3 ms·
> This is why America was conceived to be a country where the central government can only exercise enumerated powers; because the framers knew that every organi
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> This is why America was conceived to be a country where the central government can only exercise enumerated powers; because the framers knew that every organization eventually becomes run (at one point or all subsequent points) by corrupt, evil people.
This is false.
America was reconceived as a country where the federal government had enumerated powers because it started as one where the federal government had no powers and could only act by ad hoc unanimity of the constituent states, and that failed hard, and the particular idea of, and particular set of, enumerated powers chosen was a compromise among the Framers who were called to fix the failing system, and whose preferences ranged from a much more powerful central government (the Hamilton and, less extremely, Pinkney plans) to a vastly less powerful one (the New Jersey plan), and did not represent a shared common vision, contrary to the later-constructed mythology.
Taking this mythological common vision, and then constructiong a rationalization for it, and then presenting it as the original plan of government for America falsely projects into a hotly debated contentious compromise created to deal with particular exigencies arising under the earlier plan into a kind of perfect divine revelation of government, which it very much was not and was not viewed as by participants in the process.
- largbae 3y agoGreat stuff... Now knowing what you do, could you speculate how would the current powers of the intelligence committee be viewed by the participants in that process?
- dragonwriter 3y agoI think the general opinion would be, to borrow from King Louis’ Head (by way of Alexander Hamilton, as imagined by Lin-Manuel Miranda): “Do what you want, I’m super dead”. Though, among those regarded as Founding Fathers, that might be most particularly the view of Thomas Jefferson, who wrote: “On similar ground it may be proved that no society can make a perpetual constitution, or even a perpetual law. The earth belongs always to the living generation. They may manage it then, and what proceeds from it, as they please, during their usufruct. They are masters too of their own persons, and consequently may govern them as they please. But persons and property make the sum of the objects of government. The constitution and the laws of their predecessors extinguished them, in their natural course, with those whose will gave them being. This could preserve that being till it ceased to be itself, and no longer. Every constitution, then, and every law, naturally expires at the end of 19 years. If it be enforced longer, it is an act of force and not of right.” (Letter to James Madison, Paris, Sep. 6, 1789)
- pyuser583 3y agoAre suggesting we abolish the Constitution and create a new one?
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Are suggesting we abolish the Constitution and create a new one? No, that was Thomas Jefferson saying that. I’m saying asking “what would the founders think?” is asking an irrelevant question, as well as an unanswerable one.
- ixwt 3y agoThe current Supreme Court and their fixation on originalism would strongly disagree with you.
- dragonwriter 3y agoOriginalism is a mode of interpretation that focuses on how words of a legal enactment would have been understood when written, which is a distinctly different question than what the authors’ opinion would have been of something.
- tcmart14 3y agoDragonwriter has a great response. My short and sweet answer is, the constitution is a living document for a reason and people ~250 years ago couldn't possibly plan for a world where cell phones exists (or think about the intricacies of that world). That doesn't mean all their work goes out the window, but it means their work does not hold the answer to everything. Trying to define the constitutionality of regulating telecom with words written that couldn't conceive of that world, probably has a few flaws.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSomewhat ironically, the US Constitution convention was unconstitutional for this reason. It was drafted to be binding with 9 out of the 13 states signing on in direct Defiance of the unanimity required by the previous Constitution. It was somewhat a moot point because all 13 colonies ended up eventually signing,