3 ms·
> The market didn't [...] The market did all those things; acts characterized as government are services traded on the market. Yeah, there are formal restricti
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> The market didn't [...]
The market did all those things; acts characterized as government are services traded on the market. Yeah, there are formal restrictions on doing that, but just as free marketeers bleat that regulation of more conventional goods doesn’t stop them from being traded and creats a black market still guided by market forces, that's also true of government acts.
People who use appeal to the market to sell political ideas never seem to apply their logic consistently, tailoring their description of what buying and selling is “market” based on what they are trying to sell you.
> But the market itself, the free trade among people, is a neutral party and a chaotic self-driven mechanism.
The market is not a party at all, it is an abstraction describing interactions of all the parties; and it is no more neutral than the ultimate outcome of the aggregate of interactions is.
- sph 3y ago> The market did all those things; acts characterized as government are services traded on the market. We live in a world dominated by trade, everything has a price and an index. But here you're saying that the chicken came before the egg rather than viceversa. I wouldn't be so sure. The point I'm making is that there is the market, and there is the government. The one that has the power to affect the other is the government itself, with its laws and tariffs and monopoly over violence. The result is some kind of symbiosis, of course, but everything started in the king's court, not the other way around. Blaming the market for the ills of our world is like blaming the Internet for the existence of revenge porn. Both money and the internet are simply a technology to exchange information and some form of energy, and if it didn't exist, people would invent it (see black markets)
- dragonwriter 3y ago> The point I’m making is that there is the market, and there is the government. And my point is that that’s a an artificial, politically motivated distortion of reality. > Blaming the market for the ills of our world i I’m not doing that. I’m pointing out why giving the market blame or credit for anything is pointless, and only possible through selective, ends-directed reasoning.