3 ms·
Starting Strength is not recommended anymore: https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitness.wiki/faq/starting-strength-and-stronglifts-not-recom
by satvikpendem 3y ago
Starting Strength is not recommended anymore: https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitness.wiki/faq/starting-strength-and-stronglifts-not-recommended/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitnes...
- cheald 3y agoStarting Strength is fine for a beginner. It's not an optimal program, but it's simple, easy to understand, and built on good foundational principles. As an on-ramp into resistance training, it's better than a complex program that'll scare beginners off or burn them out.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThis is directly addressed on that page too: https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitness.wiki/faq/starting-strength-and-stronglifts-not-recommended/#But_SS_and_SL_are_only_meant_to_be_short_term_programs_for_a_few_months,_so_this_isn%E2%80%99t_a_big_deal https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitnes... As well as in the section above it.
- cheald 3y agoIt still doesn't change the fact that a suboptimal program which keeps beginners engaged and moving forward is infinitely superior to a more complex one that they fall off of.
- satvikpendem 3y agoIt does actually. The program is so poor that beginners might not even see enough progress that they're put off from working out, because "what's the point if I've been at it for a month or three and still don't have any gains?" That's why it's better to actually pick a good program, one that shows consistent gains as motivation rather than plateauing as a demotivational force. Other recommended programs like 5/3/1 are not "more complex," that's a false dichotomy. They're just as simple but with different sets of exercises.
- cheald 3y agoThis is a very silly argument to be made against a lifting program which has verifiably moved countless people off the couch and into resistance training. The reason people recommend Starting Strength is because it's what successfully got them into lifting. I train 5/3/1 now, I have for years, I love it, and I absolutely do not recommend it to beginners. I've tried. Their eyes glaze over when you start talking about "training maxes" and "periodization". They get confused and lose whatever sliver of motivation they had. Save the optimization for when they're bought in. Any beginner is gonna make progress on essentially any structured program just due to neuroadaptation. Premature optimization is the root of all evil.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI did SS too in the beginning. I didn't see much progress and that has also been verifiably the case for others too, if you are using anecdotes as your verification process. That SS works is despite its quality, not because of it. And so what? Should we not try to improve programs just because they work in some cases? We don't have to use 5/3/1 then, we can use even the basic beginner routine as recommended on r/fitness, it is pretty good while discarding the problems of SS.
- cheald 3y agoBut you're still lifting, presumably. That sounds like success to me. I tried to start lifting multiple times. SL 5x5 is what actually made it click. Now that I know what I'm doing, I could write volumes on its flaws, but what I needed wasn't a technically optimized program, but one which gave me a clear goal for each workout and an easy way to see what the path forward looked like. As the reddit beginner program correctly notes: > The primary goal is to be a simple, easy to follow routine that will help beginners get into the gym, start training with the standard barbell lifts, and build a habit of going to the gym consistently. Consistency over time is the biggest point of failure in making progress, and the aim is to lower the barrier as far as possible to starting and staying consistent. The point of a beginner program really isn't the volume moved or optimizing the particular split, but to give the beginner a structure on which to build routine and learn good habits. It helps no one to crap on Starting Strength, when it has an established history of achieving exactly that goal. Offering things like the reddit program as a potentially superior alternative is fine to the eager newbie, but telling people that Starting Strength is a bad way to start is just counterproductive. My advice to every new lifter is that the best program for them is the one that gets them going back to the gym consistently, and I'll continue to stand behind that. It's not SS for everyone - and that's fine. But it is SS for a lot of people, and that's also fine.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThis is survivor bias; SS keeps some beginners engaged but there's no count of those who drop off or never start it. I was in the latter group; it was the first program recommended to me, but I was leery of it because I don't have medical insurance and was skeptical about the feasibility of the suggestions based on what I knew about my own body, so I just did nothing about it. When I did start lifting, I started out with light weights and spent months figuring out a program while getting a kinetic understanding of the different muscle groups and how they worked together, spamming volume for a while and gradually adding more weight. I don't mean that SS is a bad program, it works for lots of people and it's very accessible. But I also think it's way oversold and not magic.
- cheald 3y agoIt's definitely not magic, but it's on the 80 side of the 80/20 split, IMO. It isn't the right starter program for everyone, but then, nothing is. The best program for the beginner is whichever one keeps you consistently showing up and moving forward.
- tastysandwich 3y agoSorry, as advised by "The Fitness Wiki" ? Starting Strength remains the absolute best way for a novice to gain general-purpose strength.
- ycombinete 3y agoThere's a "Where can I read some comments on Reddit about this?" section for clarifications: https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitness.wiki/faq/starting-strength-and-stronglifts-not-recommended/#Where_can_I_read_some_comments_on_Reddit_about_this https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitnes...
- satvikpendem 3y agoIt is part of r/Fitness, a very reputable resource for fitness as many top weightlifters are there too. The article addresses why it's not a good program and why beginner programs are generally not well designed: https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitness.wiki/faq/starting-strength-and-stronglifts-not-recommended/#Where_can_I_read_some_comments_on_Reddit_about_this https://web.archive.org/web/20200528135350/https://thefitnes...
- lm28469 3y agoStill better than starting Netflix and burger+fries 5x5
- satvikpendem 3y agoSure, but at that point even going for a run is better than Netflix and burgers. Don't strawman the argument, just because SS is ostensibly better doesn't mean it's actually good.
- safety1st 3y agoYour comment is being downvoted because it's low quality. It's basically a drive-by hit on SS with no context. I will upvote it and add some context. * thefitness.wiki is maintained by Reddit's r/fitness and it's a great resource. * Parent had to use an archive.org link because thefitness.wiki long ago removed the post he linked to. * I suspect they removed the post because thefitness.wiki now has a 'Basic Beginner Routine' which is similar to Starting Strength, and tells you this is what you should start with. https://thefitness.wiki/routines/r-fitness-basic-beginner-routine/ https://thefitness.wiki/routines/r-fitness-basic-beginner-ro... * I've done both BBR and SS. I prefer BBR but they're both fine places to start. They both basically have you cycle through the staple compound lifts and if you're not already trained this is the best thing you can do for your body. The health benefits of simply doing each compound lift at least once a week plus eating a ton of protein cannot be overstated, they are life changing. * I'll editorialize here but I feel both BBR and SS are designed for younger, fitter, more hardcore "beginners" than me, especially SS. I was a 40+, out of shape desk jockey and the cadence at which they want you to increase weight was too much for me. Also with these big lifts you NEED to get the technique right or you WILL hurt yourself.
- grudg3 3y agoWhat would you recommend to someone older to start with? I've done SS in my late 20s but I do feel like I'd like to try something new as I get closer to 40 and considering some exercise. Context, I wfh, am overweight and extremely sedentary. At the moment have been purely working on my diet but exercising is next.
- jaggederest 3y agoHonestly you should start again with starting strength or a beginner program like it if you haven't been actively training in the last few years. Go slow, start with the bar, let the increases happen until you hit a wall where you need to reassess. Listen to your body. Once you're back to "intermediate", i.e. 6 months to a year of reasonably consistent training, you can transition to a different program or just maintain at 2x a week if you like where you've ended up. That's in addition to very gradually adding some sort of cardio like walks around the block. Being sedentary is going to be more of a struggle to overcome than strength - you will find that the strength you used to have will come back quickly when you start training again, but as a guy in the exact same boat, the cardiovascular side is the tough part. I am getting strong again really quickly but I am getting winded half way through a strength workout, let alone actually trying to jog.
- nathias 3y agoI wouldn't trust anything on reddit...
- satvikpendem 3y agoI would. For example, /r/AskHistorians is extremely high quality. Don't mistake a forum for all of its users as one monolith.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoI think they are referring to fitness-related advice on Reddit, but, yes, there are a number of quite high quality subreddits out there among the not so great ones.
- refurb 3y agoAskHistorians is a bunch of PhDs doing quality write-ups with full referencing. You can't compare that to r/fitness in the least.
- memefrog 3y ago[dead]
- nathias 3y agodo you have a phd in history to judge that? I said I wouldn't trust, I'm sure there is some good resources but they are mixed with bad ones, I just know that r/philosophy is a terrible resource for anyone studying philosophy
- gloryjulio 3y agoJust add sledgehammer workout to the routine. It's the foundation of all combat sports. You have your core strength, upper body strength, arm strength well trained. And it's infinitely fun to hit stuff
- tayo42 3y agoThis is just some wiki related to reddit? I know reddit loves 5/3/1 and pretends that nothing else exists. Great example of the reddit echo chamber for something that isn't a political topic. 5x5 program got my bench to 275 when I was younger. I think it's fine. Really after years of trying all these systems the only that will work for sure is getting in the gym consistently and lifting heavy. Everything else is mostly a distraction. Like min/maxing in wow
- satvikpendem 3y agoThey recommend many routines, not just 5/3/1: https://thefitness.wiki/routines/strength-training-muscle-building/ https://thefitness.wiki/routines/strength-training-muscle-bu...
- tayo42 3y agoAre you just regurgitating reddit advice or have you gone through this and advised gym goers with success? The nice thing about lifting is results speak for them self. If your going to keep posting this link as solid advice, maybe share your lifts...
- satvikpendem 3y agoYes I have gone through these, started with SS, saw basically no progress, then moved to 5/3/1 and did some other routines over the past several years. At my peak before a recent injury I was at 225 bench, 325 deadlifting and 275 squat.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"At my peak before a recent injury I was at 225 bench, 325 deadlifting and 275 squat." So you barely lift...?
- bowsamic 3y agoIn what world is that "barely lifting"? I don't think I've ever even seen anyone in my gym bench that much
- moonchrome 3y agoArguments there are bullshit - talking about stuff that's completely irrelevant to beginners to make things sound complicated - personal fitness trainer playbook. If you're a couch potato dev who sits all day and does no physical activity - just doing random shit with your bodyweight or empty bar will get you sore for the first month. Overloading yourself with pointless movements that are meant to target specific muscle groups is completely irrelevant for the first year. Go to gym - find heavy stuff you can pick up - try not to do anything stupid. SS is great because it has a low number of movements, volume is irrelevant when you get sore from a barbell squat, learning how to lift is deceptively complicated (breathing/bracing/muscle activation). The article keeps straw-manning "longterm" this and that - SS is your first year in the gym (or less). By the time you're trough with it, unless you're totally oblivious, you'll pick up on other stuff when you have the time. And you'll have a decent intuition of how to lift, understand recovery implications, consistency in training, and a decent base strength. It's a great base to get you started and have an achievable progression framework that doesn't require much tutoring or time. I've seen plenty of people get from 0 to nice lifting strength in ~1 year by doing SS. The only thing that's relevant is consistency - if you come in 2-3x a week and do something difficult for an hour for a year - you will see results - it can be total fucking around - you will still get results. It's good to start with SS type exercises because those well defined movements target your entire body, and if you learn to execute them correctly you reduce your chance of injury. TL;DR - for any newbie out there that's in bad shape and looking to start gym - save yourself time and avoid "optimal muscle development" crowd. None of those arguments apply to you and are completely irrelevant. Don't trust me ? Go to the gym and do 5x5 with an empty bar and see if you're sore after the workout.
- renewiltord 3y agoUltimately, while I never reached the 200 kg / 440 lb he mentions on the deadlift I got to: (in lbs) Back Squat 275 2 rm Front Squat 225 2 rm Deadlift 375 2 rm Bench 175 5x5 OHP 135 5x5 C&J 125 1x5 Snatch 105 1x5 With my primary program being SS and then SS like (do the set 5x5 or appropriate at the work weight, advance by appropriate increment). That's the rough master plan at least. Not advising. Merely sharing my experience. Simplicity of adherence maximized adherence. Visible progress increased adherence.
- refurb 3y agoRecommended by who? Redditors? I read the critique. It's basically "you don't do enough volume for certain exercises", "you'll end up doing too many squatting and looking funny", "their approach to stall isn't optimal". It sounds like a www.bodybuilding.com forum rant. Someone arguing why micronized whey is superior to non-micronized. It's ultra-optimization. If you're someone looking to get started, you're looking to get started, not optimize for a bodybuilding competition. If you like SS, and it gets you actually lifting, then it's good. If you really get into it, then great! You can continue to refine what you do, read up on all the arguments, try different things. But if you just want a workout that makes you stronger that you can keep doing, then SS works fine. It reminds me a bit of audio enthusiasts. Somebody wants an amplifier recommendation for a certain budget and people jump in telling them "you'll regret going solid state, the purity of tube amps can't be beat" and the person is like "I just want an amplifier so my kids can watch Disney in surround sound". And the really good thing about SS is the focus on proper technique. It's more important than how much you lift.