6 ms·
Please do not post AI summaries on HN. Anyone in this community can do it by themselves, and it is no more helpful than copying and pasting search engine result
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Please do not post AI summaries on HN. Anyone in this community can do it by themselves, and it is no more helpful than copying and pasting search engine results on a topic.
- enslavedrobot 3y agoDisagree. I appreciate the summary. Keep it up.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoGood enslavedroBOT
- enslavedrobot 3y agoEverything and everyone that doesn't align with your thinking MUST be a bot.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoRelax guy, it was a cutesy reference to the "Good bot" meme and your username.
- enslavedrobot 3y agoMissed that... Powering down.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoAlso your comment redeemed you lol. Cutesy respects cutesy
- Obscurity4340 3y agoNo worries fam, just assume good faith/collegiality before malice. A lot of funny and clever folks here, grab a cuppa and stay awhile :)
- tkgally 3y agoThank you for the comment. That was the first time I have posted such a summary, and I wasn’t sure if I should or not. This was my thinking: The linked article is long and paywalled, and the title is provocative and possibly misunderstood. Rather than people commenting based only on the title and their prior views on the issue, I thought it might help to provide an objective summary of the article. An AI’s summary is likely to be more objective than one written by a person interested in the issue (including me). Claude 2 is, as far as I know, the only publically accessible LLM that can summarize such long articles, and it is currently available only to people in the U.S. and U.K. or with VPNs. I therefore decided to post that summary myself in the hope that it would lead to a more constructive discussion. Such a discussion hasn’t emerged yet, but that doesn’t seem to be because of the summary. In any case, there doesn’t seem to be consensus yet on whether AI summaries on HN are good or bad; my own AI summary has received both upvotes and downvotes. I'll drop a note to @dang and ask for his thoughts on the issue.
- tkgally 3y ago@dang kindly replied to me as follows: “[AI-generated summaries are] definitely discouraged. We haven't added it formally to the guidelines (mainly because I think it follows as a corollary, or maybe a lemma, from what's already there) but we want HN threads to be for curious conversation between humans, and have always discouraged autogenerated comments or even human-written summaries.”
- anigbrowl 3y agoThe best approach if you come across a paywalled article is to submit it to archive.org or some other archival site.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]