4 ms·
AI systems are vastly better than humans at a wide variety of tasks. Better at handwriting recognition, better at scheduling, better at playing games, better at
by adastra22 3y ago
AI systems are vastly better than humans at a wide variety of tasks. Better at handwriting recognition, better at scheduling, better at playing games, better at speech recognition and transcription, etc.
- cypress66 3y agoI am skeptical on many of those. Speech recognition is not even close to human level. Whisper, and whatever Google uses will make a lot of mistakes on audio files that are trivial to any native speaker.
- adastra22 3y agoIn actual tests it is beyond human level. Humans actually mishear about 1 in 20 words during transcription tests; whisper does better.
- emodendroket 3y agoBut we don’t solely rely on how well we hear since we have knowledge that allows us to correct for poor hearing based on what is being said rather than forging ahead with a nonsense transcription. Machine transcription is definitely faster and cheaper but the end product isn’t “better,” and anyone who has read it can attest to that.
- ben_w 3y ago> But we don’t solely rely on how well we hear since we have knowledge that allows us to correct for poor hearing based on what is being said rather than forging ahead with a nonsense transcription. Good voice transcription AI already do that too; that's why they work best if they know which language they're operating in, as that means they can use the language to create a model of the most likely words. I think the most recent WWDC from Apple even has a video about adding custom vocabulary for their speech engine to pick up on that covered some details in this exact topic, though I can't search right now.
- emodendroket 3y agoUndoubtedly so but I have yet to see one that doesn't make mistakes a human would be unlikely to. It is not an easy capability to reproduce and wouldn't have been my first choice if I wanted to talk about things it can do better than people.
- ben_w 3y ago> Undoubtedly so but I have yet to see one that doesn't make mistakes a human would be unlikely to. Absolutely, AI is very rarely human in its failure modes, and often has novel and exciting failure modes instead. But, on average… or so the marketing claims… it makes fewer mistakes. For a while, it was possible to improve upon super-human chess AI by pairing them with a human; the combination was called a centaur. Eventually the AI got too good even for that as they stopped making the sorts of mistakes humans could spot, but in the meantime, even though they were superhuman, they had failure modes that we could help out with.
- emodendroket 3y agoAssuming the intended audience is also humans, "exciting" errors seem worse in this instance, so I find it hard to credit these marketing claims.
- ben_w 3y agoSeem worse, sure. If it is or not, depends on the specific use of the transcription. Consider "I went to Lenny's" being transcribed wrong by a human as "I went to Denny's" or by an AI as "Ivan to Lenny's". Both are wrong, but if you get a human to check, we can be oblivious to the human mistake for the same reason it was made in the first place plus the effect where seeing text alters our perception of what we hear; the AI error being inhuman means we can spot it when the human error is imperceptible.
- cypress66 3y agoWell, those "actual tests" clearly don't reflect reality. This is obvious if you actually use whisper.
- oldandtired 3y agoThe question to ask is why? The answer is that we have programmed these systems to do what we require. They cannot exceed but they fail becasue of errors that we have placed in these systems. All of the tasks that you have mentioned have been programmed that way. It has taken human ingenuity to work out how to do this programming. The end result is a machine (non-sentient, non-intelligent) that is doing what we require. If you look at game playing, a system was created to play Go and won and yet that same system fails to win against humans under many circumstances. The literature is there, yet not publicised for all the world to see. A result of keeping the hype in play. If you look at speech recognition, these systems still fail when we humans work against them and yet, we humans still recognise what the machines fail at. Just keep in mind that a tractor can move a greater amount of material than a human can, but it is still only a tool. A plane can travel faster and fly higher that a human can, but it is still only a tool. We use these systems to augment our abilities and yet they are all limited in so many ways that we are not. The upshot is that we can do amazing things with the things we create, but none of those things exist without us and all those things fail without us.
- ben_w 3y ago> All of the tasks that you have mentioned have been programmed that way. It has taken human ingenuity to work out how to do this programming. The successful Go AI were programmed to learn; we still can't program a decent Go AI with rules humans come up with. > The literature is there Do you have a link? Two Minute Papers just had a video about an AI systematic finding ways to confound other AI, but I thought we'd passed the point where the best Go AI could be so manipulated by humans…
- oldandtired 3y agoYour example of the Go AI being programmed to learn is not all that accurate for what has been achieved here. I didn't keep the link for the discussion on the confounding of the Go AI system. What the discussion covered though was that there were simple Go configurations that the GO AI failed abysmally on when playing a human - it didn't learn here. I have spent forty years dealing with all sorts of computer systems - designing, building, maintaining, repairing, redesigning and rebuilding. One thing I have learnt over that time is that none of the systems ever built has been error free in terms of the logic entailed within them. All to often, I have seen systems that were used to make decisions with and those using them assuming that the outputs were correct or reasonable. Yet on investigation, the logic entailed in them was completely rubbish. We make assumptions and often we do not carefully check that those assumptions are actually real. I don't trust anything I write until I have gone over it with a fine tooth comb and then I will try to document all my assumptions and this usually shows up various logic errors or conditions that I didn't think about. I don't see this happening much out in the real world.