3 ms·
The bulletpoints from the original Forbes reporting ("https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/08/21/draft-tiktok-cfius-agreement/ https://www.forbes.
by neilv 3y ago
The bulletpoints from the original Forbes reporting ("https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/08/21/draft-tiktok-cfius-agreement/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2023/08/21/dra...") look not like domestic spying, but more like close oversight of a party who isn't trusted but can't be shut down. With possible exception of this one:
> * Examine TikTok’s U.S. facilities, records, equipment and servers with minimal or no notice,
Such as if it includes arbitrary access to user data, or opportunity to modify the systems rather than only examine.
Forbes included this interesting other bit, separate from its bulletpoint list, and I didn't see Gizmodo mention it:
> It would also force TikTok U.S. to exclude ByteDance leaders from certain security-related decision making, and instead rely on an executive security committee that would operate in secrecy from ByteDance.
BTW, why is Forbes calling this a "free speech platform"? Is that now accepted terminology, or is there some spin they're promoting?
> Were it to be finalized, the agreement would provide the government near unfettered access to internal TikTok information and unprecedented control over essential functions that it does not have over any other major free speech platform.
Is the explanation really as simple as:
> Forbes (/fɔːrbz/) is an American business magazine founded in 1917 and owned by the Hong Kong-based investment group Integrated Whale Media Investments since 2014.[3][4]
I'm inclined to think that the best defense against hypothetical threats from an app like this is a smart, critical-thinking, principled citizenry. But since Rupert Murdoch, and the culture that followed, have decimated that capability, maybe we need more help from government.