5 ms·
What is his rationale for this? It seems insane to not allow blocking -- that's a fundamental and essential tool to keep things usable. I don't understand the
by JohnFen 3y ago
What is his rationale for this? It seems insane to not allow blocking -- that's a fundamental and essential tool to keep things usable.
I don't understand the reasoning behind removing it at all.
- Avshalom 3y agoAssuming he's serious and didn't just like drink a bottle of nyquil or something it's a couple things: 1) hate fueled engagement is still engagement, he's betting that statistically he'll generate more hate-reads than account-closures 2) the specific kind of shitheel that he reply-guys to don't like being blocked because it prevents them from directing harassment at users 3) The block-the-blue thing again. Can't sell subscriptions if subscribing makes you less visible.
- JohnFen 3y ago> The block-the-blue thing again. I didn't know this was a thing -- but that alone explains everything, I think.
- Zigurd 3y agoWhen blue checks got sorted to the top of threads, I would block almost all of them. Elon created the problem. Of course his "solution" is even worse. I use Xitter as a write-only medium now.
- matsemann 3y agoHeh, I would hide their comments and ask them to donate $8 to my cause to be visible under my post.
- guax 3y agoYou might be overthinking it. Its likely just that he's not happy people can block him.
- cwkoss 3y agoUsers can block ads, and after a few weeks of doing this casually you can block a large proportion of advertisers, because most sane businesses recognize twitter as the negative-reputation cesspool that it is.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoHe said earlier that blocking is like DDoS for the servers. The blocks are filtered as an additional step from the timeline lookups. So when there are lot of blocks, you multiply the requests to build enough tweets for display. Because people on Twitter are polarized and constantly attacking and blocking each other, and Elon has no money for infrastructure, it has become a problem. And his solution is expectedly dumb. Additionally it’s bad for business when people block advertisers and blue checks.
- graeme 3y agoI’ve been getting really bad ads, so I’ve been blocking a set of advertisers. This might be why he is doing it. Though really I’m just making up for bad ad targeting
- rasz 3y agoPure BS, takes same server CPU time as muting, exact same lookups must be performed.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoNot the same. Mute is one sided 1:M. Block is bidirectional making it M:N. Muting is people muting you, they don’t see you, but you see them, so it doesn’t affect your fetches. But a million people blocking you is also you unwittingly muting those people from your side. Meaning that if a million people have blocked you, those million block lists needs to apply when you read your timeline.
- cubefox 3y agoBut this feature isn't new, right? If it was feasible ten years ago, CPUs/DBMSes of today surely don't have much of a problem with it.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoTwitter is leaking money like a sieve, way, WAY faster than ever before in its existence, and they got rid of several of their data enters, all the while trying to increase engagement and users on the platform. The feature is not new, but Twitter’s situation is new, and their management is new. Also they’re completely incompetent, which doesn’t help.
- jfengel 3y agoX has a "muting" feature which will remain. That means you don't have to see them -- that's how a lot of people understand "blocking" anyway. That's obviously essential. The extra features of blocking are less obviously essential: people can still reply and you don't see it. But your followers still see it, and by following you they're exposed any harassment you receive. That might not be quite as fundamental, but it's still pretty damn important. If people lose followers or their community is unable to talk over the noise, people will leave.
- JohnFen 3y agoMuting is insufficient -- even counterproductive sometimes -- because it doesn't stop people from harassing your followers, but it does stop you from seeing when that's happening. I think blocking is essential. Muting is nice to have.
- ksaj 3y agoIt means your harassers can reply to your posts with all kinds of things meant to change other reader's perceptions of you, while you, the victim, are completely unaware of why your circle keeps shrinking. Otherwise you could block the aggressor outright, which disallows this kind of activity. Muting is not the same, even if some people mistakenly believe they are. Muting is what you do to annoying users that always try to be the center of attention, even though they are so extremely boring or whatever. They can still participate in threads... you just won't see their constant floods. They aren't harming you. They're just an eyesore. Blocking is what you do to someone you don't want involved in any aspect of your life, and especially in your active conversations. Harassers, exes, etc.
- cubefox 3y agoMany (I actually think most) people use blocking not for harassment, but for blocking people whose opinions they don't like without being harassed in any way. Basically as a tool to keep their echo chamber echoey. So the possibility of blocking has both advantages and disadvantages. The question is which one dominates.