4 ms·
No, why? There's no single 'theory of compound interest'. First, the rich don't reliably get richer faster than the poor get richer. (Despite what the linked
by eru 3y ago
No, why? There's no single 'theory of compound interest'.
First, the rich don't reliably get richer faster than the poor get richer. (Despite what the linked article or other texts might claim.)
Second, interest rates are mostly an abstraction. Yes, if two people are both putting money in a bank account in the same currency, the one with the higher interest rate will get richer faster.
In the real world, many investments yield a variable nominal rate of return (eg real estate, stocks, art, etc). And you also have to worry about factors like inflation or counter party risk.
- VirusNewbie 3y ago>First, the rich don't reliably get richer faster than the poor get richer. yes they do, as money printing benefits those who are leveraged into assets more than other types of debt holders. The rich (by proxy, through investing in the stock market) actually hold more debt in aggregate. And per capita, they hold WAY more debt, hence benefit from money printing even more. Money printing is indirect wealth transfer from everyone else to the rich.
- eru 3y agoYou seem to assume that creditors are a bunch of morons? Any inflation that's anticipated at the time a debt contract is made will be priced in to the debt contract. That's (part of) why high inflation economies have high interest rates. You can load up with debt as well: it's fairly easy to open up a margin account at eg Interactive Brokers, or (almost equivalently) to trade in options (which have margin financing sort-of built-in).
- VirusNewbie 3y agoThis is the most arbitraged thing in the world, as inflations are lagging indicators. Chart M2 growth to CPI and you can clearly see what I mean.
- eru 3y ago> This is the most arbitraged thing in the world, [...] So we agree and you say that this thing is already priced in? Good. Yes, market participants anticipate many things, and make their contracts based on what they expect. Not on any mechanical considerations of what happened before.
- pixl97 3y ago>You seem to assume that creditors are a bunch of morons? After 2008 and 'too big to fail', you don't?
- eru 3y ago'Too big too fail' is mostly about taking advantage of (implicit or explicit) government guarantees. Ie making the taxpayer bail you out. That's very different from normal creditors being morons. (And yes, the people with resources often, but not always, have an easier time getting the government to give them even more resources.)
- robotresearcher 3y ago> the rich don't reliably get richer faster than the poor get richer. Given same rate of return, the one who puts in the most money gets richer faster, in absolute dollars. The article says that on top of this, those with more capital get better relative returns too. You don't refute this by just saying it's not so. The increasing wealth disparity we observe would seem to support this idea.
- eru 3y agoGlobal inequality has declined in recent decades. (Mostly thanks to India and even more so China going from dirt poor to poor or middle income. But many other countries like South Korea or Singapore and previously Japan have also caught up. Poland and many, but not all, former Eastern block states have also done quite well.)
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> the rich don't reliably get richer faster than the poor get richer. Doubling 100M in 10 years to 200M is, IMO, getting richer faster than double 25K to 50K in 10 years.
- steveBK123 3y agoAlso the poor generally don't have wealth to speak of, definitionally. Having $25k or 50k in savings is quite far from being poor.