11 ms·
Cosmological time dilation in the early Universe
- tines 3y agoHow can one measure the speed of things through time relative to things in their past or future? Can't we only measure the speed of things through time relative to other things that coexist at the same time? I read the article but couldn't make sense of it.
- foota 3y agoI think they're looking at parts of the universe that are very old, and so they can watch it move more slowly.
- yathaid 3y ago> Lewis explained that the brightening and fading of quasar light, known as their variability is like the stock mark, unpredictable on the surface but with statistical properties that allow it to be modelled over time. This variability can be used like the ticking of a cosmic clock. It was this understanding and the complex quasar firework display from 190 of these feeding supermassive black holes that allowed the team to spot time dilation when the universe was just 1.5 billion years old, less than 10% of its current age.
- mattashii 3y ago> when the universe was just 1.5 billion years old, less than 10% of its current age. Which universe are they talking about? Most sources I know of cite 13.78 billion years for our universe, and the quoted 1.5 billion years is definitely over 10% of that.
- colechristensen 3y agoThink of looking at someone running across the street and then looking through a telescope at someone running far away. The person far away would be in the past because of whatever amount of distance light had to travel. The person far away would seem to be running in slow motion. Instead of whatever tiny fraction of a second your telescope would enable you to look into the past, the telescopes looking at whole-ass galaxies in the early universe that appear to be "running slower".
- rstuart4133 3y ago> Can't we only measure the speed of things through time relative to other things that coexist at the same time? They weren't using speed. They were watching how fast a clock ticked back then, the clock being a quasar. The article was light on the details, but the difficulty seemed to be that quasar's aren't reliable clocks, so they needed to develop a statistical model to measure the ticking accurately. Developing the model was actual science being reported on. It happened to agree with Einstein's predictions. But even if they were using speed, gravity doesn't slow down light. It redshift's it. So there is something you could compare your speed to back then. Finally, we are comparing how fast time ticks for us now versus how fast a quasar ticked back then. I don't know if the quasar it still around, but if it is it's probably a very different beast now. In any case we are comparing two things that don't exist at the same time. In fact, my guess is it's downright difficult compare yourself to something that exists at the same time, because the speed of light is finite. That means by the time you receive the measurement, whatever you've measured has moved on.
- scandum 3y agoMy main take away from the article was that we, apparently, need a time traveler to confirm/disprove Einstein's theory.
- ww520 3y agoBased on the article and my guesses, here's how they measured time on the past. When we look at things far away from us, we're seeing their state in the past. Quasars that are 10 billion light years away took 10 billion years for their light to reach us, so right now we are seeing their images 10 billion years ago. Quasar is bright light powered by gas spiraling at a high velocity into a black hole. When things revolving around a black hole, the light given out varies. The light of the gas spinning behind the black hole is blocked and the light is shown again when the gas spinning on the side of the black hole facing us. When we're looking at it, it kind of blinks periodically in constant rate. The blinking rate can serve as clock ticks. The people of the paper figure out a way to compute the blinking rate of the quasars statistically. They look at hundreds of quasars at 12 billion light years away, i.e. looking at their state 12 billion years ago. Compute their blinking rate from twenty years of telescope observation. Compare that to the quasars close to us. They found that the far away quasars blink 5 times slower, i.e. they're blinking 5 times slower 12 billion years ago. The universe is about 13.7 billion years old, so the conclusion is that time ran slower at the early age. It actually fits the prediction from Einstein's general relativity.
- pdonis 3y agoWhat they are measuring is the apparent "speed" of processes back then. But that apparent speed is an effect of the redshift. It does not mean that clocks were actually running slower back then. The article's description is seriously misleading.
- irjustin 3y agoTo be specific it's the "average time across all space" ran more slowly, which is sort of a weird thing to say, but I'll go with it. Time runs more slower near massive objects like black holes. Since the average density of the universe when it was young was way higher, then yes on average time ran more slowly. But it's also a little weird to say because you go back far enough there's no "low density" patch so you're actually comparing it to something that doesn't exist quite yet, hence a bit weird?
- bmitc 3y ago> Time runs more slower near massive objects like black holes. Do you mean proper time or time as seen by an outside observer?
- irjustin 3y agoOriginally, I meant it as - as seen from an outside observer. I'm talking out of my pay grade now, but it also could be for proper time if you started away from the black hole and fell towards it then compared it from your start and end? Probably unnecessarily complex for this discussion though.
- IntrepidWorm 3y agoAlso punching above my weight class here: isn't observation a function of time as well though, so a local observer would notice no difference in their perception of the passage of time? It's only across distance that the perception of time would change per relativity, so obseevation of self would remain the same while observation of distant objects would appear to experience time faster, while an outside observer would perceive their own time constant and that of the infalling observer to slow through time.
- layer8 3y agoProper time always runs at 1 second per second. It’s only when you compare it to someone else's proper time that you can get a difference.
- ggm 3y agoWithout being an astrophysicist I think critique of this paper is impossible. So I ask any astrophysicists here, to explain why this is not an observer-effect, or a consequence of the extreme time and distance the signal has gone through, if you like a time effect analogous to red shift. Anything about observations made at this distance in both space and time has me think it should always be "in rats"
- boomboomsubban 3y agoAlso not an astrophysicist, but wouldn't we be able to work the consequence of the distance traveled into the prediction made before the experiment? There is a possibility that our understanding of what effect the distance would have on the readings, but as long as you don't print things like it "confirms time ran slower" there's no real problem...
- ggm 3y agoYes. I am sure the paper makes adjustments, error corrections. They're good scientists. But I'm a layperson. So, I guess the problems are headlines. Because the headline didn't say confirm, but it states positively Time ran slowly Outside of a dog, a cigar is a mans best friend. Inside of a dog, it's too dark to see. Inside of a slowly running time period, a second is still a second, surely? So I ask myself how inside the universe, we can make assertions about the relative speed a second "is" but remain inside the same system. The implications some other attribute of observed reality can remain unchanged, and confirm the "duration" of a second was different then, to now, based on observations made solely within this universe.. I'm struggling.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI was thinking the same thing. This explanation if right makes some sense: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37245317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37245317 Basically is the same “time goes more slowly” as a atomic clock that is not on a jet plane
- 22c 3y ago
- nielsbot 3y agoIt's hard to wrap your mind around the fact that time and space everywhere are whimsical and warped... there are no straight lines in nature and every point in space and time are locally doing their own thing... the universe just calculates everything everywhere all at once and there's no way to fit it into human comprehension.
- electric_mayhem 3y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=q2nNzNo_Xps https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=q2nNzNo_Xps
- backtoyoujim 3y agoIt's the idea that the wave function of reality doesn't collapse until it is observed ?
- eru 3y ago> The universe just calculates everything everywhere all at once and there's no way to fit it into human comprehension. Because the speed of light is finite, the universe wouldn't have to calculate everything everywhere all at once. If the calculations around Alpha Centauri stopped updating for a while for a few months, and then caught up quickly, we wouldn't notice, because it's a few light years away. See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon
- tghoiu4234234 3y agoau contraire. nature loves 'straight lines' (just on non-euclidean manifolds).
- assbuttbuttass 3y agoSlower relative to what?
- jezze 3y agoYeah good question. And what is the current tick rate?
- db48x 3y agoOne second per second at sea level, but slightly faster than that in orbit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ko27 3y agoSlower relative to the low density universe average today, which is pretty close to the time we experience on Earth.
- farhanhubble 3y agoDumb question perhaps but if the "1.5 billion years" is in today's time ticks what's the equivalent age of the universe?
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoIt’s simultaneously relative to any unit of 1
- qingcharles 3y agoI guess that really means the age of the universe is some sort of unknowable number.
- intotheabyss 3y agoOr the age of the universe is different for all observers.
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoHow do you describe a story without a beginning or end?
- ta8645 3y agoThe singer Katie Melua had to update her song with the correct answer after being challenged by the scientifically minded [1]. Given this new insight, she might need a new version once again. [1] https://youtu.be/iXhxDDY1GYI https://youtu.be/iXhxDDY1GYI
- irrational 3y agoSo, will time speed up the closer we get to the heat death of the universe?
- indigodaddy 3y agoLogically based on this evidence you’d have to assume so, yes?
- Ekaros 3y agoOr is it just less slowed down?
- yakorevivan 3y ago[dead]
- mongol 3y agoWhat kind of "clocks" existed in the early universe? Can we for example compare the half life of some isotopes between then and now and say something about how they differed?
- eisvogel 3y ago...if you believe in an early, non-eternal universe. Tired Light will be vindicated! Repent!
- adrian_b 3y agoFree research paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04053 https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04053
- DisjointedHunt 3y agoIsn't all of this explained by the fact that we have a supermassive black hole at the middle of the galaxy? We perceive distant time to run slow because we're falling into a black hole. This also explains a lot of the expansion observations . . .they're not moving away from each other . . .our local perspective is shifting so that the ENTIRE outside universe seems to be doing that.
- lodovic 3y agoThat is a scary thought ..
- eru 3y ago> Isn't all of this explained by the fact that we have a supermassive black hole at the middle of the galaxy? No. > We perceive distant time to run slow because we're falling into a black hole. We aren't falling into a black hole. > This also explains a lot of the expansion observations . . .they're not moving away from each other . . .our local perspective is shifting so that the ENTIRE outside universe seems to be doing that. The way our local perspective would need to be shifting for that to happen is much more complicated and unrelated to anything else, than the expansion hypothesis. We can check the predictions of the accepted theories of gravity with things like gravitational lensing and flying very precise clocks very fast under different strengths of gravity etc. That accepted theory does not predict what you are suggesting for our local perspective. Of course, we can categorically exclude a new effect like what you describe, just like we can't exclude Russell's teapot. But there's no evidence for it, and it doesn't allow us to make new predictions.
- DisjointedHunt 3y agoThis is the attitude that just makes the whole field a piece of shit to engage with. "No" - Try writing an explanation. Words are free. If you've chosen to engage with negative cynicism and consider yourself an expert in the field, you have a duty to explain your damned position instead of a "no" "We aren't falling into a black hole" - You say this with what level of certainty? Are gravitational effects of the galactic center so insignificant at our location? The images of galaxies would suggest otherwise. "Accepted theory" can kiss my ass for all its worth. If we went with accepted theory through history, i don't have to tell you the kind of seemingly obvious mistaken beliefs we've held.
- javajosh 3y agoThe fact that matter warps spacetime still blows my mind. We can basically neglect the effect on light near Earth, although it's still present. But that "gravity" is merely what we call the minimizing the action of matter near a warped spacetime is an astonishing claim. If I'm being honest, I really only believe it because people I believe are smarter say it is so; it's so strange and alien that I find it almost impossible to accept. Luckily, apart from a few minor effects here and there, I don't have to think about it and can just accept gravity as a simple force with some unknown mechanism behind it, like Newton did, and I have to say that makes me happier. This talk of time slowing down gives me the creeps.
- eru 3y agoIt's not just gravity. All the other forces are pretty weird as well, if you think about them on a deep enough level. For example, rubber bands resisting elongation isn't even a 'real' force: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_force
- bowsamic 3y agoAs a physicist who learnt it years ago it’s actually not really that crazy to me now and is far more intelligible than quantum field theory
- trimethylpurine 3y agoIs it creepy when you throw a ball up and it magically falls back into your hand? It moves back into your hand specifically because time on the ground is moving slower. The ball, like everything else, moves towards the slower moving timeline (a lesser inertial state). That's actually not creepy at all. It would be creepy if the ball went the other way for no apparent reason like a poltergeist.
- mjan22640 3y agoThe fact that there exist consistent structured phenomena, instead of everything being pure noise, is actually creepy.
- 3y ago
- lolive 3y agoTime used to run slowly in my early life too. Now every year is getting shorter. I never seem to find the time. One day I found 10 years had got me behind me. And no one had told me when to run.
- walteweiss 3y agoYou missed the starting gun!
- partomniscient 3y agoAnd you run and you run to catch up with the sun, but its sinking...racing around to come up behind you again. The sun is the same in a relative way, but you're older. Shorter of breath and one day closer to death.
- walteweiss 3y agoIt’s nice others got the idea! I love that song, there’s something special about it.
- geodel 3y agoThere is some theory that say by age of 35-40 years one has lived about 80% of their lives in term of experiences. This seems intuitively true to me considering increasingly monotonous routine nowadays. There could be just ten things that I remember from last 10 years.
- az226 3y agoAlso the more you experience the more your brain is running on auto pilot. The key is to change things up and not allow the brain to fall into familiar patterns.
- dougmwne 3y agoIt doesn’t have to be this way! Any year can be the most memorable of your life. Think about what you want, then go get it.
- kazinator 3y ago> time progressed five times slower just after the Big Bang. How do you interpret that: five times slower than what, where? Time runs more slowly for someone on a fast rocket, and what that means is that when they come home, they are younger than their twin brother who stayed home. Without such a comparison, it is meaningless. In particularly, how can you say time ran slower before such and such a time, compared to after, because those periods do not overlap; no meaningful comparison can be made. If the 13.77 billion year estimate of the age of the universe is measured in relative time within the universe then that's basically what it is: the speed of time is 1: 13.77 billion years have elapsed in a span of 13.77 billion years. Some imaginary frame of reference outside of the universe might have a different opinion about long things "actually" took, but that's either irrelevant or impossible or both. In other news, five times as many angels fit on the head of a pin in the first 300 femtoseconds of the Big Bang, compared to afterwards ...
- ko27 3y ago> five times slower than what, where Slower than the time we measure here on Earth, or outside Earth/solar system/galaxy. They are very minor time dilation differences between those cases. > In particularly, how can you say time ran slower before such and such a time, compared to after, because those periods do not overlap; no meaningful comparison can be made. Of course you can compare different time periods. When the twin from twin paradox returns younger to Earth, you can say time ran slower for him in the past. We are actually seeing the past (of those quasars) unfold in slower time right now.
- kazinator 3y agoOK, so the quasars are the observable phenomenon. So, question: any of this mean we have to adjust our estimate of the age of the universe?
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIt would be interesting to speculate a future where people doing deep work on big projects are on some near light speed craft, to buy an expert a longer working life on some essential project with a sound mind due to time dilation, versus if they did that work in a lab on earth.
- windowshopping 3y agoCan anyone who knows anything about this explain what it means for time to run slower? How do you even measure that? It's not like you can say "in one second, only half a second of time passed," because that makes no sense surely...? How can you measure how fast time is passing?
- ramblerman 3y agoYou just described it. Time passes slower at high velocities for example. after 6 months on the International Space Station (ISS), orbiting Earth at a speed of about 7,700 m/s, an astronaut would have aged about 0.005 seconds less than those on Earth. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_dilation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_dilation
- bowsamic 3y agoTime doesn’t pass slower at higher velocities unless you compare it to a clock that is moving relative to you at that velocity
- windowshopping 3y agoSo then....what is absolute time? This would imply our own clock on earth is moving much slower relative to a static inertial frame of reference, right? given the speed with which the milky way is hurtling through space? doesn't that mean we're experiencing a dramatically slowed down version of "true time" or "base time"? And then also, does the velocity have to be constant in some direction? i mean what if you're moving back and forth one inch at the speed of light, would time still be slowed for you? what if you're moving back and forth one micron?
- mr_mitm 3y agoEasy: there is no absolute time.
- bowsamic 3y agoThere is no base time. In the point of view of the thing moving quickly away from us, OUR clocks are slower. For both of us, the other’s clock seems to tick slower. The situation is symmetric. This is why it’s called relativity, there is no objective static frame of reference And yes even if you were moving back and forth by one micron at close to the speed of light then an observer stationary relative to you would see your clock tick slower
- ohthehugemanate 3y agoCan I get an ELI5 for how we can use words like "slower" about time? In my mind "slower" and "faster" are comparisons within a timeframe. How can something be slower than something else unless they both exist in the same time?
- snicker7 3y agoTime is warped by gravity. Gravity is produced by matter with mass. The early universe had a higher mass-density resulting in this time-warping effect.
- thunderbong 3y agoMy understanding is - It's slower or faster with respect to our current frame of reference.
- mellosouls 3y ago(Not a physicist) Yes, you are correct - its not within the same frame of reference but observing from one frame to another. Lets say you're watching a DVD; the main characters are walking having a conversation. Now fast seek - they speed up and talk faster. If the characters were conscious entities then within their world nothing has changed, but from your viewpoint everything is going faster. One difference with the physical world is the effect is symmetrical - so if you were observing the movement of crew on a fast moving spaceship from far away you would see them seeming to move very slowly; conversely they would see the same slowing down when observing you. But in each case you are correct that "slower" and "faster" are not in operation within the "same time" but only when viewing into one time "bubble" (DVD) from another. The "bubble-to-bubble slowing down" itself is not some marking off against a universal time axis either (which is at the root of the difficulty in understanding I think), but - if we remember that time is subordinate to the constancy of speed of light then to maintain this constancy, the measurements of time and space in different frames must adjust relative to each other as the frames speed up and slow down. It is this latter waxing and waning that produces the effect "slower" reflected between two different frames of reference.
- elihu 3y agoFrom the article it sounds like this is just a normally expected thing, that time runs more slowly near a massive object, and shortly after the big bang everything was relatively close to a lot of other mass, so from our point of view it looks like time was slower then. I wonder... if the Big Bang started with an explosion of matter from a specific point, and the closer we get to that moment the slower time goes, then might it be correct in some sense to say that the big bang happened an infinite amount of time ago? Maybe it's a meaningless thing to say, without a suitable frame of reference from which one could observe the big bang from "outside"? Thinking about this made me wonder why the big bang didn't just immediately collapse into a black hole. One answer to that, apparently, is that the universe was too uniform. It was very dense, but with ever spec of matter (or whatever it was the early universe was made of) being pulled equally in all directions at once, there wasn't an opportunity for a black hole to form. I wonder if it's like that for time, too? If you're being pulled strongly in all directions equally, does it cancel out and cause time to run at a "normal" rate, or does time run super slow because all the gravitational forces add together? In the former case, I guess it's possible that time ran normally at the very beginning and then slowed down as the universe differentiated itself.
- vasco 3y ago> big bang happened an infinite amount of time ago The big bang might have created time itself, whatever that means.
- abrookewood 3y agoI had no idea that this effect was so noticeable: "the global positioning system (GPS) technology we rely on for navigation wouldn’t work if the satellites they use didn’t have clocks that account for the fact that time runs more slowly at the surface of Earth than it does at their position in orbit"
- sillysaurusx 3y agoCould someone help settle a debate? The universe is infinite, or at least appears so. The cosmic background radiation was because the early universe was hot everywhere. However, I’ve been telling my wife that the universe didn’t start from a single point; it has always been infinite. The concept of “smaller” is only because the matter was less dispersed than it is today. Veritasium’s video seems to support this argument. She’s pointed towards a few different articles saying that the most accepted theory of physics is that the universe started from a single point, and that there is language such as “it grew to the size of an apple” within a small amount of time after the Big Bang. How can both views be correct? Either the universe isn’t infinite, and therefore has some kind of edge, or it is, and has always had infinite size.
- varjag 3y agoImagine you're inflating an air balloon, first to a size of an apple then size of your head then to enormous like a weather balloon. Now consider that the surface of balloon is the space: points on the surface get further and further apart but there is no edge or boundary.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoHow is it possible to say with any certainty that the universe was the size of an apple? That analogy also implies that space wraps around, which no experiment has ever shown to be true. This contradiction is why I have trouble. It’s a good analogy otherwise, but the details are the interesting part.
- varjag 3y ago> How is it possible to say with any certainty that the universe was the size of an apple? Haven't read the paper but one likely could tell from the density. > That analogy also implies that space wraps around, which no experiment has ever shown to be true. It's an analogy meant to highlight one particular aspect, not be a perfect model of spacetime. In mathematics, there is no shortage of topological objects that are infinite but not closed otherwise.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoSurely this is an observer dependent effect due to the expansion of the universe? For example, if a light ray was emitted each second billions of years ago, by now we observe that a redder light is emitted every 5 seconds. Because while it was travelling, the space through which it travelled expanded. When the article says things like "time was slower in the past" it makes my head hurt. Don't they mean "events in the past appear to run 5 times slower when observed today?"
- MrBodangles 3y agoI've actually had this question for a while regarding the JWST and newly discovered distant galaxies being stated as 13+ billion years old — isn't our estimation of their age based on the distance the light has traveled (red shifted) from emission? If so, wouldn't that mean that the 13+ billion year old galaxy's would actually be much younger. e.g. the light could've been emitted 10 billion years ago, but 3 billion light years of additional space has grown between us since then. My understanding is that this is dependent on hubble's law, and we do not know the exact rate of expansion now or in the past, but stating an object is 13+ billion years old without that knowledge seems... Unscientific.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoI believe cosmologists account for all of this. It takes about 13 billion years for space to expand enough to give the observed red shift. The distance between us is now greater than 13 billion light years. Yes, there is uncertainty about the rate of expansion, with different techniques disagreeing. So none of this is fully settled. Which is very scientific!
- orlp 3y agoTime is relative. Events near heavy objects appear slower to observers not near heavy objects. An observer in a similar gravitational field as the event (which is implied if the observer and event are in the same place) will see the events at "normal" speed. The separation of event and observer can be mostly in space when observing a relatively close object falling into a black hole, but can also be in both space and time when looking far into the universe (and thus back in time).
- jug 3y agoThis is pretty insane! I mentally run the universe backwards in time to relate to current very early JWST discoveries and it's so easy to think "similar to now but earlier in terms of star evolution etc", but this hammers in how we're truly looking back at something very alien and weird when we see its recent early age photos. JWST even peers farther back than 1.5 billion years since Big Bang.
- winternewt 3y agoThe phrase "just 1.5 billion years after the Big Bang time, time ran five times slower than it does today, 13.8 billion years later" seems to make about three self-referential loops around itself. What does 1.5 billion years mean if time ran slower? Is it slow years or fast years, and from what frame of reference would you even tell the difference? What does "slow" even mean, isn't speed measured in relation to time passing? If you're comparing two physically separated frames of reference it makes sense to talk about "this many seconds here corresponds to that many seconds over there". But when you're talking about the speed of time for the entire universe, how do you form such a ratio?
- theK 3y agoWhat the article actually wants to say (and it does so down the line) is that: > If you look at a pulsar, that is 12B light years away from us, it will pulsate significantly slower than expected. In this case, I think, it is that the pulsar blinks slower by a factor of 5. I presume they already have corrected out the redshift related time dilation and 5 is what was left.
- overengineer 3y agoHow can you tell difference between effect of redshift and time dilation
- dotancohen 3y agoHydrogen and other emission lines, presumably.
- taneq 3y agoDoes time dilation not affect frequency (and thence spectra)? The two effects seem perfectly equivalent to me.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNo. If a hydrogen atom makes a transition "there", then it does so with a frequency determined by the clock "there", at the point where the transition happened. If we detect the emission "here", we see both the red shift and the time dilation between "there" and "here", and we see them in exactly the same way - as a frequency shift.
- AungKyawNaing 3y ago[flagged]
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- stratigos 3y agoThe article feels dated, like the study began long before the latest revelations about our cosmos have been announced. E.g., we believe the current universe is > 23 billion years old, and that the 13.x bn year timeline is now out of date. Secondly, there is a growing agreement in the academic community that the big bang is just teleological fantasy at its best, and that there is no way to know what happened before inflation, just that inflation happened. So accurately we now know the universe is > 23bn years since inflation, and we have no idea what happened beyond that border, just that it "appears" to be expanding from a point. Its also very dated to perceive time as a 4th dimension. This is not academic, this is now common knowledge. 4th dimensional reality is the superposition of all objects in 3 dimensions, see the term "tesseract." Its the stuff of kindergartners to believe time is the 4th dimension. Also agree with the other comments that it sounds naive to measure things in "seconds" when there is nothing relative from which to measure time in the earliest states of the universe. The article basically sounds like it came from 1970s WASP academia, and is a few decades behind in the current academic perspectives of astrophysics and cosmology.
- scotty79 3y agoIs it due to gravity caused by higher density, near light speed of relative motion or space expansion?