11 ms·
Tesla asked officials to redact info of driver-assistance in use during crashes
- bdcravens 3y agoThis is why I'm not convinced by arguments that FSD is no worse than normal humans: the ethics of the underlying company. To me it's like someone who regularly drives drunk pointing to the fact they've never had an accident.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> I'm not convinced by arguments that FSD is no worse than normal humans Has this claim been made by an independent third party? (About Tesla's FSD, specifically.)
- mlyle 3y agoNo. In principle, even half-baked driver assistance can make things safer, but it all depends upon the way the driver is integrated into that system. Humans are terrible at vigilance tasks, and if you ask them to passively monitor a system that gets things right 98% of the time, you're going to have a bad time. Even worse if you strongly imply that the system is good enough (e.g. "the person in the driver's seat is only there for legal reasons")
- freerobby 3y ago> Humans are terrible at vigilance tasks, and if you ask them to passively monitor a system that gets things right 98% of the time, you're going to have a bad time. I understand this as a hypothesis but it hasn't been borne out by any of the Autopilot usage data. I suspect the reason is that humans suffer greatly from fatigue and ADAS systems reduce fatigue.
- itsoktocry 3y ago>I suspect the reason is that humans suffer greatly from fatigue and ADAS systems reduce fatigue. I understand this hypothesis, but has it borne out by any independent analysis of Autopilot usage data? Tesla is selling expensive software and claiming it's safer. It should be safer, I want it to be safer. But is it?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freerobby 3y agoWith specific respect to ADAS systems reducing fatigue: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1369847814000904 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S13698... > We investigated the effects of ACC and HAD on drivers’ workload and situation awareness through a meta-analysis and narrative review of simulator and on-road studies. Based on a total of 32 studies, the unweighted mean self-reported workload was 43.5% for manual driving, 38.6% for ACC driving, and 22.7% for HAD (0% = minimum, 100 = maximum on the NASA Task Load Index or Rating Scale Mental Effort). https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1361920921001851#b0165 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136192092... > Interviewees reported being less mentally and physically tired—though most focused on the former—both while in transit and upon arrival at their destination. Twelve (12) interviewees mentioned this. The reduction in tiredness seems to be because, from the interviewees perspective, partial automation takes over a substantial portion of the driving task.
- sumeno 3y ago> I understand this as a hypothesis but it hasn't been borne out by any of the Autopilot usage data. Which independent Autopilot usage data are you referencing?
- freerobby 3y agoI don't have any independent data, just what Tesla reports: https://www.tesla.com/VehicleSafetyReport https://www.tesla.com/VehicleSafetyReport I've read the many critiques of Tesla's analysis, and I tend to agree the benefits are overstated, but I haven't seen any reasonable empirical case that Autopilot hurts safety on net.
- burkaman 3y agoI found this study, which sort of makes this claim with a lot of qualifications: https://engrxiv.org/preprint/view/1973 https://engrxiv.org/preprint/view/1973. It's comparing Autopilot to "normal" Tesla driving, which still includes auto-braking, blind spot warnings, etc. It is still based on Tesla's own data and has to make a ton of assumptions, but it seems like they did the best they could. > By correcting for roadway usage differences between the Autopilot and active safety only data, much of the crash reduction seen by vehicles using Autopilot appears to be explained by lower crash rates experienced on freeways. While the raw crash rate shows an average 43% reduction in crash rate for Autopilot compared to active safety only, this improvement is only 10% after controlling for different rates of freeway driving. Correcting for age demographics likewise produced an 11% increase in the estimated crash rate. Several other factors may explain difference in safety rates of new vehicle technologies based on who is using them, where they are being used, and when they are being used. Some safety features cannot be used in rain or snow, for example, which may bias the data towards clear weather and lower crash rates generally. In another example, drivers often disengage Autopilot to change lanes or prepare to exit a freeway (Morando et al., 2020), both areas of increased crash risk. While Tesla includes crashes where Autopilot was deactivated less than five seconds prior to impact, there remains a potential for Autopilot use to be biased towards safer, within-lane driving. With more data regarding not only the crashes but also the use of vehicle technologies can allow for more accurate and thorough assessments of vehicle safety benefits.
- AlexandrB 3y agoNice! I've always been skeptical of coarse metrics like "X million miles per accident" because they don't differentiate between different driving environments like freeways and cities. I'm glad there's research breaking the data down in a more fine-grained way.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoOr that they've had several accidents, but just didn't happen to be "officially" drunk when the accidents occurred, even though there's evidence they were drinking shortly before...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sockaddr 3y agoAs a current tesla owner I couldn't have said it better. There have been multiple instances over the years where my car would make completely inappropriate and dangerous decisions (like slamming on the brakes on the interstate or in a parking lot for no reason) and when I ask Tesla for more information about the incident they'll flat our lie and say it never happened or that the car is or is not capable of what I'm claiming. It's lies and gaslighting all the way down even to specific repairs they do (claiming they fix something when they actually do no such thing). At this point due to Tesla corporate's untrustworthy behavior I believe Teslas are a risk to drivers and pedestrians alike and will take every opportunity to make this known as a warning to prospective buyers. Tesla, never again.
- rvnx 3y agoIt made me think about this video where a person tests whether the car detects a small child that is very fast crossing the road. The answer from Tesla: "It's all lies! It is a competitor!", without addressing the main concern.
- jonny_eh 3y ago> There have been multiple instances over the years where my car would make completely inappropriate and dangerous decisions Dumb question, but is this with the FSD on or off?
- sockaddr 3y agoNot a dumb question. My car slightly predates FSD. The behavioral issues were a result of: - Enhanced Autopilot $5000 option that I can't get a refund for - Emergency auto-braking (has to be manually disabled for each trip) I commented because the lack of ethics of this company still apply regardless of the specific tech.
- jonny_eh 3y ago> Emergency auto-braking (has to be manually disabled for each trip) Wow, what a nightmare!
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/I7Q5M https://archive.is/I7Q5M
- wedn3sday 3y agoIve had the FSD beta for about a month now and never once has it gotten me anywhere without a disengagement, and has several times very nearly caused a crash. I know its anecdata but from all the youtube videos and press I was really expecting it to at least be half-way decent. At the moment its absolute rubbish and should not be allowed on the roads.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dzader 3y agoI also have FSD beta and my model Y can't even get out of my neighborhood successfully. really wish I could get a refund.
- toast0 3y agoIf I were in your shoes, I'd check w/ a lemon law attorney, and see what they think about using that to get a refund. After all, the car doesn't work as described.
- throwaway54_56 3y agoI'm not a contract expert by any means, but this is what it says on the order page: "The currently enabled features require active driver supervision and do not make the vehicle autonomous. The activation and use of these features are dependent on achieving reliability far in excess of human drivers as demonstrated by billions of miles of experience, as well as regulatory approval, which may take longer in some jurisdictions. As these self-driving features evolve, your car will be continuously upgraded through over-the-air software updates."
- yomlica8 3y ago> The activation and use of these features are dependent on achieving reliability far in excess of human drivers as demonstrated by billions of miles of experience, as well as regulatory approval, which may take longer in some jurisdictions. In other words, you can't rely on this until if becomes perfect. Which is meant to imply it is already almost perfect, but upon careful reading could also mean it doesn't work at all.
- Operyl 3y agoWait, according to the article FSD is now 15k PER YEAR? Holy smokes.
- thorncorona 3y agoper year doesn't seem right.
- andrewmunsell 3y agoIt’s not. It’s $15k one time or $200 a month
- mjhay 3y agoNonetheless, that's quite a bit. Why would I want to pay that when I can plow my car into a gore point for free?
- adocomplete 3y agoArticle is wrong. It's either $15k one-time or $200/mo.
- pseudosavant 3y agoTesla pricing is wild. A base Model 3 is $40k. Increase that price by 50% to $60k if you want FSD beta and a color other than black or white.
- candiddevmike 3y agoPaying for the privilege of beta testing something that puts you and your passengers lives at risk.
- input_sh 3y agoThis "article" is pretty much regurgitating a fairly brief part of a much longer New Yorker article: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/08/28/elon-musks-shadow-rule https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/08/28/elon-musks-sha... I'd suggest reading the New Yorker article instead. There was a discussion on it, but most of the comments were flagged to death, so I'm not gonna link it. Other bold claims include Musk personally talking to Putin and intervening in Ukraine's counter-offensive via Starlink, NASA officials saying he's basically treated as an unelected official, Sam Altman claiming he "wants the world to be saved, but only if he can be the one to save it" etc.
- aauchter 3y agoThe article misstates that Tesla redacted when ADAS was in use, which is incorrect. They redact which version was in use.
- pseudosavant 3y agoIf the data showed that Tesla's driver-assistance features were correlated with fewer crashes and better outcomes I'm pretty sure Tesla wouldn't be trying to get the govt to redact this information. Elon would be Xing about it left and right.
- dmoy 3y agoIt is really unfortunate that the verb form of X is a sort of common name in Chinese. That sentence parses like "Elon would be Jerry about it left and right"
- pseudosavant 3y agoI kind of hate myself for even referring to it as X. haha
- kwhitefoot 3y agoI think the really important part of the article is this: "The Vehicle Safety Act explicitly restricts NHTSA's ability to release what the companies label as confidential information. Once any company claims confidentiality, NHTSA is legally obligated to treat it as confidential unless/until NHTSA goes through a legal process to deny the claim." This can't have been done merely at the behest of Tesla, there must have been other forces at work to get that put into the legislation. So while Tesla is the proximate cause in this case they are enabled by legislation that is hostile to road safety.
- abduhl 3y agoThis type of language is found in many public safety type laws. It’s to encourage companies to cooperate with the public safety investigation without having to fear that their confidential information will be released. It may seem hostile to public safety on its face but it really isn’t - it’s harmful to public knowledge, which is hardly a proxy for public safety. It’s certainly been abused by some companies but is likely beneficial on the whole because it encourages full disclosure and cooperation with the government public safety agencies. The opposite approach would be to not have the protection available and to have companies withhold information until forced to disclose by the government, most likely via a lawsuit of some kind which would take years to resolve. Years that could be used improving public safety.
- tiahura 3y agoThis type of language is found in many public safety type laws. See e.g., Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act.
- Veserv 3y agoIf you want to look at the underlying reports they can be found here: https://www.nhtsa.gov/laws-regulations/standing-general-order-crash-reporting https://www.nhtsa.gov/laws-regulations/standing-general-orde... In particular here: https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/ffdd/sgo-2021-01/SGO-2021-01_Incident_Reports_ADAS.csv https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/ffdd/sgo-2021-01/SGO-2021-01_In... You can see that Tesla always reports ADAS version as: [REDACTED, MAY CONTAIN CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION]. Almost every other company reports the version almost always if it is known. Some companies have many unknowns, but most of those crash reports seem to be from customer reports which appear to not have associated telemetry. Of note, most of those reports with unknown version include un-redacted summaries and injury severity information, so they do seem to be good faith efforts, if somewhat lacking in actionable information. In contrast, Tesla redacts all narrative and does not confirm injury severity. In over 700 cases, around 95% of their reports, they choose not to investigate whether an injury or fatality occurred. In the ~5% with a confirmed injury/fatality, exactly one has no 3rd party confirmation. The other ~95% have no 3rd party reports of injury/fatality and lo and behold, no injury/fatality is reported. This is straight up impossible if you look at the crash reports. There are literally tens if not hundreds of high speed oncoming, t-bone, object, and pole collisions all with no recorded injury/fatality. They are absolutely reporting in bad faith.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> In contrast, Tesla redacts all narrative and does not confirm injury severity. In over 700 cases, around 95% of their reports, they choose not to investigate whether an injury or fatality occurred. Tesla has now "decided" that if active restraints or airbags are not deployed, that incident "does not count going forward". As an automobile manufacturer, there is no good conscience reasoning that Tesla is unaware that active restraint and airbag systems of today are far more nuanced and weigh multiple criteria when deciding to deploy (as compared to initial/early implementations, which were essentially "if collision=true and speed >= X mph then deploy"). You can have a very significant incident (two that I've witnessed recently as a paramedic involved vehicles into stationary objects at ~30mph) without airbag deployment. But if that was a Tesla in FSD that hit something at 30mph and didn't deploy airbags, well, that's not an accident according to Tesla. That also doesn't account for "incident was so catastrophic that restraint systems could not deploy", also "not counted" by Tesla. Or just as egregious, "systems failed to deploy for any reason up to and including poor assembly line quality control", also not an accident and also "not counted".
- stevenhubertron 3y agoIf they marketed it as "driver assistance" and not "full self driving" I would agree with the redaction. Assistance software is just that, but when you sell it as set it and forget. Then it is relevant to the story.
- aauchter 3y agoThe reason this isn't getting more attention: There are 99 fatalities per day in the US from car accidents. There have been 17 fatalities from Teslas in AutoPilot mode since 2019 per WaPo.
- newaccount74 3y ago17 fatalities the WaPo was able to independently confirm. I'm assuming there are more than 17, but we don't know about them, because "redacted"
- aauchter 3y agoThey redacted the version of driver assistance (autopilot vs FSD), not that there was driver assistance. The article is does not make this clear, but another poster linked to the actual reports CSV and it's clear that's the case.
- phkahler 3y ago"Tesla requested redaction of fields of the crash report based on a claim that those fields contained confidential business information," an NHTSA spokesperson told Insider in a statement. "The Vehicle Safety Act explicitly restricts NHTSA's ability to release what the companies label as confidential information. Once any company claims confidentiality, NHTSA is legally obligated to treat it as confidential unless/until NHTSA goes through a legal process to deny the claim." There's nothing confidential about which systems were active. The driver knows this, assuming they're not dead. You don't get to claim something is confidential if it's information that's already out there.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> There's nothing confidential about which systems were active. The driver knows this, assuming they're not dead. You don't get to claim something is confidential if it's information that's already out there. Therein lies another problem. Tesla will happily (and without your specific agreement) release any and all telemetry, or use it against you, if they feel it will protect their reputation. One of the earlier fatal FSD-related crashes, Tesla held a press conference to defend FSD. They talked about "requiring driver attention" and that, in this case, "the vehicle had issued a warning to the driver about their inattentiveness". What they didn't say in that press conference, and was only revealed much later, though they obviously knew it at that time, was that while the vehicle had triggered an inattention warning: 1) It happened only one time, and 2) It happened eighteen MINUTES before the collision.
- more_corn 3y agoFunny how it goes from Full Self Driving!!! When they’re selling it to ‘driving assistance’ when somebody dies.
- throwthat1 3y agoHey should get sued for FSD claim