5 ms·
>The article assumes the ends never justify the means, and it seems to me fairly naive to have that position It's pretty naive to assume that you and your fami
by coldtea 3y ago
>The article assumes the ends never justify the means, and it seems to me fairly naive to have that position
It's pretty naive to assume that you and your family would be on the "enjoying the ends" side of the equation as opposed to the "sacrificed as means" side.
A lot of people, from Robespiere to USSR party officials found out the hard way.
Not to mention that the kind of types who opt "for the ends, the means be damned" seldom show much restraint.
Or the problem of who choses those ends, for whose benefit, and who did they ask?
>A police who shoots a knife wielding attacker in the leg is clearly a means that justify the ends for example. The only difference between that and Hitler is 1) the scale and 2) that Hitler was factually wrong about the universe.
No, the difference between that and Hitler is one of quality, not scale.
For starters, shooting the leg of 10 million people is not the same as executing 10 million people. Even as physical bodily damage is way less. I'd chose to be shot in the leg over being gassed any day of the week.
And it's even less "the same" if the ones who shot in the leg were knife wielding attackers and you did it to stop them, as opposed to them having done nothing.
As for being "factually wrong", Hitler could just as well be equally vicious while being factually correct. Saying "I know Jews are not pulling the strings, but I want to blame and exterminate them anyway because I want to use them as scapegoats" would be factually correct, yet the deeds would be no less evil.
- fluoridation 3y agoI think what the GP was getting at is that they're both actions that are (in the mind of the person executing the action in question) necessary to achieve the desired effect. If you think that it is absolutely necessary to stop the knife-wielding attacker then you'll take any action necessary to do so. That shooting him in the leg was enough doesn't mean you wouldn't have gone further. If you think there's an international Jewish conspiracy that must be stopped you'll also take any action necessary to do so. The difference in scale is, I think, irrelevant. Under no circumstances would someone need to kill millions of people to stop a single stabber. At that point you're arguing the analogy, not the argument.
- coldtea 3y ago>The difference in scale is, I think, irrelevant. Under no circumstances would someone need to kill millions of people to stop a single stabber. At that point you're arguing the analogy, not the argument. The argument is made in the form of an analogy though. And what's more the parent insists that the main difference is "scale". I don't think the main difference is scale. I think the difference is one is a legitimate action in defense, and the other is not. That's objectively so, regarless of if Hitler believed in a conspiracy or not. And even if he did legitimately believe in a Jewish conspiracy, still killing non-participating Jews (like babies and regular folk) would not be in defence even then, it would be proactive. One could legitimately believe a whole class of people are in a vast conspiracy, and still find killing them that way abhorent and not wanting to do it. That would be like the cop killing a guy who thinks might attack someone with a knife in the future, or who thinks their kid will.
- boxed 3y ago[flagged]
- c22 3y agoWhat exactly makes an action a "legitimate action in defense?" John T Williams had a knife, but I'm not sure his killing was legitimate.
- coldtea 3y ago(a) It being in defence (b) The force used being proportionate to the danger In that case John wasn't attacking anyone at the monent, so no defence. The 4 shots are also way disrpoportionate to the non-danger. And they came within 5 seconds of ordering to drop his knife, which again is not enough time to react (also assuming he could hear it). In this case the shooting is more of an illegitimate action of offense. Note that police doesn't just do actions for defence, but also e.g. to enforce some law. But the shooting, 4 times, lethally, of someone away from you, carrying a knife, within 5 seconds of you having told them to drop it, is not justified even under this context. At least it wouldn't be acceptable in any civilized country.
- watwut 3y ago> Hitler could just as well be equally vicious while being factually correct I think that it would be impossible for him to become equally powerful if he did not lied however.
- coldtea 3y agoProbably, but "factually correct" here is with regard to his inner beliefs, not if he said truth of lies. After all every politician lies.
- watwut 3y agoHitler lied including with "regard to his inner beliefs". He told lies he knew full well were lies. He also contradicted himself quite a lot, directly, which just one more data point towards "he knew he was lying". He gave instructions to people under him that amounted to "lie about this thing, because it is strategical". > After all every politician lies. There are massive differences in how much politicians lies. Some of them lie more, others less. There are massive differences in topics politicians lie about. Lying about liking a musical piece for example is not the same as lying about planned policies.
- boxed 3y ago> As for being "factually wrong", Hitler could just as well be equally vicious while being factually correct. Saying "I know Jews are not pulling the strings, but I want to blame and exterminate them anyway because I want to use them as scapegoats" would be factually correct, yet the deeds would be no less evil. That's a better point. One would have to dig deeper in order to find the factually incorrect idea in this scenario. It's all about the goal. If the goal was to improve Germany this stance you cited would clearly make him again incorrect about the facts, as the extermination of the Jews hurt Germany. If the goal was to gobble up power and riches for himself and his cronies, then he was factually incorrect about how powerful the allies were, as that clearly backfired pretty damn badly on him. I don't see how you can get to any position where Hitler isn't monstrously wrong about something very fundamental. You can be as cynical as you'd like, but at the end he killed himself in a bunker. Clearly that was not his goal!
- the_af 3y agoBut even if Hitler hadn't underestimated the Soviet Union, or if exterminating the Jews had been an actual way to improve Germany, the Holocaust still would have been an evil act.
- boxed 3y agoI mean.. sure. He did try other solutions too like deporting them all. Just that no country would take them. But that's another story.
- developer93 3y agoSo... that's OK then..?
- boxed 3y agoNope. But I think we should all be aware that the anti-semitism was super high at the time in surrounding countries too, that's why he couldn't deport them.