4 ms·
Who’s Afraid of Lorne Michaels?
- Waterluvian 3y agoLorne Michaels really seems to have a talent for understanding talent and seeing the bigger picture in it all. The more I read about Conan getting Late Night to replace Letterman, the more I thought, “what kind of madman would put some writer like that on such a perch? Madness!” But Conan is arguably one of the greatest. I feel like a lot of industry people are successful because of connections or simply through volume. But Lorne’s bibliography really makes it hard to think the same. P.S. Pete Davidson has quite a story to tell and I enjoy him at times, but I still don’t understand what he was doing on SNL. It was like they just pulled “that guy” from the friend group who said, “pffft I could do that.” Improv is one of those things that really looks easy but there’s ridiculous depth and talent to being consistently good at it.
- fineIllregister 3y ago> I still don’t understand what he was doing on SNL. It was like they just pulled “that guy” from the friend group who said, “pffft I could do that.” Improv... SNL isn't improvised. Also I've never heard anyone claim Pete Davidson has improv ability.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoSNL players are often drawn from those who are experienced in improv. In fact, as a live show, the players are often forced to improv due to circumstances, and you may find that some of the most famous, funniest lines/scenes were improv. The writers change up the script until the last second, anyway, so the players are usually just as surprised at their lines as anyone. As a recent example, "Lisa from Temecula", there was much discussion whether Ego's retort "oh, cuz we Black?!" was improv, and also, as a sketch that was nearly cut from the lineup, they decided to run it with a hilarious shaking table, which was the source of Pascal's surprise and laughter, and infectious to the rest of the cast.
- pfranz 3y agoI've always heard that Lorne is famously against improvisation while shooting. There have been numerous examples over the years of people getting in trouble for doing it. Here's one article [1]. There are very minor changes that don't seem to cause problems. Bill Hader talked about Fred Armisen's delivery of "What are you doing here?" in the first Californians sketch being different when shooting causing him to have trouble keeping from laughing. This article [2] says, “Oh, ’cause we Black?” was added ahead of the run-through, but camera direction changed and not everyone was informed who the camera would be showing as it was delivered. [1] https://www.slashfilm.com/1225418/why-lorne-michaels-doesnt-want-improv-on-saturday-night-live/ https://www.slashfilm.com/1225418/why-lorne-michaels-doesnt-... [2] https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2023/02/snl-lisa-from-temecula-sketch-oral-history https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2023/02/snl-lisa-from-t...
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoAh, thanks for pointing this out! Yeah, I was unaware of how little of it there really is. It does make a lot of sense, of course. And the cast is often maligned for their poor eye contact and wooden reading of the cue cards, so it's clear to see how they're under orders to stick to the scripts. Considering how much improv background some of them have, they may begin to resent that!
- jakubmazanec 3y agoMy favorite example of improv that made it to air is Space, The Infinite Frontier: Dr. Kent Wahler. Here https://youtu.be/gQDqRlMeJ4U?si=rRNKw2TZyyV3xcLR&t=177 https://youtu.be/gQDqRlMeJ4U?si=rRNKw2TZyyV3xcLR&t=177 is when Will Ferrel realizes he improvised too much and Jeff Goldblum is too confused, and steers back.
- fineIllregister 3y agoSNL hires a lot of people with improv background because that's where comedy makers are. They hire just as many people from stand-up backgrounds, because that's the other place comedians are. Last year's new four were all stand-up, like Pete Davidson. Improv players are in a good position because being able to create comedy in the moment (improv) is a good proxy for being able to create comedy over a week (SNL). Writing is so important to SNL that players must either write themselves or partner with a writer to get airtime. Some of the best moments were improvised, for sure, but they're not planning on it (obviously) and they're not depending on it. The sibling comment said enough about that. > The writers change up the script until the last second, anyway, so the players are usually just as surprised at their lines as anyone. Yeah, it's written. They're reading the lines. Not improvised. Obviously they're bringing creativity to it in their acting, but they've heard it in pitch meeting, they've contributed to writing it, they've heard it at table read, they've heard it at dress rehearsal, maybe a line on the cue card has changed. There are moments of improvisation, but SNL is emphatically not improv.
- paulcole 3y agoPete Davidson is young, cool, and funny. Why wouldn’t he be on SNL?
- khazhoux 3y agoHis voice is very personal and very unlike the standard writing on SNL. At first I couldn't figure out why he was cast. But once he started doing his material on Weekend Update about his own life, it was clear that he brought something new and different.
- willcipriano 3y agoPete Davidson is funny? I just assumed SNL pivoted away from comedy or something.
- paulcole 3y agoYeah it’s strange. I think SNL peaked when I was 19 and my dad says the exact same thing about when he was 19.
- hotnfresh 3y agoIt’s had multiple good and bad runs, usually lasting a few years each—the show’s been on a long time—so rather than this being one of those “everyone thinks X was best when they were age Y” you could both kinda be right.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoI agree that he's young.
- pbj1968 3y agoConan has been cringe and terrible since he got a TV show. He wrote a few decent Simpsons episodes.
- rileymat2 3y agoI disagree that he is terrible, but I do appreciate your comment, because he was that sort of cringe comedy before I had a name for it, now that I think of it.
- hoten 3y agoNo one person writes an episode of TV, at least not the Simpsons.
- browningstreet 3y agoI can’t stand Leno or Conan and like Pete Davidson. That’s all.
- tadfisher 3y agoConan replaced Jay Leno on the Tonight Show, not Letterman.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoConan famously replaced Letterman on Late Night, not the Tonight Show, in 1993, and built his empire on that show. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Night_with_Conan_O%27Brien https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Late_Night_with_Conan_O%27Brie...
- twirlip 3y agoI think of Lorne Michaels holds a similar place in culture as did Hugh Hefner. SNL was highly influential, but has been coasting on eroding cultural relevance since the internet became more interesting than broadcast television. Comics are discovering they don't need an impresario or producer as they did in the more rarefied entertainment environment of the past.
- jjfoooo4 3y agoHe’s an extremely prolific producer. I happened to watch The Other Two and Detroiters the other day, both produced by him. Tim Robinson from Detroiters went on to make I Think You Should Leave
- whoevencares 3y agoBut SNL and Lorne are not synonymous - his reach has extended far beyond that show.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> Comics are discovering they don't need an impresario or producer as they did in the more rarefied entertainment environment of the past. Are they? I highly doubt it. I disagreed with a ton of stuff in this article, but I think the points it made about the comedy business are pretty spot on: hardly anyone can make an actual living in comedy, and getting your big break on SNL is still one of surest ways to be able to make a living (and then some) in comedy. It's not the only way (and the article concedes as much), but the legions of people posting comedy web series or doing stand-up in local clubs definitely have day jobs, and tons (most?) of these people still dream about getting on SNL someday.
- shrubble 3y agoMy personal view is that SCTV was head and shoulders above SNL; shame that it only became a cult classic later. The "3CP1" (CCCP) spoof episode with Cold War era Moscow hijacking the Melonville satellite uplink and the "Queen Haters" punk rock sketch from Mel's Rock Pile, with its prophetic "I feel sorry for you Lady Di, having a mother-in-law like that" being two of my personal favorites.
- johnohara 3y agoAgree. In the same vein was Fridays featuring Melanie Chartoff, Larry David, and Michael Richards. Also live, also funny. And, if I may, a tip of the hat to Howard Cosell for the "original" Saturday Night Live whose name NBC began using only after Howard was cancelled.
- peteforde 3y agoI read this as carefully as intended, and I did not like it or feel compelled by the many arguments it tries so hard to make. What leaves me frustrated by pieces like this really amounts to: in practical and literal terms, what do you want Lorne Michaels to do? Because it kind of sounds like you want him to apologize for existing while slowly lowering himself into a vat of acid, live on television. To be clear, I have always sort of assumed that Lorne Michaels is a crazy asshole who I would not enjoy spending time with. However, my strong suspicion that he's also a savant at picking talent has been repeatedly reinforced by listening to Dana Carvey and David Spade talk to former castmates on their Fly on the Wall podcast. (which is great listening, btw) There are always going to people who are pissed off that something they don't like appears to be working better than anything else has, before or since. This essay is that. I would bet real money that the author would accept a cast role if it was offered to them; a sort of cynical "hate the game, not the player" shrug. As for Seth and Tina not speaking out about Sanz: I have a hard time imagining either of them holding back if something was upsetting them. To me, this suggests that perhaps they know (or believe) something that the author of the essay doesn't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- khazhoux 3y ago> To be clear, I have always sort of assumed that Lorne Michaels is a crazy asshole who I would not enjoy spending time with. However, my strong suspicion that he's also a savant at picking talent has been repeatedly reinforced by listening to Dana Carvey and David Spade talk to former castmates on their Fly on the Wall podcast. (which is great listening, btw) But from Fly On The Wall (yes, a great podcast), you also learn that Lorne is not actually an asshole. He's intimidating, cold, unapproachable, and sometimes snarky, but I don't think a single story on that podcast casts him as actually mean. In fact, a lot of them say how Lorne picked them up when they were down, with just a few on-point words. Like, when Dana Carvey was worried he wouldn't be able to get back into the game after a long slump, Lorne simply said to him: "Dana... everybody knows you." And that gave him the confidence boost he needed.
- jeffgreco 3y ago
- xyzelement 3y agoArticle felt off to me. Was curious about author, not much on his site. Then this: https://cris-italia.medium.com/seth-simons-is-not-a-journalist-71ec06bdafe2 https://cris-italia.medium.com/seth-simons-is-not-a-journali... Explains what I picked up
- jeffgreco 3y agoWhat on earth is this linked piece? Bizarre behavior.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThanks very much for posting this - I got a similar vibe (and I'm also getting the sense a lot of these comments here are just about the title and from folks that didn't actually read the article). Basically, it felt like the author was trying to weave a narrative that Lorne Michaels is as toxic as, say, Scott Rubin ( https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/everyone-just-knows-hes-an-absolute-monster-scott-rudins-ex-staffers-speak-out-on-abusive-behavior-4161883/ https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/everyone... ), but his evidence just came off as way, way weaker, and so in the end it felt like a hit piece to me. My guess is a better analogy is someone like Anna Wintour: someone notorious for being demanding and difficult to work with, but also someone who engenders loyalty of people that work with her - more of a "very tough but ultimately fair" sort of vibe.
- jrflowers 3y agoIf anybody is wondering why that article feels off, Cris Italia was responding to this article wherein he was called out for pretty obviously pushing vaccine-autism stuff in October of 2020. https://sethsimons.substack.com/p/the-comedy-club-owner-with-a-background https://sethsimons.substack.com/p/the-comedy-club-owner-with...
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoMan, both these people come off as weirdly assholish to me. I mean, look at the title of the article you posted: "The Comedy Club Owner With a Background Questioning Vaccine Safety- Come with me down a disturbing rabbit hole." Why would I give a fuck that a comedy club owner is questioning vaccine safety? Last I checked comedy club owners aren't setting medical policy, and it's not like they have the broad reach to influence social policy. People are still allowed to believe whatever the hell they want, even if it's dumb. The "Come with me down a disturbing rabbit hole" subtitle sounds like something from a junior BuzzFeed intern.
- khazhoux 3y agoSummary: * Lorne is racist because there's not more minorities * Lorne is sexist because some of the cast have been accused of harassment * Lorne should not just hire comedians he himself thinks are funny * Lorne is bad because too many people owe their careers to him
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whoevencares 3y agoI heard he has doggedly refused to personally become a female, minority cast member.
- culturthrowaway 3y agoThe very first thing to do when clicking through to an article about SNL is obviously to ctrl-f G-I-L-L... 0 results. Okay, probably not going to bother, it looks pretty long. Then I notice the author. Crazy lol.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> funniness—the power to reach inside your body and give you sudden, uncontrollable pleasure—is usually the most obvious and therefore least interesting thing about it That's something only a person in the business would say. For the audience, funniness is the only thing that matters.
- itisit 3y agoIt’s funny how such an unfunny show works to promote and train a steady flow of talent. I wonder what will become the next mainstream comedy breeding ground after Lorne calls it quits. Given the show’s ratings (and relevance) decline since the 90s, I imagine we’ll see SNL wrap it up within the decade. I’m not sure it will be missed.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI literally could of have posted your exact same comment in any year of the past 40 (replacing the "decline since the xxs" with some previous decade), and it would have looked like a million similar comments of that time, and would gotten lots of "yeah, SNL was way funnier back in my day" responses. Yet obviously some people find it funny, or it wouldn't have been around for nearly 50 years.
- itisit 3y agoIt's not nostalgia for anything, as the show's never been to my taste. What I'm saying is the show's ratings are quite literally the worst they've ever been. Part of that is the general decline of linear tv and part is also the quality of the show itself. Were it not for its largely unchallenged time slot, it would have been off the air long ago.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dools 3y agoIf anyone is interested in some inside baseball discussions about SNL check out the fly on the wall podcast with Dana carvey and David spade it’s very enjoyable