14 ms·
60 Minutes: Elon Musk and SpaceX [video]
- jeremyrwelch 15y agowas shocked to see Elon tear up a bit when the interviewer asks him about Buzz Aldrin's criticisms.
- friism 15y agoYeah, me too - powerful stuff.
- bane 15y agoThere's a time, a sad time, when up and comers ping on the radar of their heroes and find them to not be the men they imagined. It shouldn't diminish the respect they have for their heroes, but it is the sign that they should now move out from behind them and chart their own course...except now they are on their own...there is nobody to guide them.
- jeremyrwelch 15y agoExactly. Reminds me of a favorite quote from Frank Herbert's Dune "There is probably no more terrible instant of enlightenment than the one in which you discover your father is a man--with human flesh."
- joering2 15y agowhat he should have said is that he can't comment because neither he nor his company is in making or deciding on politics. elon is a businessman after all - the government decided to retire space program but there still be a need to travel both cargo and life. he's seeing future opportunity and betting on it, which should be every wise businessman approach.
- stevear 15y agoI respectfully disagree. Being human is something we have washed away with dedicated PR staff. I feel 'numb' to public figures now, especially political and that takes something intangible away. Elon is leading us into space by setting incredible goals and asking for the best from the best. He is a leader in more than one sense. Showing emotion and character is important in leadership and I thought it was appropriate and touching.
- joedevon 15y agoHear hear
- joering2 15y agoI really dont get huge downvote on this one. I dont see anything wrong in being a businessmen like Elon. Sure he is betting on future and thats great. It was emotional moment, I get that as well. Still he is not in policy making process, which I think is good.
- Pwnguinz 15y agoSo you would rather clueless goons be in the so called "policy making process" (but let's be honest, more like a "lobby making process") than intelligent individuals that are pioneering the field which will soon need the policies? Great logic.
- marcamillion 15y agoSame here....that part really endeared him to me. He (Musk) has always been a 'semi-hero' in my eyes - immigrant, built and sold Paypal and is now running 3 companies, 2 of which will likely revolutionize civilization. How many people build 1 company that does that? He is on track to do it three times over (don't know much about the solar power endeavor, but I imagine it should be similar). It's also why I love Bezos with his 10,000 year clock. Nothing he does is small. It is people like that, that inspire me to stop trying to be 'good enough', but be great. The humanity in the hurt makes the goals seem even more 'doable'.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIt's hard to deal with the fact that heroes can be human beings too. Even Elon is just a human, with many flaws. As are Aldrin and Armstrong. And Tyson and Sagan. It's good to draw inspiration from the inspirational, but ultimately you have to be your own man regardless.
- burgerbrain 15y ago>"just a human, with many flaws. As are [snip] Sagan." Lies. How could you? :(
- InclinedPlane 15y agoSagan would be the first to tell you not to raise him to the status of godhood. As I said, take inspiration, as much as you like. But in the end you need to be your own person and stand on your own.
- neurotech1 15y agoThat's because it's somewhat inaccurate. Dr Aldrin is all for commercial space flight. Dr Buzz Aldrin is (Apparently) upset that NASA had 7 years from the decision to end the shuttle program to come up with a working replacement and they failed. The Dr Aldrin is a legend, and so is Neil Armstrong. It was Neil Armstrong and Gene Cernan who did the criticizing of SpaceX, not Dr Aldrin.
- beefman 15y agoMe too. I was also somewhat reviled by the interviewer apparently smelling money and asking him four versions of the same question at that point. As a general comment, this willingness to make a spectacle of misery seemed to come out of nowhere in 1999 with Who Wants to be a Millionaire. I'm sure classic game shows did this too, but in my lifetime this seemed to be a real turning point. '99 is also the year I threw away my TV, and I haven't regretted that.
- rdl 15y agoWhoa. Greenhouse on mars as a photo op to get people interested in space again? Elon Musk is probably the most amazing entrepreneur of the modern day. Electronic payments. Electric cars (which might prevent the next middle eastern war), and solar power. Space.
- dhughes 15y agoWhat's funny though is the Middle East is a sunny place which is perfect for generating power from solar, if electric takes over from oil it may still be in the energy business. Add to that oil is used for more than just fuel for vehicles so electric power and oil both in the Middle East, but I'm sure other sunny countries will generate their own.
- rdl 15y agoViolent places governed by dictators and religious genocidal death cults aren't my favorite places to make large capital investments in physical plant, though. It's also rather far from consumers. I'd prefer Nevada...
- Maven911 15y agoThose are some pretty strong words (religious genocidial death cults), who says they are governed by them ? And for the fighting that goes on in some of these countries, the term civil war would be more appropriate
- seclorum 15y agoBesides the fact that the US is essentially governed by its own death cult ..
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe US doesn't own Christianity. I'm pretty sure that rdl was referring to the abrahamic religions. Two of the major three and the problems associated with them are pretty much defining characteristics of that region.
- stevear 15y agoI really wish a reality show would focus on SpaceX and take us along for the ride so to speak. One way to really get kids excited about science again is bring things like this to the forefront-- show everyone it's an adventure, hard work and a ton of risk but ultimately leaving an indelible mark in history.
- rdl 15y agoYou could possibly pay for a mars (and certainly moon) mission just by doing a bunch of movies, reality shows, etc. $5b incremental cost to do a moon mission, probably, for SpaceX in a few years. $10-20b to do Mars Direct. That's not incredibly far off from a major video game or movie franchise.
- joering2 15y agowhere are you getting your numbers from. I am not an accountant for NASA but they sound extremely low!
- rdl 15y agoZubrin, Mars Direct. He estimated $10-15b to do it, and if you were SpaceX, you could probably do it for less. The key to making Mars cheap is to do multiple launches -- first launch is a fuel production facility (automated) which uses Mars resources to make fuel and oxygen, then housing, then a return vehicle. Launch the crew once everything is set up, in a vehicle which can't return on its own -- they use the stuff already on Mars to live and return. I mostly just made up the moon number, based on it being a whole lot easier than Mars. I think you could probably do a recreation of Apollo pretty cheaply (a quick flight to the moon, simple landing, etc.). Certainly a trip to the moon without landing wouldn't be THAT hard once you had a rocket able to escape from earth gravity (maybe 2x as hard as launching to GEO?). You could maybe do it with a Falcon 9 in a single launch, so that's about $2b. It's less fun if you don't land, though.
- edge17 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_program#Program_costs_and_cancellation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_program#Program_costs_an... pretty cheap when you put it next to a bank bailout
- sethbannon 15y agoElon is a testament to dreaming big and achieving. Truly inspiring stuff.
- mukaiji 15y agoFor Elon: "Here's to the Crazy Ones. The misfits. The rebels. The trouble-makers. The round pegs in the square holes. The ones who see things differently. They're not fond of rules, and they have no respect for the status-quo. You can quote them, disagree with them, glorify, or vilify them. About the only thing you can't do is ignore them. Because they change things. They push the human race forward. And while some may see them as the crazy ones, we see genius. Because the people who are crazy enough to think they can change the world - are the ones who DO!"
- reneherse 15y agoWhat an awesome human being. (And a thoroughly sleep deprived one, in some of those segments, I am certain.) Truly inspiring.
- JDulin 15y agoThe lack of government funding for a space exploration program makes me as sad and angry as anyone. However, I find Neil Armstrong and Gene Cernan's argument against commercialized space-flight lame. They say it would be less safe than a NASA program and that "To be without carriage to low Earth orbit and with no human exploration capability to go beyond Earth orbit for an indeterminate time into the future, destines our nation to become one of second- or even third-rate stature..." Note though that some of their argument was directed at the cancellation of NASA's planned moon missions. With that in mind, let's consider the shuttle program. In 135 missions, it had an abysmal safety record that claimed the lives of 14 astronauts, making it the deadliest spaceflight program in history. It's budget cost $196 billion dollars over the craft's lifetime instead of the estimated $43 billion (adjusted for inflation), while making around half of the promised flights. The shuttle was an important (for both good and bad) craft that helped accomplish great things, like build the ISS and Hubble space telescope. But nationalist pride shouldn't make us blind to the fact that NASA's last program probably set progress in spaceflight backwards, or at least slowed it, and never attempted to leave low-Earth orbit. Those astronauts may not like it, but Elon Musk has a clearer vision and more ambition than NASA (or the politicians) have had for a very long time.
- ADent 15y ago>The lack of government funding for a space exploration program makes me as sad and angry as anyone Lack of funding??? NASA gets 17 Billion a year and typically around 10 billion is for manned space flight - 2011 has 9 billion. How much more does NASA need?
- Synthetase 15y agoThe United States Federal Budget is $3.8 trillion dollars. The Apollo program has been the best taxpayer expenditure dollar for dollar of any government program. Computers, fuel cells, CNC machines,... We are tragically underinvesting in space.
- cocolos 15y agoI refer you to this: http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/137277/neil-degrasse-tyson/the-case-for-space http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/137277/neil-degrasse-...
- robomartin 15y agoIt is really unfortunate that Aldrin and Armstrong seem so critical of efforts like SpaceX. Both of these men are very intelligent and highly accomplished. That said, every transition in thinking and technology has always found opposition from those deeply invested in what is about to fade away. I would hope that, in this case at least, things start to change as further proof of the merits of private enterprise is produced. Elon, if you are reading this, know that you have something pulling for you that Aldrin and Armstrong will never have: The next generation. My kids want to be like their mother and father (who are scientists) and we make it a point to highlight people such as yourself as role models. They want to be just like you. And so will countless others.
- hinathan 15y agoAldrin and Armstrong are NASA astronauts. They spent the best years of their lives wholly bought into the centrally-funded prime-contractor system. They were at the absolute apex of that system, and they and a very small handful of astronauts reaped the fame and opportunity that enormous Apollo (400k people according to wikipedia) program. SpaceX is doing orbital missions with around 1000 people. This means cheaper flights which means more flights. It's going to lead to the same democratization of access that the computing and network revolutions brought, pulling these technologies out of enormous institutions and dramatically dropping costs.
- mkn 15y agoAfter seeing that clip, I wondered how Cernan and Armstrong could have said the things they said and, eventually, how they could even feel qualified to comment. I think the answer to both questions is related. Armstrong and Cernan are just the Spam in the can. They're glorified pilots. As such, they are extensions of the PR arm of NASA and the entrenched aerospace industries. I've phrased that a little harshly, but not by much. Certainly, as trained monkeys go, they are marvelously trained. And not just any monkey could be trained to perform as they did in their, and I emphasize, highly specialized and limited roles within the space program. But, when we see a well-trained dog, the credit goes to the master. If Armstrong and Cernan were rocket designers, if they had captained a startup that created a new launch vehicle, then I could take their statements seriously. If they were systems integrators, if they were manufacturing engineers, if they were anything other than good pilots, then they might have something useful to add to the discussion on a national level. Until then, all I want to hear from them is how beautiful the Earth looks from space, how fun it is to play golf on the Moon, and various other fun facts about events that took place 40+ years ago. I feel awful trying to cut these men down, trying to knock them back into place. However, the truly shameful thing is that they've used their legacy to usurp beyond their areas of expertise. I console myself that the bounds over which they've stepped are generous bounds, the bounds of heroes, and it takes a truly cataclysmic level of folly to behave as they have done. It would take nothing less than the legendary ego of a pilot. Cernan and Armstrong, rest on your laurels, and get out of the way of people who are doing.
- shingen 15y agoNobody deserves it more than Elon. After PayPal the guy could have just done what so many others do, lay down and casually invest, chill on a beach, and let others do the hard work. Instead he's killing himself running multiple ground breaking companies, directly challenging near government monopolies in GM / Ford / Boeing / Lockheed (protected by massive lobbying, deep political ties going back decades, and regulation designed to protect them from competition). If America could get a few more Elon Musks, we might start to get our mojo back. Hey there immigration policy.
- smeg 15y agoI remember watching another video about the Falcon Heavy Rocket, and how it was designed with a large number of small rockets cones at the bottom, so a certain number can die yet the whole thing can still reach orbit. I just seemed so elegant and efficient, the kind of thing that could only have come from the mind of private industry that is so mindful of cost and efficiency, unlike the government which only build monstrosities at ridiculous expense (to the taxpayer).
- ballooney 15y agoQuite incorrect. If we rewind to the golden age in the 60s, the US's Saturn V had 5 F-1 engines on the first stage. The UK's Black Arrow had 8 identical engines in 4 pairs. Russia's Soyuz has 20. Similarly, if you ask anyone at SpaceX they would tell you it's difficult to underestimate how much they owe to the old grey-beards from NASA who are still around and who helped them get up to speed quickly, avoiding many hundreds of thousands, indeed millions of dollars of blind alleys and reinventing the wheel. SpaceX is a wonderful example of good engineers - old nasa ones and fresh graduates, united by a common mindset, with enlightened (for which private is often but not strictly a prerequisite) management. That's where they succeed, I think. They look at where they are now, where they want to be, and keep the string taught between the two. But don't think SpaceX could have done this in a vacuum (hohoho). Of the several SpaceXers I've met, including Elon Musk himself back when he had time to give talks at SEDS conferences, none would make such a claim, certainly.
- htf 15y agoSpaceX's launch prices are already much lower than its competitors. Things will become even more interesting in a few years when SpaceX starts reusing its rockets. Launching stuff to orbit will become so cheap, it's difficult to fully comprehend the impact SpaceX will have. The imagination runs wild. Massive spaceships anyone?
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThere are several "big things" that will happen. First, there will start to be a lot more people going into space. Second, there will start to be significant off-Earth infrastructure. Not just satellites, the GPS system, that sort of thing, but meta-infrastructure. Space stations where people do actual work (instead of just research). Systems of transportation. Fuel depots. Repair facilities. Etc. Instead of mounting expeditions to the Moon or Mars or asteroids we will undertake commuter trips. A regularly scheduled vehicle will ferry crew up to an Earth orbit station. There they will travel in a craft that never touches the surface of a planet from that station to another station in orbit of the Moon and they'll take yet another ferry ride down to a lunar colony. Third, as a consequence of all of this there will start to be a significant effectively permanent off-Earth population and off-Earth economy. Fourth, as an additional side effect of so much activity significant effort will be spent tackling the medical and other problems of living in space for long periods of time. And then all of this snowballs until sooner than you realize it there are kids going to college who never knew a time when mankind didn't have cities in orbit, on the Moon, on Mars, etc.
- reason 15y agoThis guy is my hero, more so than any entrepreneur out there. What always fascinates me about Elon's story is his ability to self-teach himself the subjects he needs to effectively compete in an industry. He literally taught himself rocket science. I can barely finish a book on business.
- brandall10 15y agoSame here... when people ask "where will the next Steve Jobs come from" - my attitude he's already amongst us, and his goals are loftier and perhaps more socially pragmatic. Keep in mind the man wants see Mars in his lifetime, taken in that perspective learning rocket science is a pretty small feat. Creating SpaceX is the first step to that goal, and leaving anything on the table - ie. just being a CEO/leader, and not being able to work hand-in-hand with the engineers/scientists he has under employ is a risk. To me, the key takeaway is if you want something bad enough the seemingly difficult becomes doable.
- krschultz 15y agoI don't disagree with your sentiment at all, but I think in this case it's not a big leap from where he was. Elon Musk has a Physics degree. All the principles are there - math, science, etc. 'Rocket science' is just domain specific knowledge in that arena. For a manager of rocket scientists, that's all he needs. Although he got his money programming code at Paypal, he was a heck of a lot closer to an aerospace engineering background than your average web startup founder today.
- kmfrk 15y agoNo one can teach themselves business. You just fake it, until you make it. :)
- avar 15y agoIt refuses to play on the CBS website for some reason so I've downloaded the torrent, their adverts work just fine though, but not the actual video.
- rglover 15y agoI had no idea that Neil Armstrong and other veteran astronauts are against Musk and SpaceX. Other than being in the government's back pocket, I can't think of a reason why people who have been in space would not support going back (putting safety aside, which was considerably the same thing back in NASA's early days).
- CrankyPants 15y agoThey aren't. They're just opposed to terminating a functioning program before we have a better one ready to go.
- mckoss 15y agoThis was a really great episode of 60 Minutes - also see the in-depth story on face blindness; it's an excellent demonstration of a mysterious capacity of (most) people's ability to recognize faces. BTW - 60 Minutes should be retitled "40 Minutes" - from the time codes on my DVR I find that the Musk story was 15 minutes, and the face blindness story was 25 minutes. Is it any wonder people would rather consume video online (rather than watch 20 minutes of Cialis ads).
- pkrumins 15y agoAnyone knows why these "60 minutes" shows are actually just 15-20 minute shows? Is it 60 mins on TV and just 15-20 on the internet?
- learc83 15y agoBecause that was just one segment of the show. The other part of that episode was on "face blindness."
- chauzer 15y agoElon Musk is amazing. That was a great piece on what SpaceX is doing. Here's an episode of Risk Takers on Bloomberg for Elon Musk: http://www.bloomberg.com/video/73460184/ http://www.bloomberg.com/video/73460184/ Great episode as well.