4 ms·
> And that’s just lawsuit number one: Ars Technica reports there are two more. Three SanDisk SSD lawsuits in total, each seeking class-action status for the sam
by crazygringo 3y ago
> And that’s just lawsuit number one: Ars Technica reports there are two more. Three SanDisk SSD lawsuits in total, each seeking class-action status for the same failures.
Good. I don't really care about whether WD answers questions, I care about them losing a lawsuit and having punitive damages per affected customer that are far more than the retail value of each product, due to loss of data.
I am baffled by why WD isn't voluntarily issuing product recalls, replacements, and/or firmware updates as necessary in this situation -- the hit they're taking to their reputation is far worse in the long run. But fortunately we have the courts.
- j-bos 3y agoI agree, I've naively trusted the SanDisk brand but just today I went compared and bought an SSD, didn't even look a WD or SanDisk. Their name is now tainted in my book.
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoInterestingly Framework (the laptop company) ships exclusively WD SSDs, although I suppose you can bring your own SSD if you really want. Though I wonder which other brands are trustable? Just yesterday I read a comment on another thread mentioning how Samsung’s firmware is subpar (which, having owned several other Samsung products, doesn’t surprise me).
- wtallis 3y agoThe solution is to give up on the entire idea of brand loyalty. These are commodity products. None of the products or companies are 100% reliable. To some extent, you get what you pay for, but paying more won't guarantee a trouble-free experience. When some brands command a premium price in the market, across their entire product line, that's really just a sign that they've managed to get customers to think their products are special. But everyone has shipped some lemons, and everyone has screwed over somebody with bad customer support.
- frognumber 3y agoNo, I don't think so. Off-brands are hyper-unreliable. There is a stack of chips for reliability, ranked from 100% working, to ones which e.g. have half disabled, or ECC+scrambler. On-brands at least /try/ to be reliable. Off-brands don't. WD/Sandisk is a little weird, in that they went from on-brand to off-brand. I also haven't seen many lemons from Crucial. They control the process end-to-end, and don't really go for bleeding-edge performance or rock-bottom price. For me, they've always been good and reliable for both memory and flash. Kingston, Lexar, and Sandisk were premium brands which really tried to be reliable, until WD bough Sandisk. Samsung cares about reputation too, but pushes performance a bit more, so you sometimes get lemons. But on the whole, they at least try.
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoI wouldn’t really consider WD an off-brand. Off-brands to me are the cheapie no-name brands from China.
- philistine 3y agoColloquially, those are the six-letter brands. https://archive.is/NNfO3 https://archive.is/NNfO3
- frognumber 3y agoI would definitely consider WD an off-brand at this point. It's not about the size of the company. Many small, boutique brands are excellent. By revenue, Walmart is the largest company in the world, but no one praises them for their commitment to quality. Indeed, the stores I trust most are small family-run shops where the proprietor has been running them for decades. I also no longer consider Chinese brands to necessarily be off-brands. China has some excellent brands too these days.
- wtallis 3y ago> Off-brands are hyper-unreliable. There is a stack of chips for reliability, ranked from 100% working, to ones which e.g. have half disabled, or ECC+scrambler. Nah, that's not at all accurate. There are tons of small brands that have both dirt-cheap drives built using whatever components are cheap that week, and more expensive products using high-grade current-generation flash and controllers. Kingston and Lexar brands operate that way, too, with a mix of cheap crap and more expensive products with quality components (often overpriced). And some of the small brands don't really do bottom-of-the-barrel drives at all (eg. Corsair, Sabrent). And certainly Crucial/Micron have had their fair share of serious SSD issues. Brand just isn't the reliable indicator of quality that you and many other consumers wish it was.
- frognumber 3y agoCrucial is my go-to brand for reliability at reasonable prices. Otherwise: * Kingston has an excellent reputation for reliability, as does Lexar, but you often pay a premium. * Samsung and Intel are considered good, but they do occasionally make specific subpar models. Crucial is my go-to, thought. I also buy direct to avoid knock-offs. Buying premium brands from eBay or Amazon especially makes no sense, since knock-offs are so !@#$% common.
- ciupicri 3y agoLexar was bought by the Chinese company Longsys. Kingston has a reputation for bait and switch as in the V300 scandal (https://www.anandtech.com/show/7763/an-update-to-kingston-ssdnow-v300-a-switch-to-slower-micron-nand https://www.anandtech.com/show/7763/an-update-to-kingston-ss...).
- frognumber 3y agoDid that result in a decline in Lexar quality? It's a serious question. - Many Chinese firms bought established brand names in order to milk a cash cow and sell junk at premium prices. - Many others did so with very good products, and seem to be doing a nice job sustaining those brands and are investing in this long-term. I don't know what happened here. ThinkPads don't seem any worse under Lenovo than late IBM, and GE Appliances, if anything, went up in quality.
- ciupicri 3y agoI bought an SD card for someone a couple of years ago and he had no issues, but I can't remember if it was after the acquisition or before.
- Smoosh 3y agoKingston were being anti-consumer around 10 years ago. I don’t know if they have improved their practices since then. https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/184253-ssd-shadiness-kingston-and-pny-caught-bait-and-switching-cheaper-components-after-good-reviews https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/184253-ssd-shadiness-kin...
- mceachen 3y agoSK Hynix is an OEM supplier for a bunch of brands, and seems to have good ratings across several different e-tailers. As for anecdata, I chew through SSDs due to high disk I/O loads from running continuous integration test suites for PhotoStructure on a bunch of different test rigs. I've had several WD and Samsung SSDs fail, but have yet to kill one of my 10+ SK Hynix sticks. The best solution, of course, is to have automated backups in place, so drive failure is only a minor inconvenience, not a tragedy.
- j-bos 3y agoWhere do you buy SK Hynix from?
- drdaeman 3y ago> But fortunately we have the courts. How long until next drives are sold with a shrink-wrapped forced arbitration clause? (In the US)
- frognumber 3y agoProbably unenforceable.
- Schiendelman 3y agoIt is nice that the Democrats are trying to address this: https://www.banking.senate.gov/newsroom/majority/brown-introduces-bill-to-protect-consumers-by-banning-forced-arbitration https://www.banking.senate.gov/newsroom/majority/brown-intro...
- tinus_hn 3y agoEvery disk comes with a statement the manufacturer does not warrant damage caused by the loss of data. This suit sounds tough and is going nowhere.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y ago>>>I am baffled by why WD isn't voluntarily issuing product recalls, replacements, and/or firmware updates as necessary in this situation The last (class?) lawsuit seemed to clear for a pittance, I'd think objectively, its cheaper to resolve the lawsuit than issue the recall. This is not long-term thinking, but keep in mind this is the same (product) management that seems to have created these hardware problems in the first place. And WD can always change names and remove negative brand equity.
- seanp2k2 3y ago[flagged]
- TheNewsIsHere 3y agoMy first “private” hard drive, that was all my own, was a WD external. It was a birthday gift from my parents. Ever since then I had purchased WD drives and recommended them. I used them exclusively in every computer I built and used them exclusively whenever I needed external storage. They were hanging on a thread as far as I was concerned when they shipped NAS drives with SMR. I was burned by that. I’ve moved to Seagate now. WD has lost all the trust I had in them. I’m soon buying over 100TB worth of drives and not one of them will be WD.