2 ms·
> I tell you I have two children and that (at least) one of them is a boy, and ask you what you think is the probability that I have two boys. Many people, when
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> I tell you I have two children and that (at least) one of them is a boy, and ask you what you think is the probability that I have two boys. Many people, when they hear this puzzle for the first time, give the answer 1/2, reasoning that there is an equal likelihood that my other child is a boy or a girl. But this is not correct. Based on what you know, you should conclude that I am actually twice as likely to have a boy and a girl as I am to have two boys. So your right answer to my question is not 1/2 but 1/3.
Actually, neither is correct – leaving aside whether the math is correct given the unstated assumptions – because the unstated assumptions are wrong: birth probabilities by sex are not equal and, within the same family, are not independent.