2 ms·
There's also some interesting things about the paper that set off some flags for me. I've studied radiation extensively, but not medicine fwiw. - I'm always wa
by godelski 3y ago
There's also some interesting things about the paper that set off some flags for me. I've studied radiation extensively, but not medicine fwiw.
- I'm always wary of anyone that will do something like write 2000 keV instead of 2MeV. They also are constantly saying "photon radiation" instead of "gamma," which just reads weird. Neither of these are "incorrect" though.
- They seem to not be accounting for neutrons which is quite a common source if we're talking about reactor workers or Hiroshima. The neutrons get absorbed into the atoms and then it sheds energy through gamma radiation, but a new neutron results in potentially a different chemistry in addition to the ionization energies. Actually reactors depend on this: 235U + 1n -> 236U -> 89Kr + 114Ba + 3n + 2gamma. You just don't often see the 236U discussed, but it is unstable and causes the splitting.
- They use Japanese atomic bomb survivors as comparisons but that's not great and there are many studies looking at radiation workers (both these get neutron doses). There's two big aspects here that matter. First, acute dosage is very different from chronic exposure, and atomic bomb dosages are going to be acute (not just Japanese, but also soldiers). Most workers are going to be chronic, but some may be acute which you need to account for. They don't seem to. There are also many studies on places in the world where the natural background radiation is over the 100mGy that they are saying doubles the cancer rate, but people from these places don't show increased cancer rates (this is mostly radon too, so alpha radiation, and of course this is chronic and not acute).
I don't feel qualified to invalidate the work btw, but these seemed points of note. I know there are some users here with some more expertise, especially in radiation physics, so I was hoping someone could help me understand.