3 ms·
I'm surprised that evidence gathered through this method can't be thrown out in court. The customer that provided the DNA did not give consent to sharing the d
by kelnos 3y ago
I'm surprised that evidence gathered through this method can't be thrown out in court. The customer that provided the DNA did not give consent to sharing the data, and the company holding the data did not give consent to share it with law enforcement (would be entertaining if the act of exploiting a security hole in the search form could be a CFAA violation on top of that).
Of course, this doesn't stop parallel construction; once they find their likely suspects through the illegally-obtained genetic search, they can likely often construct a case without even mentioning the genetic tracing.
- rolph 3y ago>> they can likely often construct a case without even mentioning the genetic tracing<< I think that would be cause to throw the whole thing out, if it was eluted during discovery.
- ralferoo 3y agoActually, I've never really understood the reason behind this. Surely, it doesn't really matter WHY you suspected somebody in the first place. If there's enough other evidence to show irrefutably that they committed the crime, there shouldn't be a huge difference between the first tip coming from some random guy phoning the cops and saying "there's a dodgy looking guy here" or getting a random match from a DNA database? I can see the intent behind probable cause for e.g. traffic stops, because that is designed to stop prejudiced-based harassment. But if there is an extremely close DNA-match found randomly, that search hasn't caused any harm to anyone, and should be a perfectly good reason to investigate someone a little more thoroughly. Maybe it should be disclosed in the case, e.g. "we became suspicious because of the DNA matching, and further investigation showed the victim's blood all over his house, clothes, and the murder weapon that he'd put back in his tool rack" should be a slam dunk conviction not grounds for letting someone go on a technicality because e.g. there wasn't a nosy neighbour who'd reported them for being too noisy or whatever.
- superkuh 3y agoUsing the interface in unintended (by the creators) ways is a prosecutable crime under the CFAA. People can be and have been imprisoned for it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev#Trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev#Trial is a notable example.
- sobkas 3y agoThey were imprisoned because there was political/economic will to throw book at them. It's only illegal if you get caught and there is someone willing to prosecute(and sentence) you.
- StanislavPetrov 3y agohttps://www.hrw.org/report/2018/01/09/dark-side/secret-origins-evidence-us-criminal-cases https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/01/09/dark-side/secret-origi...