4 ms·
Australia eyes UK online bill in fight with tech companies
- darkclouds 3y agoBit late knowing that Starlink exists.
- neilalexander 3y agoMakes absolutely zero difference whether Starlink exists or not. These companies are still subject to laws on the ground and if they don’t want to comply, they will simply be refused regulatory approval to operate.
- darkclouds 3y ago>These companies are still subject to laws on the ground and if they don’t want to comply, they will simply be refused regulatory approval to operate. And how do these govt's prove non compliance, unless they hack these companies, kind of setting a bad example.
- neilalexander 3y agoAre you kidding? Literally all someone in government has to do is to buy a Starlink subscription and see whether or not it allows them to do something the regulations shouldn’t allow them to do. They could also just refuse Starlink a license to operate in that country unless they can prove by audit that certain measures are being taken. Or they could just refuse a license to operate regardless.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago"Won't someone please think of the children?" attempt no. 1739358
- fsflover 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalypse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...
- roenxi 3y agoI'm sure that compromising the Facebook and Google ecosystems will be really convenient for law enforcement, but realistically how much of an effect will this have on child safety? We have DoH, HTTPS and VPNs. Russia hasn't managed to shut down encrypted messages. Even China as far as I know has failed, people can still use VPNs. So while I know this isn't really about children, how can they even pretend? It is the internet. You can't stop the big players in illegal industries communicating with encrypted messages. This most reasonable explanation here is that this is targeted at average Facebook users and the authorities want to snoop.
- defrost 3y agoI'm no fan of rock spiders but these measures will impact everybody with minimal impact on a tiny percentage of offenders that traditionally Australian Government has been all to happy to overlook. Travesties such as Bindoon Boys Town *, Castledare, Clontarf and Tardun operated in plain sight without any reliance on encryption. As pointed out in the linked article, traffic analysis with no access to message content reveals more than enough information to focus CSAM investigations on highly probable targets: “The work that we’re doing to detect behavioural signals on our services is really effective here,” he said in February. “A user who is part of a sophisticated criminal enterprise has different behaviour on encrypted services than an ordinary user. “Even if we are not able to see the content, there’s some pretty effective work we’ve been able to do to analyse the metadata based on the behaviour of the individuals involved.” * https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/australasia/bindoon-boys-town-the-sad-truth-behind-britain-s-lost-children-1782544.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/australasia/bindoon...
- stOneskull 3y agothat is a horribly saddening article. i can't imagine the pain those kids went though. why are people so evil?
- traceroute66 3y agoNot sure why anybody is remotely surprised. As a reminder, this comes to you from the country whose Prime Minister said: “The laws of mathematics are very commendable, but the only law that applies in Australia is the law of Australia".
- pepepepe13 3y ago[flagged]
- defrost 3y agoPeak Turnball .. who was a short(ish) term Liberal (right wing conservative) PM. The Morrison Government (last but one, also Liberal) was more worryingly dystopian bringing a frisson of mini-Trump, reality distortion, Marketing 101 BS, and evangelical fervour to a post that traditionally didn't see all those elements colliding and turned up to 11. Our current Government (Labour .. but not the old Labour) is continuing to trade on reality distortion to some degree and sliding further into bed with the US than might be advisable. https://johnmenadue.com/us-australia-force-posture-agreement-undermines-sovereignty-must-be-terminated/ https://johnmenadue.com/us-australia-force-posture-agreement... Who really wants to be Airstrip One in the Sino-'Merkin War?
- seydor 3y agotech & the state are increasingly converging (after all, governments are informational entities). At some not very distant point they re going to merge, and it seems like centralized states are already ahead.
- version_five 3y agoFor a lot of purposes government is already irrelevant and tech is the "authority".
- stOneskull 3y agobecause pedos exist, we're all slaves. privacy is good. it comes first, as does the individual, as does the family. privacy is good for children too. it keep the snoops out of your sharing personal communications with your loved ones.
- weebull 3y agoBecause people lust for power, we are all slaves.
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoI'm fully expecting my government (UK) to work out a way to implement thought crime and pre-crime law. Surely that's their ultimate goal.
- dist-epoch 3y agoInstead of framing it as a fight for child safety, they need to use a more acceptable message - a fight against racists and white supremacy extremists: > Today, as extremist groups are expelled from Facebook and Twitter, they migrate to social networks like Gab and encrypted chat platforms like Signal. In the attack on the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, anti-government groups like the Oath Keepers coordinated their movements over the walkie-talkie app Zello, for instance. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/26/us/louis-beam-white-supremacy-internet.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/26/us/louis-beam-white-supre... > Far-right groups move online conversations from social media to chat apps — and out of view of law enforcement https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/01/15/parler-telegram-chat-apps/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/01/15/parler-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- andrewstuart 3y agoI’m nearly out of outrage. I wish I could leave Australia for a country that makes better political decisions. It’s exhausting being constantly outraged by the bad political decisions.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoWhere's is the refuge though? UK? US? New Zealand is a beautiful country and it's politics is slightly better, I think, but then they did let the US do a US-style raid on a personal residence in New Zealand, so they also have form in licking the boot that's stamping on their face.
- grecy 3y agoI left Australia for Canada, and I'm extremely happy I did. It's not perfect, but there's a lot more ability here to live the life you want - just work 4 days a week, or maybe 6 months a year. Out West it's perfectly acceptable for a 20-something or 30-something or 40-something to say "actually, I'd like to go to work less and live more". People are very accepting of that. So the priority is not simply to work more, but to find a life that is fulfilling and enjoyable for you. I really like that. When I was recently in Australia I had dozens and dozens of people confront me and tell me that I need to "get a real job" and all of that. I also feel strongly that somewhere along the line Australia's lost the plot and now the purpose of life is going to work, getting insurance and saving for retirement. I was once told "Australian's don't know how to live, they just die slowly". I've spent a few thousand hours thinking about that, and the more I saw of Australia the more I found it to be generally true. It was also extremely eye-opening to realize how cut-off from the world Australia is, and how the media & politicians there can basically say whatever they want, and Australian's swallow it down hook and all because they have nothing to easily fact or reality check it against. (I say this as someone who lived 24 years in Australia, studied Engineering at University, etc. etc.) After spending 18 months in Australia last year and driving all over the entire country, I know for 100% certain I will never live there again.
- throw492 3y agoHaving been based in Ontario for 5 years I can safely say that it is much more career and work driven than Sydney or Melbourne. Many personal interactions are all around "networking" and can be extremely transactional at times. After visiting BC and Alberta for the first time you can feel a different mode of operation, its good to know this is really the case
- sys_64738 3y agoAus will get added to Britain with geo-locking out these territories.
- moribvndvs 3y agoAuthoritarians gonna authoritarian.
- ajb 3y agoIt's not too surprising that this bill is going through easily (in the UK) because the media campaign against it has been crap. The major takeaway I get is that techies are butthurt about not being listened to. And yet there are major risks for every parent and grandparent in the country that should be easy to vicerally bring home to the ordinary voter. What happens if this goes through? Every picture sent in the country gets scanned for possible child abuse. Will the scanning optimise for accurately detecting it and not accusing innocents? No, it will be optimised to pass the buck as hard as possible[1], because the tech companies don't want to business of taking the blame when some pedophile isn't caught. Who is the second level of review? Maybe some minimum wage zero-hours subcontractor at Serco or Group 4 Security. But that's probably it - once the image has been labelled 'bad' no-one else will want to look at it. So, even if you are sending a picture of your own child to your own mother, you have at the very least to have to think about whether it could be mistaken for child abuse by someone you don't know who has about 5 seconds to look at it and is probably from a completely different culture. Quite likely outcomes are that social workers will be sent round to interview lots of innocent parents, who they are primed to suspect are pedophiles, and that there will be an uptick in children being removed from innocent parents. Yet none of this has been brought up in the media either by tech companies or by privacy activists. [1] The other option is that the tech companies abdicate completely and just use some black box from the government to scan every picture. Problems with that left as an exercise...
- ksec 3y ago>The major takeaway I get is that techies are butthurt about not being listened to. I am totally against the bill, but the government has wanted revenge and it is one of the biggest middle finger to US tech companies as they have been insanely arrogant in the past.
- SenAnder 3y agoThey could take revenge by gutting software patents, or promoting open-source software and right to repair that doesn't enrich and hand control to US corporations. But no, the chief target and victim of this "revenge" is the Australian and UK public. Tech companies wouldn't even be harmed, only their users.
- SenAnder 3y agoNext step: audio monitoring in pubs and restaurants to solve the going-dark problem of face-to-face conversations, exploited by pedophiles. The step after that: audio/video monitoring in private homes, since that is where most child abuse happens. The step after: a mandatory government minder to accompany families with children on hikes and other excursions away from surveillance. Or maybe just ankle monitors for all.
- psychphysic 3y agoIf the law passes much of the world will look to replicate
- Cypher 3y ago[flagged]
- pepepepe13 3y ago[flagged]