3 ms·
> You can see this today on the daily graph for France when solar production ramps over the day, pushing down nuclear generation. That.... is exactly what nucl
by troupo 3y ago
> You can see this today on the daily graph for France when solar production ramps over the day, pushing down nuclear generation.
That.... is exactly what nuclear plants are literally designed to do.
As for "economics". If we don't discuss the politics of disregard and underinvestment in nuclear power plants, we can't discuss the economics. The only reason your last link exists is precisely because French government sat on its ass and did nothing to the most important energy source in their country. What do you think will happen to your renewable energy after decades of similar disregard?
If we don't discuss where to get energy on a quiet night, we can't discuss "economics". The only reason "Germany has replaced nuclear with renewables" discource exists is because Germany burns insane amounts of coal and imports energy from France and Denmark every time there's a dip in renewables (aka at least every 12 hours or so).
- ben_w 3y ago> What do you think will happen to your renewable energy after decades of similar disregard? I hope it's not the governments' mistake to make next time, given how much easier it is to scale renewables anywhere from multi-gigawatt down to however many milliwatts solar powered pocket calculators were.
- troupo 3y ago> given how much easier it is to scale renewables anywhere from multi-gigawatt down to Easy to scale nameplate capacity? Yes. Easy to scale generation? No. Right now, as I write this, in Germany: - Wind: 66.5 GW installed capacity. Generation: 1.82 GW, or 2.74% of that - Solar: 69.1 GW of installed capacity. Generation: 0.38 GW, or 0.55% of that - Hydro: 9.78 GW of installed capacity. Generation: 3.09 GW, or 31% of that So Germany is busy burning gas (generation: 7.6 GW), coal (generation: 14.2 GW), and "bio fuels" (generation: 5 GW), and importing electricity from as far away as Norway
- ben_w 3y agoAs you wrote that, the sun is still low (in practice) on the horizon even here in Berlin. If you want to argue storage capacity etc. is up to the government, fine, but not where I was going.
- troupo 3y ago> As you wrote that, the sun is still low (in practice) on the horizon even here in Berlin. Exactly > If you want to argue storage capacity etc. is up to the government Yes, the storage capacity is also an issue. > but not where I was going. I don't know where you were going, but when you say "it's easy to scale renewables" and then say "oh, but the sun is below horizon and inadequate storage capacity", it's clear that it's not that easy to scale renewables.
- ben_w 3y ago> Yes, the storage capacity is also an issue. Yeah, but a different one. I don't know if it will be solved by large scale government-backed mega-projects — which can be anything from grid-scale batteries, cubic kilometres of cryo-hydrogen, hydroelectric dams, or (my personal favourite) a global TW-scale power grid — or if it will be spontaneous local interest like electric cars and slightly scaled up versions of the ~kWh battery packs I see in Obi and Kaufland as home power storage. The home battery packs are already at a level where they just about make sense financially over their working lifetime, but hardly anyone will want to spend €17k for 15+ years of grid independence, especially here where the grid is basically guaranteed to work.
- troupo 3y ago> > Yes, the storage capacity is also an issue. > Yeah, but a different one. It is the same issue, and pretending that it isn't is disingenous at best. What's the point of "quickly scaling renewables" if they can provide 0.55% of their nameplate capacity? > I don't know if it will be solved by Indeed, no one knows how this problem will be solved (and if it can be solved), but it doesn't stop you from statements like "how much easier it is to scale renewables anywhere from multi-gigawatt down to however many milliwatts". Germany has easily scaled renewables to gigawatts. And yet even now, during the day wind is at 2.38% capacity, solar is at 43% capacity, and 15 GW has to come from coal even though if you look at numbers only, there's 67 GW of wind installed. > especially here where the grid is basically guaranteed to work. Currently the only reason is working is that countries burn copious amounts of coal and gas to keep up with demand. Even Denmark which is covered in wind turbines currently only utilizes 9.6% of installed wind capacity, and has to import 34% of its electricity from Norway. But sure do tell me how easy it is to scale renewables without accounting for the actual reality we can observe literally right now?