7 ms·
I’d think defense attorneys would be all over that. “We’re suppose to take some ‘hacking company’’s word for it that they’re doing everything forensically corre
by kstrauser 3y ago
I’d think defense attorneys would be all over that. “We’re suppose to take some ‘hacking company’’s word for it that they’re doing everything forensically correctly, and the prosecution expects us to just trust them?”
Were I such an attorney, I’d campaign to taint the reputation of Cellebrite and make the evidence it generates completely untrustworthy.
- solarpunk 3y agoAll the ammunition you need for the last part is right here: https://signal.org/blog/cellebrite-vulnerabilities/ https://signal.org/blog/cellebrite-vulnerabilities/
- saagarjha 3y agoThis is quite frankly a farce of a PR stunt. “Oops we hacked the UFED we stole” is not going to fly in any reasonable court. There are proper ways to get evidence thrown out and trying to use the most petty way possible since it sells well is not it.
- yyyk 3y agoIt's way dumber than a PR stunt. Plenty of Signal users live in totalitarian dictatorships, where the law doesn't care if you're actually guilty. Even in democracies you can't always rely on the courts. "We're planting incriminating evidence on your phone" should lead to mass uninstall of Signal. Except nobody really believes they did that. Signal would be banned from all App Stores, and moxie would go to jail on so many charges. It's one of those nerd law ideas where 'you can't 100% prove it' is the golden defence except it isn't really - the law can call a bluff, especially when millions of users and multiple app stores already did. It says reasonable doubt, not any doubt.
- buzer 3y agoSomewhat similar thing does happens often with DNA evidence. Prosecution submits evidence where report was generated in proprietary software and company's employee testifies that the result is correct & tell the chance of false positive is 1 in 10 billion. Defense asks for access to source code to validate the claims and company says they are trade secrets & judge decides to not grant access and does not dismiss the evidence.
- rolph 3y agoPCR is the product of a drug user giving creedence to hallucinations https://www.iflscience.com/lsd-dna-pcr-the-strange-origins-of-a-biology-revolution-63126 https://www.iflscience.com/lsd-dna-pcr-the-strange-origins-o... https://archive.org/details/dancingnakedinmi00mull/mode/1up https://archive.org/details/dancingnakedinmi00mull/mode/1up https://archive.org/details/makingpcrstoryof00rabi/mode/1up https://archive.org/details/makingpcrstoryof00rabi/mode/1up
- Crontab 3y agoI have wondered if there are matches between different people in DNA databases and, if so, how often is happens.
- scheme271 3y agoDepends on the lengths of the sequences being compared but the birthday problem indicates that it's more common than you'd expect.
- tomatocracy 3y agoAt the very least there will be identical multiple births in some of them.
- Fatboyrunning 3y agoLet's say you're charged. They seize your phone and pull photographs, text messages, messenger logs, maps data, etc. The messages are inculpatory. What do you want to say? That the extraction method is unreliable, that the Police have incorrect logs? Imply that the text messages have been extracted with errors, somehow? That simply isn't the case. The data extracted is both reliable and probative. This is a copy and paste.
- CameronNemo 3y agoThe data extracted is both reliable and probative. This is a copy and paste. Debatable. https://signal.org/blog/cellebrite-vulnerabilities/ https://signal.org/blog/cellebrite-vulnerabilities/
- alluro2 3y agoOuch, that's pretty nasty. Also, I couldn't help but be amused by cheekiness: "By a truly unbelievable coincidence, I was recently out for a walk when I saw a small package fall off a truck ahead of me. As I got closer, the dull enterprise typeface slowly came into focus: Cellebrite. Inside, we found the latest versions of the Cellebrite software, a hardware dongle designed to prevent piracy (tells you something about their customers I guess!), and a bizarrely large number of cable adapters."
- heavyset_go 3y agoChain of custody matters and if there's an untrustworthy link in that chain it calls into question the validity of the evidence itself.
- Kostchei 3y agosure, but if the phone company says there was an sms, when you open the phone it looks like there is an sms, and cellebrite extracts one, which you then present in a nice power point to the court... then your accusation as to tapering with the evidence and where in the chain of custody it occurred had better be good, or all you are going to do is annoy the court (as someone with dozens , maybe hundred+, of cellebrite reports in various court records) This is what armchair lawyers tend to forget, especially coders tend to forget. The law is not code. The judge is not a complier. When the law does not represent reality (this guys sells drugs and uses his phone to do it being a common reality) , then it becomes news-worthy. But normally people just look at the reality and go "oh yes, this tool extracts the stuff on a phone and turns it into a pdf/html, how convenient". 99.99% of the time, the time a drug dealer alleging he has no knowledge of the 100's of deals on his phone is about as realistic as your 5 year old nephew with cake smeared on his face denying he ate the last bit of cake... and is treated as such. Should the act of selling drugs be a crime?- completely different topic.
- foooorsyth 3y ago>“We’re suppose to take some ‘hacking company’’s word for it that they’re doing everything forensically correctly, and the prosecution expects us to just trust them?” You'd be surprised. The courts are not scientific debate arenas. Burn forensics? Pseudoscience. Bite mark forensics? Pseudoscience. Lots of DNA-based forensics? Totally unreliable. Firearms ballistics forensics? Laughable pseudoscience. Polygraph tests? Laughable pseudoscience. Field sobriety tests / "drug recognition expert" certifications? Lol, lmao even. All of this nonsense has been successfully used to convict people in court. Turns out, putting someone with PhD after their name or a white lab coat or a phony certification on the stand tends to work for prosecutors.
- sgarland 3y agoHow is ballistics forensics unreliable? Genuinely curious, I’ve never heard that.
- adgjlsfhk1 3y agoSome of it (e.g. what bullet type) is real, but angles and distances are largely impossible to reliably.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- foooorsyth 3y agoIt’s pretty much just complete non-replicable BS. The claim is that the rifling on gun barrels differs from gun to gun, and that they can examine grooves made in the bullets by the rifling and compare them to other rounds shot through the same barrel and find a match. It doesn’t stand up to independent scrutiny, and I would imagine that with modern machining the gun to gun differences in rifling on the same mass produced guns are minimal. Perhaps there are differences in fowling in well-used guns, but the notion that they’re gonna match a flattened bullet to a specific barrel is ridiculous. Basically a few kooks across the country wear white coats and claim that they can do this “science” and prosecutions pay them to be expert witnesses. Juries eat it up. It’s really nuts. The only legitimate analysis they’re doing is ammo brand matching. “Hey, there was a Sellier & Bellot 380 Auto casing at the murder scene. The suspect had S&B 380 in his gun safe. We got him.”
- heavyset_go 3y agoIt's your expert witnesses versus the state's, and the state can always outspend you. Judges and juries are going to default to trusting them, as well.
- unstatusthequo 3y agoDefense attorney here. Client of Cellebrite. Look, it’s the gold standard in smartphone processing. What would anyone want to taint something that works well. For BOTH sides. Don’t assume a tool always favors one side. The data is the data. A tool reveals it. Don’t want it found? Don’t use an easily processable app…
- ISL 3y agoHow do we know that the tool doesn't alter the data?
- arsome 3y agoOr perhaps even more likely - process fake data injected by a malicious 3rd party trying to spoof an app.
- yyyk 3y agoIt's a defence often used in CP cases - 'my computer was hacked! I had no idea the computer had CSAM!' - and it always fails. Because hacking is atypical, courts place the burden on the defendant to prove hacking, and there's usually no good way to do that. Same thing here, except the defendant is in an even worse position. In theory, a CP felon would have reason to generically hack some another computer (since CSAM storage itself is illegal), and desktop OSs are less secure. In the phone case, you likely need to assume a specific criminal conspiracy entirely meant to convict the defendant, one that must involve the police*, and that's an extremely high bar to meet. * The police are the ones using the tool; the only way to effectively plant non-generic evidence is to have the corroborating data first and that requires police assistance.
- flangola7 3y agoHow good is it? Can it extract secure enclave keys or only bypass the rate limiting?
- 8organicbits 3y agoCellebrite apparently had vulnerabilities and was poorly patched. Seems possible to me. https://signal.org/blog/cellebrite-vulnerabilities/ https://signal.org/blog/cellebrite-vulnerabilities/
- ixwt 3y agoThat's what Parallel Construction is for.
- publicpretender 3y agoIn general, defense attorneys who have used the software are not inherently opposed to it: 1. most cases are about sms text contents and timestamps. these can be externally validated from the phones themselves, other software, or from having both sides of the conversation 2. other data, like location, is less certain, needs to be validated, and there are debates about what the evidence means, 3. Cellebrite software is available to people who pay for it on both sides and their training videos encourage LEO to actually go out and validate the results they see. the constantly changing cat and mouse nature of cellphone extraction and parsing requires double checking and validation. this is the big issue. LEO generally have no tech skills and are just armchair phone extractors. they do not validate the data. that is a problem, but not the tool itself.
- yyyk 3y agoThere's a nerd law idea where everything needs to be 100% scientifically proven and reproducible for a criminal conviction. That's not how the law works at all. The law works probabilistically, and when the doubts are low enough than it's goto jail, even for criminal cases. The prosecution would present the Cellebrite 'evidence' to the judge and (in our scenario) it would move the needle towards the prosecution. Then the defence will (always) try to doubt the evidence and move the needle back, but it would take a lot more than 'something might have happened, dunno how' to do that fully. When the needle is tilted enough, the prosecution has their conviction. Note that in our reality, judges have a lot of trust in prosecutors, and the needle always starts tilted...
- nullifidian 3y ago>law works probabilistically Science also works probabilistically, like most of it, but the law works "probabilistically", as in eyeballing a rough estimate using folk theories kind of probability.
- kelnos 3y ago"Nerd law idea" or not, this should bother us. Some "expert" saying some software found incriminating evidence, but, oops, you'll just have to trust us that it works as we're telling you it does... no, no, no, that's not justice at all.
- yyyk 3y agoAre you suggesting they can't hack phones, and just fake entire address book/location history/all messages? That's obviously false. Is the suggestion that there was some sort of massive conspiracy planting evidence*? I strongly suspect judges won't assign much credence to that. * Such a conspiracy would have to include Cellebrite, the police and Apple/Google. After all, hacking the phone likely means you have the iCloud keys and can download the backups to verify. Furthermore, the conspiracy would always be at risk from the accused choosing to restore the backups to show some evidence wasn't there. So someone at Apple/Google would have to be complicit as well to modify the backups.
- sidewndr46 3y agoThis is where you're wrong. You can't just get up in front of a criminal court and decide that a company is a "hacking company". The judge is not going to allow it.
- kstrauser 3y agoExcept that they literally are. They use undocumented zero-day exploits to hack into locked devices.
- Spooky23 3y agoThey are, they are just expensive. I was on a jury where the defense counsel eviscerated an expert witness from a red light camera company. The police used the cellular/gps time on the camera to splice together 10-12 videos from various camera whose times weren’t in sync. Having impeached the time; the whole case fell apart and her client’s manslaughter charge was dismissed.
- tremon 3y agoHow is this is type of evidence tampering not a slam-dunk case of perjury?
- Spooky23 3y agoIt wasn’t tampering, the rhetorical skills of the attorney and the dumbass ADAs failure to rein it in bamboozled a poorly prepared expert. In fairness, the guy was there to talk about a camera, not to describe how NTP on the cellular network works. The defense had the judge questioning the nature of time and space!
- darkclouds 3y agoIf you know anything about biology, you'd realise the jury based court process is fundamentally flawed anyway.