5 ms·
The Pentagon’s UFO Shop, the Hitchhiker Effect, and Models of Contagion [pdf]
- kelseyfrog 3y agoThis is just folie en famille[1] / folie à plusieurs, right? The Skinwalker visitor fits the criteria as the folie imposée and the main contributors of stress and isolation are easily inferred - the site is remote, and visitors are aware of its history which frames their time there as particularly stress-inducing. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folie_%C3%A0_deux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folie_%C3%A0_deux
- throwaway743 3y agoMaybe, maybe not.
- SimbaOnSteroids 3y agoMy favorite type of mass hallucination is the type that gets painted by radar.
- jjoonathan 3y agoA third of all radar jammers operate on the principle of generating fake returns that "fly away" (often in unphysical ways because that was good enough). It's funny how this 101-level fact that every radar technician, operator, and designer is keenly aware of somehow never seems to make it into the UFOlogist monologues about how infallible radar evidence is.
- SimbaOnSteroids 3y agoYes, and OP said they represented a mass hallucination. Which they're clearly not entirely. I find it odd that every time this subject comes up people just bend over backwards to behave in the most smug ways possible.
- keepamovin 3y agoI like your attitude toward all this! I haven’t seen much of that kind of approach before and it’s inspiring. Thank you for sharing.! I think the smugness is a compensatory disguise, so like a psychological defense, both in reaction to something that people are genuinely scared of being real and also in reaction to something they can’t understand. Some people are very uncomfortable with that level of ambiguity, used as they are to being across everything in their slice of life normally (or feeling like they need to pretend that they know everything to maintain the position of authority they feel expected to by the people around them) and so they react in that kind of way. the smugness, I suppose helps bolster the points they’re saying as if we should believe them more so because this person delivers them so confidently and treats, any other possibilities, so dismissively, we should kind of take what they’re saying on faith and trust them. I think when you take a step back and look at it, it’s very obvious that an individual couldn’t have such omniscient knowledge as to be able to conclusively deny all the possibilities of the universe from the point of view of their own slice of experience as these SmugMug’s seem to pretend. Ha! :) I think the curious thing is that boring dismissals like that became a kind of norm in the discourse, while people are missing out on the sheer adventurous interest of engaging with something unexplainable in a curious way. I mean what could be more fun even doing that? Yeah, it’s funny to me that the boring view became popular like this, at least for a while.
- jjoonathan 3y agoRight back atcha.
- SimbaOnSteroids 3y agoHard agree, the UFO community is full of some of the dumbest most self confident people you can find on earth, myself potentially included.
- simonh 3y agoExcept that many of them are purely optical phenomena that don’t show up on radar at all. Which of course is even more mysterious and meaningful!
- misnome 3y agoThe rename from "UFO Program" to "UFO Shop" unfortunately makes it sound like the Pentagon has a souvenir shop that sells little UFOs. I'm disappointed.
- mcpackieh 3y agoI was thinking UFO shop is where they manufacture UFOs. Or more likely, where they manufacture UFO hoaxes.
- cirrus3 3y ago^ I clicked to see what was for sale in the shop, disappointed.
- keepamovin 3y agoSorry about that! I tried to fit the title. Your understandable reading of that is kind of charming tho. Maybe they do! Or they should! Haha :)
- demondemidi 3y agoI'd like to visit this place, but there are no cheap flights to the obverse side of the flat earth from where I live, and United won't fly over the edge of the world's ice barrier. Damn.
- jcrawfordor 3y agoSkinwalker Ranch is one of the most famous sites in contemporary parascience, and Bigelow has been involved in it since long before AATIP (roughly since 1995; Harry Reid may have been on board with the project that entire time although it's difficult to say for sure). Colm Kelleher has also been involved in Skinwalker Ranch since the start. So I think it's important to understand that this is not a case of the DoD taking interest in Skinwalker Ranch, but a case of Bigelow directing their interest there. Despite occasional claims by Bigelow, Kelleher, and others, paranormal phenomenon are not clearly documented at Skinwalker Ranch prior to the ownership of the Shermans in 1994, immediately before they sold the property to Bigelow. The exact details of this transaction, how Bigelow became aware of the property, etc., are opaque, but it presents a substantial possibility that the paranormal history was fabricated by the Shermans to motivate the sale. Bigelow and his various organizations (NIDSci, a more genera parascience and paranormal organization, and later BAAS, his aerospace company) have owned the ranch and been conducting research there for 27 years, and yet they have failed to produce any reasonable documentary evidence of the phenomenon. What they have produced is innumerable stories like this one, full of intrigue but absent of evidence. Some might see it as too dismissive to suggest that there isn't something paranormal at Skinwalker Ranch, but at this point people even in the UFO community are inclined to agree that Bigelow has made a huge effort and doesn't have anything to show for it. Bigelow's decision to completely close the property to entry by other researchers, and hiring a small security force to keep people out, has been taken as a bit of an affront. This coincided with his signing a number of media deals including a "Curse of Oak Island"-esque History Channel series, creating the appearance that Bigelow is more interested in finding funding and press than finding the truth. I have previously expressed my belief that Bigelow's involvement in DoD UAP programs, facilitated by Sen. Reid, was primarily an effort to obtain government funding to continue his Skinwalker Ranch pursuits. This article seems to support that perspective.
- jerrysievert 3y ago> Bigelow's decision to completely close the property to entry by other researchers, and hiring a small security force to keep people out, has been taken as a bit of an affront. This coincided with his signing a number of media deals including a "Curse of Oak Island"-esque History Channel series, creating the appearance that Bigelow is more interested in finding funding and press than finding the truth. as noted in the linked article, Bigelow sold the ranch to Brandon Fugal, who has continued research with a private team, closed off access, and now has two television shows about the ranch and other phenomena.