3 ms·
If they don't want to explain how to do things in a way they disagree with, then the appropriate response is to not say anything at all. The current culture on
by lolinder 3y ago
If they don't want to explain how to do things in a way they disagree with, then the appropriate response is to not say anything at all.
The current culture on SO is to flood questions with "don't do X, do Y", then upvote those answers. The result is that questions look answered but actually aren't, so the questions stay unanswered. When I come along months or years later having already considered all options, I don't want to have my time wasted by a question that perfectly matches my goal but was never answered because it got drowned in alternative approaches that I already ruled out.
- JohnFen 3y ago> The current culture on SO is to flood questions with "don't do X, do Y", then upvote those answers. The result is that questions look answered but actually aren't, so the questions stay unanswered. I think this is the #1 reason why SO isn't a great resource for me.
- shawnz 3y agoIsn't it the question author who gets to choose when an answer is satisfactory or not on SO? If a question is full of answers that aren't marked as satisfactory, then there's still an opportunity for someone to come in and get the points by providing a different one. What more can they do, ban people from trying to provide alternative solutions? Surely that is going to create much more harm than good.
- lolinder 3y ago> Isn't it the question author who gets to choose when an answer is satisfactory or not on SO? This would be a fine policy if SO didn't also make a huge stink about duplicate questions. As is, there's one canonical copy of each similarly-phrased question, and a re-ask that says "but for real, I actually want to do it this way" is going to get shut down as a duplicate. > If a question is full of answers that aren't marked as satisfactory, then there's still an opportunity for someone to come in and get the points by providing a different one. The system rewards being one of the first responders, not the one who actually answers the question. This is especially true now that they've updated the system to place the highest-voted answer first rather than the accepted answer. > What more can they do, ban people from trying to provide alternative solutions? Surely that is going to create much more harm than good. I don't know that there's anything the company can do, since it's pretty clear that they've lost control of most aspects of the culture.
- shawnz 3y agoFair enough, I totally agree that SO moderators are way too overbearing when it comes to duplicates.