3 ms·
I don't like the deus ex machina trick of turning Gandalf the Grey into Gandalf the White. That's like Spock's inner eye lid. BTW the primary actors are Sam a
by croes 3y ago
I don't like the deus ex machina trick of turning Gandalf the Grey into Gandalf the White.
That's like Spock's inner eye lid.
BTW the primary actors are Sam and Frodo and their friendship where one carries the burden of the ring and the other carries his friend.
- morelisp 3y agoI don't think you can criticize "deus ex machina" as a plot device when it's, from go, literally "ex deus" - Gandalf is on a mission (/ missions) from god, and Eru's not gonna let him get off so easily.
- Ntrails 3y agoIt's arguable whether you want to describe the wizards as 'Mortal' in the first place. The return of Gandalf never much bothered me, it fit well enough.
- croes 3y agoJust because it's literally ex deus doesn't make it less ex deus. Ex deus is cheap
- morelisp 3y agoThe more critical part is "from go" - deus ex machina is considered bad because it's a narrative rupture. In a story of wars openly involving divine beings, there's no such discontinuity. It is also usually associated with stories that wrap up a bit too tidily, and that's also not the case in LotR. Gandalf dies 2/6 of the way through the story and comes back 3/6 of the way through. His death may be the climax of the first two books, but his return is merely a plot beat and many of the remaining problems have yet to even be revealed, let alone solved.
- rightbyte 3y agoYou don't think the plot was put out in advance for Gandalf to not die in Moria? Or what do you mean? I guess he had to disappear for the fellowship to break up. If I remember correctly, you don't get to know that he technically did die in Moria. That is background lore.
- croes 3y agoTricking the reader to think he died to let him return more powerful when he is needed. That's comic book logic. Boromir's death was far better plotwise.
- morelisp 3y agoHe doesn't return more powerful, he returns with a different mandate. He is no more or less powerful as he was before, rather he is "licensed" by Eru to reveal more of it as Saruman has abdicated that role, and Gandalf had been the only faithful Istari of the five - dying being a critical part of that.
- croes 3y agoAccording to Tolkien he is more powerful >What Gandalf did was what the Authority wished. The "wizards" were failures as they had been and needed enhancement to match the gravity of the crisis. Gandalf's sacrifice was accepted so he was returned in an enhanced state (more power and wisdom). The old Gandalf could not have dealt with Théoden or Saruman as he was able after his enhancement https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Letter_156 https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Letter_156
- wolverine876 3y agoIt was based on the Bible and the Resurrection. Tolkien was an observant Catholic and openly talked about the religious elements in LOTR. For example, the description of Gandalf's white rainments are similar to Jesus's in the Gospels.