4 ms·
This is what happens when radical political ideology clashes with technical rationality. If only Orwell were alive today...
by userbinator 3y ago
This is what happens when radical political ideology clashes with technical rationality. If only Orwell were alive today...
- christofosho 3y agoCan you explain what you mean?
- userbinator 3y agoExtremists have taken accepted standard terminology completely out of context and interpreted it in the worst possible way, using it as a weapon to turn STEM into an environment where (often fabricated!) emotions triumph over rational thought. One might say that this "inclusiveness" has also lead to the inclusion of idiots.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoIt really hurts me as an educator, because of course we need to adopt the updated wording because we are sensitive to the changing times and morals, but we also need to make sure that students are aware of the old terms so that they are not unduly confused when they get into the real world, because out there, you're going to find a lot of legacy code and legacy documentation, and most importantly, legacy people like me. At fifty years of age and never much for PC terminology, I am having difficulty adjusting my vocabulary to the "new normal" particularly some things which had come so naturally, such as pronouning people I don't know. I am just thankful that I don't work over real-time video, so I can adjust and correct my writing if I slip up.
- danbruc 3y agoMaster and slave are just words, sequences of letters, the meaning is in peoples heads and may be context dependent. Never in my life have I thought of slavery when I had to deal with those words in a technical context. I mean, I get the intention, if we would coin those terms today, then we would surely pick terms without this historical burden. But now that those terms have been widely used for a long time, trying to change language in countless standards, books, code bases, peoples heads, ... that just does not seem quite reasonable.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> But now that those terms have been widely used for a long time, trying to change language in countless standards, books, code bases, peoples heads, ... that just does not seem quite reasonable You know that there are other terms which have been widely used for a long time that we have successfully changed (most) people's minds about using? It is entirely reasonable to do.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoNot only that, but there are a number of terms which are "updated" on a regular basis because they inevitably take on a derogatory connotation and must be euphemized repeatedly. I feel that this is often unreasonable political correctness. In fact, it's a non-Inclusive practice. One effect of updating the language is that you exclude people of a certain generation. So you can identify and out and then segregate people based on the terminology they use. Are you familiar with "shibboleths"? Happens all the time. What the IETF is doing here is creating shibboleths for the next generation of IT professionals to separate themselves from the previous generation, who may not be careful enough to update our language.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> One effect of updating the language is that you exclude people of a certain generation. Your argument is that making language more inclusive is, in fact, exclusionary because people of certain generations are, presumably, incapable of updating their language and thus will continue to go around saying the old, exclusionary things and thus being shunned by the younger generations? Do you not want to think about that for a bit and consider how utterly ludicrous in sounds in the face of, y'know, reality?
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoExcerpts from Rules for Radicals by Saul Alinsky: 3. "Whenever possible go outside the expertise of the enemy" 4. "Make the enemy live up to its own book of rules." 5. "Ridicule is man's most potent weapon. There is no defense. It is almost impossible to counterattack ridicule. Also it infuriates the opposition, who then react to your advantage." 8. "Keep the pressure on." 11. "If you push a negative hard and deep enough it will break through into its counterside; this is based on the principle that every positive has its negative." 13. "Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it."
- defrost 3y agoOrwell the famously committed democratic socialist who sought to promote a more egalitarian and fairer society? That Orwell? I imagine he'd be writing an essay asking why this hadn't happened sooner and whether a better pairing of words than Leader/Follower could have been found.
- namdnay 3y agoWhy is it clashing? There’s nothing more “rational” about one set of terms than the other. The whole thing is a bit silly IMHO, but … meh? If Orwell were alive he’d be worried about far more important things than what terms some of the worlds wealthiest professionals are using to describe their tools
- nonomoreplease 3y ago[flagged]
- gnfargbl 3y ago...then as a lifelong leftist and champion of precision and clarity in writing, he would perhaps have applauded the choice of language which is both inclusive and technically exact?
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoI don’t really understand the divisiveness of changes like this at all. I already say “allowlist” and “denylist” habitually. Whether or not that matches my sociopolitical ideology, that’s just where the industry is at this point, so I’m there too. Everything in technology is constantly changing, and that is neither good nor bad in my view. It seems strange to be outraged by a change in vernacular when that’s amongst the easiest changes we face in industry generally. I say, save the anger for when SAP stops investing in on-prem, when Azure signing keys are compromised, when your storage vendor loses your data, or when your upstream vendor changes licenses on you, etc.
- pavlov 3y agoIf this terminology was more explicitly sexually tinted instead, the American right would have no problem with changing it “to protect the children.” But because it’s associated with a legacy of systemic violence, suddenly changing it is an offense to civilization that would have Orwell turning in his grave. You see this same bizarre logic in the new education laws in Florida. It’s bad to tell children about human sexuality. It’s fine to tell them about human violence. But it’s very bad to tell them about society’s role in violence.
- scrollaway 3y agoYou really think if entrenched terminology had potential sexual connotations, people wouldn’t make a fuss for it being changed? You must not have met humans.
- pavlov 3y agoIf the original terms had been “cock/pussy”, I don’t think many people would be up in arms about changing it. And if you think that’s ridiculous because nobody would ever have named database components something so obviously offensive, that’s the whole point. Norms change. There was a time just 50-60 years ago when sexual harassment in workplaces was much more accepted than today. Similarly non-inclusive language was much more accepted a few decades ago. In both cases many men have trouble adapting and think it’s a sign of decline of society that their assumptions are being challenged.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoSo we're not allowed to label connectors as "male/female" anymore, because that's transphobic. It seems like peak science denialism to me, and it's ironic that we were already, 30 years ago, using terms like "gender-changer" when discussing these connectors too. Frankly it seems to me that most modern connectors are trans already: is USB-C male or female? Both?
- scrollaway 3y ago
- krapp 3y ago[flagged]
- dwb 3y agoWhat exactly is the technical reality that ties us to the terms "master" and "slave", or means that we can't change them if enough people think that's good?
- ukj 3y agoYou mean other than the decades of connotation lost by switching terminology and the innevitable miscommunication that will ensue? There's nothing wrong with switching the term "red" for the term "carmine", "scarlet" or "ruby" either. They are synonymous on paper, but the latter simply doesn't evoke the same recall in people's heads. You are welcome to run the experiment yourself. Go and ask people if they normally stop at (carmine|scarlet|ruby) traffic lights and observe the ensuing confusion at your question. Then there is the emergent discrepancy in terminology between legacy systems and current RFCs.
- dwb 3y agoI don't find this at all convincing. The terms in question here don't need to evoke connotation, they are labels in a technical system. It is very straight-forward to re-label things. Documentation can easily cover the change.
- ukj 3y agoAnd I don't find it convincing that you don't find it convincing. All terms evoke connotation. That's how and why language works. Which is why I proposed the social experiment for you. Go ahead and replace the word "red" with the word "scarlet" in your day-to-day vocabulary and see if communication with other humans breaks down. Update the documentation as necessary.
- dwb 3y agoYou're generalising far too much. Of course replacing "red" with "scarlet" generally would make a difference in understanding, not least because "scarlet" is more specific than "red". But that doesn't at all speak to what is going on in this RFC, which is already technical documentation and very specific. If you want to talk about connotation, the entire point here is to get rid of terms that connote horrific crimes. Maybe not to you, but clearly to enough people that this change has been made.
- flangola7 3y ago[flagged]