4 ms·
Windows 11 takes about 12 minutes to boot from an HDD. Imagine trying to boot it from an FDD. Installing Windows 11 and then waiting for all the updates to ins
by jeffbee 3y ago
Windows 11 takes about 12 minutes to boot from an HDD. Imagine trying to boot it from an FDD.
Installing Windows 11 and then waiting for all the updates to install on a HDD takes about 8 days.
- hosteur 3y agoWow. That is outrageous.
- jeffbee 3y agoI only know this because I needed to use a utility from Asus to update the Intel ME, and it only runs under Windows. I naively assumed it would not be that much trouble to throw a hard disk that was laying around into that PC and install Windows thereupon.
- Knee_Pain 3y ago[dead]
- gsich 3y agoAlso false.
- toast0 3y agoI'm kind of surprised Windows 11 allows you to install to or run from something that isn't an SSD. Windows 7 ran just fine on spinners, but Windows 10 is pretty bad; I'm not surprised Windows 11 is worse, but they really should just disallow it.
- soupfordummies 3y agoMaybe they shouldn't have such resource-creep that REQUIRES an SSD. Maybe they WOULDN'T if there weren't mountains of bloatware and telemetry bs.
- toast0 3y agoI mean, that would be great; but if nobody is holding the line on resource-creep, as is obviously the case, and nobody is testing if releases are acceptable on HDDs, as is obviously the case, they should just change the published requirements to reflect reality.
- wtallis 3y ago> they should just change the published requirements to reflect reality. Marketing won't let them so long as it would piss off PC OEMs that still ship crappy systems and want to use the Windows logo.
- toast0 3y agoShouldn't be a hard sell for OEMs; official specs are 64 GB is enough storage for windows 11, and I can get a 128 GB SSD for $15 retail, whereas the lowest price hard drive I can find is $25 retail (500 GB, but 3.5"), so if you're a cheap PC OEM, putting in a crappy, tiny, SSD saves money. And the only systems without SSDs I saw on BestBuy were refurbished machines shipping with Windows 10.
- pixl97 3y agoWhy shouldn't they? People don't buy operating systems to be slimmed down... If you got a computer and it didn't come with all the needed drivers and a web browser along with most of the functionality needed to print, you'd most likely wonder what decade it came from. All that stuff I listed, without the telemetry is still going to run like dog shit on a HDD. I honestly think users are forgetting just how badly fragmented hard drives of days yonder used to run, and those same spinning disks are not any faster these days. Cutting down the OS to barely do anything still took more time than the complete boot cycle of my current computer up to a browser on an SSD.
- toast0 3y agoYeah, hard drives are never going to be great (although 15k rpm drives aren't too bad), but IMHO, the real thing that causes perf to be awful is that windows 10 (and I assume 11 has gotten worse) can't seem to ever stop writing to the disk. Those writes seem to interrupt reads enough that you never can get good sustained read speeds, so loading anything is painful. I'm not going to setup a system to test, because it's too painful, but I'm now idly wondering if you could set the checkbox on a hard drive for "Turn off Windows write-cache buffer flushing on the device", and if that would help. Doing a aggregated write of a couple MB once a minute would probably work better than doing a few KB every second. Of course, at great risk of data loss, but YOLO. (a smidge of research seems to indicate this is for asking the device to pretty-please flush its internal write cache, so that might help a bit, but probably not very much; maybe there's a knob somewhere to tune the system file cache)
- water9 3y agoThey must have a lot of "Telemetry" to collect on you.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoI thought telemetry was supposed to improve the experience. Not make it worse?
- JohnClark1337 3y ago[dead]
- lowercased 3y agoIt improves "the" experience; not "your" experience. ;)
- 1023bytes 3y agoCome on now, HDDs aren't that bad. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MpNagBwWlNk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MpNagBwWlNk
- jeffbee 3y agoWell that is not at all what happens on my machine, which is a Core i9 13900K with 128GiB of memory. It just grinds and grinds and grinds for ages.
- omnibrain 3y agoWhy do you use a HDD? Of course, I ask in jest, but I'm also a bit curious.
- jeffbee 3y agoI have a very excellent SSD which I removed from that system because I am certain that the Windows installer would fuck it up, and I did not want the hassle of trying to fix it. So I pulled it out of the box to keep it from harm, and the only media I had at hand at that moment was a WD SATA HDD. I thought it would be slow, not kill-me-now slow. I do not "use an HDD" of course. It was improvisational.
- deathanatos 3y agoThe same reason anyone has always used a HDD? … they're dirt cheap, compared to SSDs. I'd consider hybrid being the best cost option, with a small SSD backing frequently used data, like the OS. But there's more complexity in that setup. I'm also a Linux user, and boot times don't bother me.
- pixl97 3y agoDirt cheap in which measure? I was at Microcenter and some 1TB (rather questionable) NVMe drivers were $30 on special. Going to be difficult to get cheaper than that. Now, lets turn your equation around. What is the cost per IOPS of your HDD versus SSD? HDDs start to get expensive very fast in that measure.
- wsc981 3y agoI fucked up the partitions on my 2017 iMac with Fusion drive a short while ago trying to create a dual boot system and even since my Mac was slow. I think from beginning of start-up to a somewhat usable system was maybe 5 minutes? Quite long either way. But just last weekend got sick of the slowness and found there's a 'diskutil resetFusion' [0] command that restores the partitions to the default. So I ran this command, reinstalled the OS and now my iMac is pretty speedy again. Not great mind you, but way better then before. Lesson learned: dual boot on a Fusion drive is a bad idea. --- [0]: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207584 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207584
- objektif 3y agoThis cannot be true.
- alephxyz 3y agoI have a W10 install on a 7200rpm HDD and I believe it.
- justsomehnguy 3y agoCan confirm the boot time with Win10 on HDD. Can't argue about updates, took about a couple of hours, def. not days.
- biogene 3y agoNot seeing those boot times, but I rarely reboot. I usually reboot my W10 box once every few months or so. Our IT department commissions our Windows PCs in about an hour. Something seems very very wrong here, but I'm not an IT expert.
- hospitalJail 3y agoTry to remove Windows/Microsoft from your life, Microsoft no longer is decent. We need to migrate to Linux.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Windows 11 takes about 12 minutes to boot from an HDD. Mine doesn't. It takes 3-4 minutes (which can easily feel like an hour).