2 ms·
The hilarious thing is that hormesis, taken seriously, would make one think the risk curve has a negative second derivative, as this study suggests it does. So
by pfdietz 3y ago
The hilarious thing is that hormesis, taken seriously, would make one think the risk curve has a negative second derivative, as this study suggests it does. So a hormesis fan should have been suggesting LNT was underestimating the danger of low dose radiation.
- snarkconjecture 3y agoAll of the graphs in the literature suggest a positive second derivative. Why do you say negative? AIUI the model is that hormesis kicks in even for extremely small amounts of radiation, but has a limited effect and is overwhelmed by the negative effects of larger amounts.
- scythe 3y agoNo it wouldn't. The hormesis hypothesis proposes that the body's repair mechanism from a low dose of radiation yields benefits that outweigh the damage of the radiation. Eventually those internal repair mechanisms are overwhelmed, leading to a positive second derivative. There is no specific evidence for hormesis (i.e. evidence lacking good alternative explanations) nor are there reasonable proposed mechanisms by which this would happen. But we should be clear about what it says.
- pfdietz 3y agoNo, what the hormesis idea suggests is that radiation induces an increase in repair mechanisms. So, add radiation, you boost defense mechanisms, and more radiation then has less effect. The curve is bent downward, the second derivative is negative.