3 ms·
I wondered if the high safety standards in nuclear plants was affecting the outcome. If industrial workers aren't dying in things like construction accidents th
by roenxi 3y ago
I wondered if the high safety standards in nuclear plants was affecting the outcome. If industrial workers aren't dying in things like construction accidents then they have to die of something else and sometimes that will be cancer. Because that graph does make it look like being employed in the nuclear industry increases cancer risk even without any radiation dose at all. It isn't though, because it looks like we're talking about ~10,000 otherwise unexplained deaths over ~300,000 people and even being pessimistic I think industrial accidents would only be <50 deaths. I wouldn't completely rule out some industry-specific effect like that even now, looking at the figure you reference.
The nature of the study make it hard to be confident, there are a lot of potential influences that could throw the conclusions. It is challenging to interpret too, table C in the supplementary data makes it look like risk drops with higher doses and I am sure I'm reading that wrong.