8 ms·
Sometimes i think one of the biggest hurdles to environmentalism is greens insisting on wishful, return to edan, thinking instead of practical solution. Convin
by bawolff 3y ago
Sometimes i think one of the biggest hurdles to environmentalism is greens insisting on wishful, return to edan, thinking instead of practical solution.
Convincing everyone in the world to do a massive cultural change involving large standard of living decreases is not happening except at the point of a literal gun. The world can't afford to wait for impractical solutions.
- panick21_ 3y agoThe most efficent conversion from fossil to green happen in France and it had nothing to do with envoirmentalism. In fact envorionmentalism for most of the 20th century did more to prevent replacment of fossil fuel then it did to reduce it.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoExpecting technology to solve all our problems is just as wishful.
- sneak 3y agoEveryone who made it out of childhood thanks to antibiotics and vaccines should probably reject takes like this. Technology has solved the vast majority of all of the major problems of human beings throughout all of human civilization. Agriculture is technology. Writing is technology. Inks and paper are technology. Pharmaceuticals are technology. Heart surgery is technology. The modern industrial supply chain is technology. Transportation is technology. Seatbelts and blood typing to enable blood transfusions - technology. It is theoretically possible that technology could solve the problem of death itself. To make claims to the contrary, which would be extraordinary, something a great deal more substantial than a handwavey dismissal is required.
- mdiesel 3y agoSure, we now survive childhood based on vaccines, but remember that there was a time between the disease appearing and the vaccine being developed, and in that time we used simpler methods to try survive. The issue is not what the world will be like in 200 years when the climate crisis is solved, it's how we get there. Tech takes decades to research, design, and develop; we need ways to limit the damage that can be implemented in years to limit the effects we'll see in our lifetimes. I agree tech will be the end solution, but continuing to burn at current rates while we wait for that is going to cause, or already is causing, massive problems.
- tticvs 3y ago> Sure, we now survive childhood based on vaccines, but remember that there was a time between the disease appearing and the vaccine being developed, and in that time we used simpler methods to try survive. 50% of children died before their 5th birthday
- rini17 3y agoI don't think anyone is talking here about going without antibiotics or modern agriculture. More like curbing excess production of concrete (making construction more sustainable) and metals (reducing automobilism and other wasteful means of transport).
- tchaffee 3y agoThe revolutions or sometimes evolutions resulting in democrat nations with regulated market based economies are what allowed the rapid pace of innovating you are praising. Those revolutions were radical social changes.
- goodpoint 3y agoNothing in your post rebukes the claim made by the parent.
- reacharavindh 3y agoIMO, we need both - people screaming out loud to reduce consumption and rooting for truly green technologies that create a revolution. While some silent practical warriors change the status quo one kg of CO2 at a time until those revolutionary changes kick in. I think no sensible person would protest a more sustainable solution than the current fossil burning tech even if it is not 100% renewable.
- mschuster91 3y ago> IMO, we need both - people screaming out loud to reduce consumption and rooting for truly green technologies that create a revolution. Nuclear fusion for energy generation purposes has been promised for, what, 60 years now? Hoping for that to eventually succeed will only lead to one thing: it won't work out and whoops, suddenly humanity is out of options because everyone had refused to change in the hope for a miracle. It is more sensible to prepare for the worst case now.
- bawolff 3y agoFortunately nuclear fisson technology has been here for a while and solves most of the immediate problems we have. Too bad we barely used it.
- Tade0 3y agoWe barely used it because it's a textbook case of overpromising and underdelivering. A nuclear project on average has a probability of going over time and budget somewhere between an IT project and organizing the Olympics. These are not great odds, especially that renewables are on the other end of the same scale.
- panick21_ 3y agoWho promied what exactly. One president onetime said it was gone be "to cheap to meter" so now it can ne er be used because of "overpromise". Who gives a shit? It delivers plent. And if we actually developed fission technology beyond the 1970 we could do so so much more. Nuclear projects in Western nations done as low priority "keep the industry alive" individual projects are often late. But historically when large amount of investment is made, you get very large amount of energy quickly. Lets not pretend that every renewable project is perfectly on time on budget either. Its just that those are smaller and on project being late isn't news worthy. India just finished reactors very cheaply. UAE and South Korea just showed an amazing buildout of nuclear that could be scaled to much larger easly. Finlands project took a while and was expensive but now they have great reactor that produces lots of power for the next 80 years or more. Frnace literally made its grid green in 20 years and they have had cheap energy since. Fission is amazing, fusion is totally unneeded. Not using fission more is one of the dumbest things humanity ever did.
- pjerem 3y agoNo, it’s more a narrative issue than anything else. Nobody says we should go back to Stone Age but we should unleash our narratives of what is a nice future. Living in a world where everyone is eating healthy local food, where you live longer because it’s safe to use your bicycle and hard to use the car. Living in a world where you can walk everyday because there are trees to give you their shadows. Living in a world where work is meaningful. For me that’s a bright future. Nobody says we have to abandon all of our technological and cultural advances but that we have to prefer some over others. Like my grandfather said, plant 2 trees when you build your home and you’ll never need air conditioning. His idea wasn’t that you should ban A/C but rather that you can use it way more efficiently just by adding some shadow. That’s the world we must live in now : consuming energy is ok but not if it is a countermeasure to our own stupid decisions. It’s the same with cars. Ok they are nice sometimes. But they are stupid if we use them to go in a far office with the same computer you have at home. We don’t need to go back to Stone Age but we need to dream of a future where we don’t use the energy for stupid things. And this implies being able to see what is stupid and who have interest in keeping a given stupid thing, stupid.
- panick21_ 3y agoWhile I geneally agree. There are tons of degrowth advocates who go way further with this way of thinking.
- bawolff 3y ago> Living in a world where everyone is eating healthy local food, where you live longer because it’s safe to use your bicycle and hard to use the car. Living in a world where you can walk everyday because there are trees to give you their shadows. Living in a world where work is meaningful. For me that’s a bright future. That sounds nice and all (although as a canadian, too much heat due to lack of shade is definitely not the issue around here ;) ). I'd even go as far as to say that those types of life style changes have an important part to play. However, even if implemented to the fullest extent possible, i don't really think it solves the greenhouse gas problem by itself or even comes close.
- 3y ago
- mschuster91 3y ago> Convincing everyone in the world to do a massive cultural change involving large standard of living decreases is not happening except at the point of a literal gun. ...or when you have millions of people on the Western borders fleeing from climate change and its side effects (we're already seeing just how cruel politicans behave towards the relatively small amount of people at the borders currently - imagine how the situation will look like with just 10x as many!), or entire of our states being devastated by wildfires, hurricanes or tornadoes. Probably it's going to take the latter until politicians wake up, when the situation is undeniable even to the hardest MAGAts and other deniers. The key thing is: humanity is using more resources (no matter if you're talking about food, drinkable water or fuel) than nature can regenerate, each year. We are currently digging into reserves that took (in case of groundwater) sometimes many millennia to create. > The world can't afford to wait for impractical solutions. It can't afford doing nothing, because continuing as-is without managing sensible degrowth may work out for our generations, but the ones born after 2010? They're fucked.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoNature bats last, and humanity is the ball.