-hazard siren system can be used for a variety of both natural and human-caused events; including tsunamis, hurricanes, dam breaches, flooding, wildfires, volcanic eruptions, terrorist threats, hazardous material incidents, and more.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Alupis 3y agoOk, so don't use that specific siren. What about all the other emergency communication systems that exist? We get Amber and Silver alerts directly on our cell phones. Heck, I've received "poor air quality" alerts even. There's also the classic emergency frequency stuff for radio/tv. Why were none of those mechanisms used? Or were they, and they're just not being reported on?
- lolinder 3y agoThey did use them, but cell towers and electricity were out in much of the area. https://www.civilbeat.org/2023/08/maui-emergency-chief-defends-decision-not-to-activate-warning-sirens/ https://www.civilbeat.org/2023/08/maui-emergency-chief-defen...
- bhk 3y agoThat page also says: > The all-hazard siren system can be used for a variety of both natural and human-caused events; including tsunamis, hurricanes, dam breaches, flooding, wildfires, volcanic eruptions, terrorist threats, hazardous material incidents, and more. > When a siren tone is heard other than a scheduled test, tune into local Radio/TV/Cable stations for emergency information and instructions by official authorities.
- msandford 3y agoFrom that website: The all-hazard siren system can be used for a variety of both natural and human-caused events; including tsunamis, hurricanes, dam breaches, flooding, wildfires, volcanic eruptions, terrorist threats, hazardous material incidents, and more.
- emodendroket 3y agoI do find it somewhat plausible the explanation that sounding the sirens could cause people to seek higher ground when that was basically the worst thing they could do.
- ggm 3y agoYes. It's absolutely plausible.
- lurking_swe 3y agoi call BS. it’s plausible, until you take into account that this emergency occurred in the middle of the night when many residents were asleep. And cell towers were offline by this point, so there was literally no other way to alert people in west maui. The risk that some residents are stupid enough to run into a fire uphill seems WAY better than letting one thousand plus people die in their sleep.
- macinjosh 3y agoI am sure once outside the nature of the emergency would become clear. They are people not lemmings.
- emodendroket 3y agoWhy are you sure of this? If it were so readily apparent just by looking what difference would the sirens make?
- geph2021 3y agoif you stick to a rulebook you can be covered for indemnity and if you divert from a rulebook you are on your own I think a solution to this "flaw" could be for government/officials to have a version of the business judgement rule[1] to shield them from liability, especially when operating under emergency situations. 1 - https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/business_judgment_rule https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/business_judgment_rule
- SoftTalker 3y agoSimilar to aircraft and ship captains. They operate under a litany of rules, but in an emergency they are recognized as the person in control and they may deviate from rules as necessary based on their experienced and professional judgement.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoIt’s even codified. Rule number 2 in the colregs (ship right of way rules: collision regulations) is that nothing in the rule book exonerates you from responsibility to avoid la collision if you can. In other words, if breaking the rules is the prudent thing to do, you aren’t just empowered to break the rules, you are required to. There is no such thing as stand your ground rules at sea.
- derekp7 3y agoBut is the captain shielded from liability if they make the wrong judgement call when deviating from the rule book in an emergency, and protected when following the rules? Or are they judged for making the wrong decision regardless if they were following the rules or not? Or third option, if in an emergency they are protected no matter what decision they make, as long as the decision could be considered reasonable based on information available, even if not optimal based on hindsight? Of those I like 2 and 3 the best. For 2, it can help influence them to make better decisions (i.e., seek more training ahead of time). For 3, it seems to be the most fair to the person in charge.
- kgilpin 3y ago
- kappuchino 3y agoI'm only commenting on this passage: >> the emergency sirens weren't used because "they aren't for this function" and now we have ... I think the sirens were a good call and a bad example of what you want to state. Becuase it is established that people (would) associate the sirens with a tusnami warning. Their anticipated action would under this assumption to seek higher ground. Where the fire was. (See for yourself: https://old.reddit.com/r/therewasanattempt/comments/15vfw26/to_accuse_an_emergency_service_worker_for/ https://old.reddit.com/r/therewasanattempt/comments/15vfw26/...) I'm from germany and here sirens here have been assigned with the "turn the fucking radio on NOW" behaviour. In my city there is a siren drill every other month to get you aware, my city only skipped it out of sensibility one time for the ukranian refugees directly after the war to give them some peace. For more emergent situations we have Emergency Apps like "Nina" and "KatWarn" + Mobile Push Systems to alert you precisely about the kind of emergency/danger you are facing. My city for example has a WW2 Bomb found every other week, meaning thousands of people get evacuated for a time and need get informed.
- michaelmrose 3y agoWouldn't they likely have seen the smoke instead of hanging out in there houses until it was too late to leave. People that are out and moving can choose to move in the right direction but people who are stationary are just waiting to die from a crisis they don't understand is happening. I think it was the wrong call.
- lolinder 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37230146 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37230146 We have a commenter here who lived on Maui who says that the behavior on hearing the siren is hard coded, not something people second guess. If you hesitate when there's a tsunami, you die. Personally, I'm not qualified to have an opinion on this, not living on Maui, so I'll defer to the locals rather than the armchair emergency response managers.
- 8note 3y agoBy the time you can see the slightly denser smoke, you're stuck in traffic headed towards the fire, no?
- legitster 3y ago> There is a quite common "design feature" in official functions which says if you stick to a rulebook you can be covered for indemnity and if you divert from a rulebook you are on your own. The reason that I don't find discussions of the Trolley Problem very interesting is that we as a society have largely solved for it already: If you take responsibility and change the default state, it is your fault - if you leave it alone, it is nobody's.
- aCoreyJ 3y agoMaking a decision isn't solving the trolly problem though
- lazide 3y agoIf you don’t ‘touch it’ by getting involved, society has generally agreed it isn’t your trolley problem. Which is nice, at least.
- someplaceguy 3y agoNice for you and the one guy stuck in the other track, but not for the 100 people that would be hit by the trolley if you didn't do anything... :)
- lazide 3y agoSounds like those folks should hire someone to give a damn instead of trying to guilt random passerby’s into saving them!
- justinclift 3y ago> the emergency sirens weren't used Are you meaning in Queensland or Maui?
- ggm 3y agoMaui. A good case is being made that this was the right decision. I don't live there and I think thats something locals should say. So, I'm reading this and reflecting more than writing.
- xwdv 3y agoIt was absolutely the right decision. If you sound sirens for anything you’ll sound them for everything and they lose impact.
- userbinator 3y agoThis seems to be a natural consequence of training people to follow rules unquestioningly; their thinking skills atrophy, to the point that they won't be able to do anything else.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stock_toaster 3y agoI believe there is more going on than meets the eye here. > This is a classic case of disaster capitalism: a small elite > group using a profound human tragedy as their window to roll > back a hard-won grassroots victory for water rights, while > removing civil servants who pose a political inconvenience > to the administration’s pro-developer agenda. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/aug/17/hawaii-fires-maui-water-rights-disaster-capitalism https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/aug/17/hawaii...
- 2-718-281-828 3y ago> It is designed to stop things like Chernobyl. how is this applicable to chernobyl?