4 ms·
I may be reading it a bit defensively, but the article seems to be trivializing mass movements; "Oh it's just the middle class griping because they don't have a
by JKCalhoun 3y ago
I may be reading it a bit defensively, but the article seems to be trivializing mass movements; "Oh it's just the middle class griping because they don't have a private jet."
That mass movements coincide with a period of "betterment" is an interesting way to try to understand the civil rights and equal rights movements in the 50's and 60's. When the classes are no longer merely struggling to put food on the table they can rise up and demand something better than separate but equal education. And the comfortable and educated middle class white population had nothing to lose by joining those causes.
At the same time if there is a growing frustration among the masses now I have no doubt it is being fueled by a wealth inequity that seems to shower all the accolades of life on a very select few. And not just private jets and private islands but exemption as well from the laws that govern the rest of us.
Unlike many of my progressive friends, I understand the root frustration of the MAGA crowd and see something there that we are all frustrated about — those of us on both (all) sides.
(As an aside, I discourage friends and family (and any who will listen) from having anything to do with any movement that embraces violence — whether on the "right" or "left". Because I believe any successful movement that relies on violence to succeed will then rule with violence. Not cool.)
- Michelangelo11 3y ago> That mass movements coincide with a period of "betterment" is an interesting way to try to understand the civil rights and equal rights movements in the 50's and 60's. These are specifically not what the author was talking about, since they had clearly defined goals that were achieved, as per: > The True Believer advises against supporting organizations without clear, attainable objectives. The dockyard philosopher reminds us that we should be skeptical of mass movements without clearly defined goals.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoI don't have a history background but I assume that the desegregation of schools for blacks and equal pay for women (and reproductive freedom since it just popped into my mind) seem pretty clearly defined.
- Michelangelo11 3y agoYes. That is the point I was trying to make.
- somedude895 3y agoEqual pay for women isn't a movement. Modern feminism is the movement, and there this quote becomes relevant: > Mass movements that are good at what they do make previously content individuals frustrated and further frustrate their adherents while pretending to advance the movement. This means that the strongest mass movements are inevitably going to be the ones that are the best at not delivering the goods. Equal pay for equal work is pretty much achieved and the so-called gender wage gap is extremely misleadingly used to foster frustration.
- pstuart 3y ago> Equal pay for equal work is pretty much achieved Perhaps not? * https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/03/01/gender-pay-gap-facts/ * https://www.epi.org/blog/gender-wage-gap-widens-even-as-low-wage-workers-see-strong-gains-women-are-paid-roughly-22-less-than-men-on-average/
- eduction 3y agoI’m very curious for an example of a mass movement without clearly defined goals. Even USSR communism, Naziism, and the cultural revolution in China had clear goals. Cults have clear goals. Hate groups have clear goals. Seems orthogonal to his thesis about mass movements arising from personal emotional issues. Maybe he means narrow vs broad goals, but given the absurd breadth of his poorly defined hypothesis (irony alert) I’m not inclined to try and make his thesis clear for him.
- philwelch 3y ago> I’m very curious for an example of a mass movement without clearly defined goals. The first one that comes to mind was Occupy Wall Street. BLM also suffered from this to some degree.
- pstuart 3y agoThe MAGA movement does not seem to have any clear goals; the general theme I discern from it is "burn it all to the ground" (a literal quote from a supporter). Some of their grievances are legitimate (government failures, the decline of relative prosperity) and others are "understandable" (the fear and dislike of "others" that they are uncomfortable with (LGBQT+, different religions and races, the decline of the default dominance of their alphas (white men)), the defining name of their movement is as vague as can be. That is, what is the specific greatness to be returned to and what does achieving it look like?
- nobody9999 3y ago>The MAGA movement does not seem to have any clear goals; the general theme I discern from it is "burn it all to the ground" (a literal quote from a supporter). I took a trip to New Hampshire this past week and noted a banner on a house that read: Trump 2024 Make the liberals cry! Which seems like a pretty clear goal to me. Achieving such a goal does absolutely nothing to make my home (the United States) a better place for anyone, including those who support such a goal. Rather, it just drives division and makes reasonable compromise more difficult. Which will likely just make addressing the legitimate grievances (and there absolutely legitimate grievances) such folks have impossible to alleviate. >Some of their grievances are legitimate (government failures, the decline of relative prosperity) and others are "understandable" (the fear and dislike of "others" that they are uncomfortable with (LGBQT+, different religions and races, the decline of the default dominance of their alphas (white men)), the defining name of their movement is as vague as can be. Absolutely. At the same time, the "cultural" portions of the above list can be credibly addressed by simply allowing folks to live their own lives. Want to be an Evangelical Christian? Go for it! Think sex with someone of a particular gender isn't right? Don't do it. Think abortion is wrong? Don't have one. But considering those who believe differently on a few points, especially in a nation where the vast majority of us agree on most things, the enemy is counterproductive in the extreme. The vast majority of us just want a decent chance at having a good life, regardless of other issues. Adopting the attitude that those who disagree with you about specific things are evil and must be eradicated is, IMHO, reductive in the extreme and almost guarantees that the issues the vast majority of us can agree upon won't be addressed. And that's sad.
- shigawire 3y ago>Unlike many of my progressive friends, I understand the root frustration of the MAGA crowd After hundreds of think pieces about this, I think very few progressives don't understand the root frustrations here. We just find the outlet for that frustration hopelessly misguided.
- mistermann 3y agoFor a certain definition of "understand", and no verification mechanism.
- sneak 3y agoAll rulers rule with violence, in every country on Earth, throughout all time, up to and including all countries in the present day. That's what makes them rulers. Without the willingness to both a) use violence and b) claim the legitimacy of same, you're just some dude in a robe.
- jonahx 3y agoIf you construe "violence" broadly enough, then yes, this is true. But a broad interpretation misses most of the nuance that matters in practice. If you conceive of state violence instead as something like "the probability that you will get tortured, or beaten, or lose your money or property for things like speaking out against those in power", then the original statement is no longer true, and there are stark differences between living in modern western democracies and actually violent regimes -- which of course there are.
- LocalH 3y agoThe concept is literally called the "monopoly on violence".
- civilitty 3y agoThe “monopoly on violence” just means that the government is the only one that can legitimately use force to enforce its rules. No polity has an actual monopoly on violence within its borders because anyone can make a shiv and stab someone or start their own violent gang or militia.
- onetimeusename 3y agoI don't know that I buy it because the Nazi and German Communist movements had their roots in the defeat of WWI, a monarch who resigned, radical changes in government, and the hyper-inflationary period of the Weimar. It was even predicted that the Treaty of Versailles would be ruinous. Although I am sure someone will disagree, it's hard to see how there were many improvements to life prior to about 1920 for German people that would cause frustration in the way described. I think it's still possible some movements are directly a result of lack of improvement.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]