8 ms·
Too Much SEO? Google’s Working On An “Over-Optimization” Penalty For That
- lkozma 15y agoWhile they can certainly penalize sites that optimize today with respect to the criteria of yesterday, that effectively just means changing the criteria of ranking. Nothing stops site owners to optimize with respect to the new criteria tomorrow. The full implications of the proposition are reminiscent of Russel's paradox, or worthy to be included in a next edition of Hofstadter's Gödel, Escher, Bach book. EDIT: small clarification
- kami8845 15y agoWell no, it's clearly stated that the goal is to even the playing field, not change the rules. If SEOs build too many backlinks (and for big keywords you need them in the range of hundreds of thousands) they will get punished. What are they gonna do, build less backlinks? This is of course over-simplified but it does come across as a sound solution.
- theseanstewart 15y agoThe solution would be to keep building more backlinks but vary the anchor text significantly.
- jakeonthemove 15y agoWell, that's pretty good news... if it works. There's a lot of garbage on the first page just because the page/site has a lot of backlinks and has the whole site SEO'd by the book (titles, keyword density, headers, etc.).
- mtkd 15y agoThis can't come soon enough. Too many sites are ranking by stuffing keywords and buying links. Next, Google need to find a way to rank a page based on it's role in a broader user experience - rather than being measured in isolation. Sites (especially in retail) are forced to optimise a page in a specific way to get indexed successfully. The result is everyone putting too much content on a single page - detracting from usability and creating homogeneity for users - like cars all optimised in wind tunnels.
- palish 15y ago"buying links"? I'm completely new to this; would you mind explaining what the benefit is of buying links?
- a-priori 15y agoLet's say I run a site with lots of Google juice. For the low, low price of $[big number], I'll link to your site to give you some of my Google juice.
- mjwalshe 15y agoAnd if you get caught you get banned I know more than one major publication has been caught this way.
- ZanderEarth32 15y agoYou don't always necessarily get banned permanently, or banned at all. Google might just discount all the links they find to be bought and adjust your ranking according to your new link count minus the paid links. You can always clean up the links yourself and then submit a reconsideration request. Whether that request is accepted, that's up to Google.
- mjwalshe 15y agoTrue but some times you do get a big slap BMW is probably the best known. And getting back can be a problem for sites with out a high profile and for ever after your on Googles watch list :-)
- jeremydavid 15y agoHistorically, a large component of Google's ranking algorithm involves the number of links pointing to a website (and a number of other qualities like anchor text, unique domains, surrounding text, etc.). If my memory serves me, there are over 300 ranking factors - but links are still the most important. By buying links (undetected) you can manipulate the quality and relevancy of your website in Google's eyes and cause it to rank better than it should.
- stfu 15y agoI have relatively little hope that it takes longer than a few days/weeks until a wave of seo-deoptimization services hit the SEO market. The incentives for beating "the system" are just too high.
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoThat's my thoughts too. It's a game nobody can win.
- jeremydavid 15y agoI would guess Google already keeps a record of a website's history and could easily detect if it suddenly became "seo-deoptimized" EDIT: But I completely agree. There are far too many SEO's out there for this to beat everything
- Drbble 15y agoThat's the whole point! To make Google-friendly sites more similar to human-friendly sites. (There's even an xkcd comic about this already.)
- blacksmythe 15y agoSounds like the equivalent of the AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax, designed to increase the US income tax of those deemed to have too many deductions).
- ZanderEarth32 15y agoAs an SEO I am interested to see how this update goes. Google updates usually have a 'shotgun' result. They might kill the intended targets but there is a lot of damage from the spray to sites that might be unwarranted.
- andybak 15y agoDefine 'unwarranted'. For every site with a good ranking there's probably a dozen who rank worse but provide equally good content. Maybe just shaking things up a bit regularly isn't a bad idea in itself.
- ZanderEarth32 15y agoBy 'unwarranted' I am referring to websites who might get dinged in this update but are not overdoing the SEO, or possibly not doing any SEO at all. It happened with the Panda update so I can't help but think that it will happen again.
- Kiro 15y agoIf you're doing SEO at all you should be punished imo. Let Google do its job without interfering and trying to manipulate please. And no, I don't believe there is such a thing as "whitehat SEO". Whitehat SEO is just common sense (write good content and don't screw up your markup).
- AznHisoka 15y agoThat's like saying trying to sell your product is a sin. Mind telling me how a consumer web startup is supposed to get others who are interested in X to visit his site about X? This is the basis of SEO: matching searchers to pages. It doesn't happen magically just by wishful thinking, and writing good content unfortunately.
- Kiro 15y agoNo, it's like saying trying to lure people into buying something worse instead of the better is a sin. Like the product manufacturer secretly sneaking around in stores hiding competing products and putting their own in the front.
- klbarry 15y agoHard to believe that they don't already do this...?
- sheff 15y agoUnless the penalties from Google are long term I can't see this as being very effective, as you would assume competent SEOs will just tweak their processes in response. From what I've read over the years, basic SEO mainly boils down to : - Have good, relevant content - Choose your page titles and URLs carefully - Get lots of links to your pages , from as many different domains as possible, and try to get them from high Pagerank domains - Where possible try to get anchor text relevant to the terms you want to rank for - but don't go overboard with a large percentage being the same phrase, as it appears artificial - An older site can benefit you, as will exact match domains for the main TLDs Except for site age, they are all easily changeable by the SEO. Maybe Pagerank is too easily gameable, and what is old will become new again, and some of the approaches tried in the 90s and replaced by Pagerank will return with a new twist.
- polyfractal 15y agoPagerank is a very small part of Google's ranking algorithm nowadays.
- user24 15y agoThe problem is that Google actually aren't good enough at search yet. They still rely on this dumb word-based approach to document retrieval. Example, if my page is about how to manage your time, and it's a really fantastic resource about that, but I don't actually mention the phrase "how to manage your time" anywhere, I won't rank for people searching for that phrase. I should, but I won't. So I have to write my content for two audiences - humans and Google. I don't want to do this. I'd be much happier just building great content for my human readers, and if I happen not to mention the exact keyword phrase a searcher might use, it doesn't matter, Google still knows it should put my site at the top for that phrase, because it understands that my site is about that phrase, even though I don't mention it exactly. But Google just isn't good enough yet. Someone can set up a page which has a bunch of headers and URLs and variations of the keywords and beat me to #1, even if their content is utter rubbish for human consumption. That's why SEO still exists. It's symptomatic of a bug in Google. This penalty will help, hopefully, but we're still going to be in a state where we have to compromise our content to serve two masters.
- alinajaf 15y agoAs I understand it, google is putting a lot of resources into semantic search atm which may go some way towards fixing the problems you're describing.
- user24 15y agoYeah semantic search, if solved, would address this problem. That's really what I was getting at. Stripped right down, Google is still just viewing documents as a bag of words[1]. I mean, they have pagerank and they will apply more weight to words in headings, and they have 6-gram indexes and synonyms and all that clever stuff, but at it's core it's still lexically centered not semantically centered. [1] Further reading: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bag_of_words_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bag_of_words_model
- Drbble 15y agoMeaning Google makes no effort to score your whole page against each word in the dictionary, it only attempts to score 1- to 6-game from the page and inbound links? That's unfortunate.
- janesvilleseo 15y agoI think this is going to be very interesting. I can understand the benefit of it, but as an SEO, I also feel that because we are working in the dark it is as much a science as an art. To me, this just means I have to work on fine tuning what it takes. Also, I think it will be harder for those who play on the wrong side of the tracks to rank well, which in turn may make it easier for those who do to rank well.
- theseanstewart 15y agoI think Google needs to be really careful with this. It would make sense that the first place they should look for over optimization is anchor text manipulation. The problem is that this could open up the door for "Negative SEO" services where you can blast a competitor with high traffic keyword anchor texts. The safest place to look will be on page factors and if they decide to go after anchor text manipulation there should be some type of authority metric that protects established sites.
- Isofarro 15y agoGoogle is probably already do that, which is why the current traffic-generation methods advice is along the lines of varying anchor text. This is done mostly by identifying related / tangential / complementary / supplementary keyword terms to the resource linked to. Non whitehat SEOers are wising up to the idea of a site targetting niches, and that considerably widens the list of appropriate keywords. By tackling the long tail keywords en masse - these are less competitive, easier to rank for, and correlated better to buying intent; gradually they make significant inroads to ranking strongly for the big-head keyword in a manner that looks more natural.
- sixQuarks 15y agoI gave up trying to optimize for SEO a long time ago. The future is good content, period. Technology will eventually figure out a way to get the good content in front of users, whether it's through a Google-like search engine or something totally different. I'd rather focus my energy on driving traffic in other ways, such as traditional media, list building, PR - and focusing on creating great content. I just do the bare minimum stuff when it comes to SEO (title, h1 tags, some anchor text here and there). Other than that, I don't pay attention to SEO in the actual content of the pages.
- dannyr 15y agoI'm with you. Create content & do minimum SEO. Eventually, other sites will link to your content & Google will figure it out.
- jonbishop 15y agoGood content is a key part of SEO
- AznHisoka 15y agoI think this is wishful thinking. Google have been trying to make search smarter for many many years. The truth is that links are still a good signal, and you should try to consciously build links. There are many many many articles out in the internet that are well-written and informative but noone can find them because they're not in the top 10 in Google.
- sixQuarks 15y agoCreating good content and promoting it through PR should result in natural links - the exact type that Google looks for. If you try to stay on top of the latest SEO tactics, you end up hurting yourself in the long-term. For example, awhile back it was recommended to create huge directories of conten t (something like: Travel deals in Ohio, Travel deals in NY, etc, etc). With Panda update, you are now penalized if you have too much similar content. Why deal with all that headache, just create good content.
- fellowniusmonk 15y agoThought 1: This may be overly cynical, but it is hard to believe that this isn't just another way to dump more people into their adwords system. People who "over optimize" on a large scale are probably the same people making money off of well ranked SERP's, penalizing those people pushes them to buy adwords. They are in essence pre-qualified customers for adwords since they have already demonstrated a willingness to invest real time/money in ranking. Sure this will just trigger yet another race to optimize optimization, but until things are refigured out more money will be dumped into adwords. Thought 2: This SERP "Market Volatility" is a great way for Google and SEO's to make a little more money. This is also a good way of reminding some people how much their revenue is dependent on Google, when you see an overnight dive in revenue it captures the attention/mind share of higher ups who have maybe been taking their well oiled SERP machine for granted. It's like a one night only "Google Dance" reunion tour, and gets people obsessing over them again.
- andybak 15y agoThat sounds like a marvelous future. Everyone who can justify throwing money at the problem can use paid search and everyone left in organic search can wish them all good riddance and get on with producing content.
- AznHisoka 15y agoexcept this makes sites like StackOverFlow, Huffington Post, Mashable, Yelp, and most sites that depend on advertising economically unsustainable. Before you say "No..", remember even Yelp, a great word-of-mouth resource gets over 70% of their visits through search engines. As does Stack Overflow. What will be left will be personal bloggers, charities, and hobbyist sites. Be careful what you wish for.
- Drbble 15y agoHuffPo is a spam site that Panda should have killed. Stackoverflow is a unique content sites with practically no human-unfriendly SEO (Except maybe the huge list of related questions that tends to fool Google, where the search term is split over two questions and neither is actually relevant. )
- sad_panda 15y agoIs there a SEO industry around Bing? What does Bing SEO look like?
- jaredmck 15y agoI don't know of anyone who specifically optimizes for Bing - most of the ranking signals are the same or at least similar to Google, so with far less traffic than G it's not worth it to focus on bing SEO (or for bing to change their algorithm to include widely disparate ranking signals)
- Drbble 15y agoBing picks crap sites seemingly at random already anyway, so there is no SE to try to O.
- jordhy 15y agoMany factors make Bing SEO different. Since Bing doesn't crawl as many pages as Google, they are more harsh on low quality sites and links coming from "content farms". Specifically, Bing is: - Less likely to find results in forums - Harsher on results from “content mills” (even after Panda) - Less likely to give you ranking for a keyword if is not found verbatim in the page - Also provides way fewer results for phone number queries
- tocomment 15y agoGoogle has gotten so bad. I'm now finding worthwhile results until the second or third page. Here is my search process If it is from ehow ignore If it has my search term in the URL ignore If it is from about.com ignore
- DanBC 15y agoehow should have been hit with the Panda update? Do you have a "block all example.com results" link on your Google results page? (You might have to visit the link and then hit back in your browser to get it to appear.) Do you have any examples of search terms that don't return useful results until page two or three?
- dholowiski 15y agoLet me tell you, searching for typical tech support issues, ehow is always on the first page and the content is clearly spam- usually only tangentially related to the query. try Googling exchange server specify IP adress- and try to find something useful.
- tocomment 15y agoIntroduction to gardening was a search I tried today and wasn't happy with the results.
- AznHisoka 15y agoActually, it was shown that eHow's traffic actually went UP after Panda.
- guimarin 15y agosounds like it's time for you to give blekko.com a try. they block spam sites like ehow, about.com, and wikihow.
- Drbble 15y agoYou. Don't know why people say about.com is a spam site. It is a paraphrase site, with long readable content pages that link to other resources. I learn much more and more quickly about tmobile cell phone plans from about.com then I do from wading through tmobile's worthless website.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoI am all for continuing to clean up search. I'd also like to note that for people creating content on the web, especially programming-type people who deal in logic and certainty, the SEO system resembles something like black magic. It's pretty clear that unless you understand SEO and apply it, you're never going to be seen no matter how good your content is. Now it appears that if you understand it too well that's also a bad thing. The goal here is to let the users themselves inform the search engine as to what content is good -- hence the plus-ones, social search and all of that stuff. But all of this is still indirect evidence. Unless you could plug a computer inside the head of a person and watch their every thought, the only real data you have for input is server logs, click-throughs, and all kinds of other things that computers do, not people. I just don't see this being solved any time soon. But I do see it getting so complex and unwieldy that it continues to frustrate searchers and content producers alike. Meanwhile the bad actors will continue to have a heyday. Wish I could be more optimistic about it.
- dholowiski 15y agoDon't you think the obvious solution is to build an algorythm that thinks like the human brain? I suspect Google isn't that far away from that riht now.
- stfu 15y agoFortunately this is somewhat more than just a wicked problem, something that is going to keep life interesting for a few more years to come.
- danmaz74 15y agoI hope they'll be able to do it right. But, as soon as they change their algorithms, SEOs will reverse engineer them again and change the optimizations. There can be no definitive solutions, at least not with current technologies, because SEOs are very smart and very fast at adapting. As an aside, the first over-optimization that I would target if I were google are keyword-based domain names. Keywords in the domain name are given WAY too much weight; how often do you find that the top three results for the search "XXXX YYY ZZZZZ" to be very shallow but keywords-rich websites with the domain names www.XXXXYYYZZZZZ.com, www.XXXXYYYZZZZZ.org, www.XXXXYYYZZZZZ.net?
- nostromo 15y agoI wonder if Google is getting trapped near a local peak. I watched the video they released on improving search quality yesterday (http://insidesearch.blogspot.com/2012/03/video-search-quality-meeting-uncut.html http://insidesearch.blogspot.com/2012/03/video-search-qualit...) and was initially impressed that they gave so much thought to slightly improving a small subset of 0.1% of queries. That meeting must have had 40 people attending! But afterwards it left me with the feeling that Google is becoming so big and entrenched in old ways of doing things, that they may not be focusing enough on the next big improvement in search. Penalties and heuristics can only go so far -- eventually they'll need something approaching AI -- and if any company can do it it's Google.
- mark_h 15y agoThere was this, the other day: http://gizmodo.com/5893494/googles-overhauling-search-to-make-it-semantic http://gizmodo.com/5893494/googles-overhauling-search-to-mak...
- ma2rten 15y agoI don't know if you have any concrete idea in mind, with what AI Google should to approach AI, but Google does fund a lot of research in Information Retrieval and other subfields of AI (machine translation, machine learning, ...). If you were thinking more along the lines of: "you ask a question and it understands your question and answers it like a human would", then I can tell you that this would require a scientific breakthrough first. That is not really something that you can plan for. Also Google mainly excels in engineering, less so in research. I actually think that Yahoo and Microsoft have stronger research divisions.
- yaix 15y agoFor years those penalties have often been mentioned on SEO forums. This is nothing new but just another filter they will add. Or maybe its just a little FUD to keep people nervous?
- itsprofitbaron 15y agoThis is completely the wrong thing to do and in my opinion this means that, Google have essentially just admitted they're bad at search. Firstly, for ecommerce sites etc due to the lack of content - especially unique content (because there are only so many ways you can say something is X length) these sites are forced to SEO themselves. This is even more apparent as Google are placing their “Google Product Search” within the results as well. Sure, you could add yourself to Google Product Search but that’s not the point - Google should be adding ecommerce sites etc in their automatically to make it a level playing field. Sure, you can argue that it is hard to do and that might be the case but, there is proof out there in the marketplace to highlight that this is possible - look at what TheFind etc are doing in this space. Additionally, I think there is a lot more that can be done in the Shopping Search space as well as other areas of search which I will cover below. Having covered those, I will also highlight another problem which is hindering Google = their search engine is based around the Pagerank algorithm which despite evolving is actually hurting Google in trying to solve the problem of SEO. I believe this is the case because of PageRank and the general Google Search algorithms which are in place – their search at its core is based on 'citations' like those in academic papers etc (yes it has evolved over time) but it is still even loosely based and developed upon on this ranking system. Hence there is the problem of paid links - although you can report them [1] this reporting method actually isn't effective and doesn't work. Additionally, there are tons of ways to get links really easily which appear natural, won’t appear overly seo’d and are extremely easy to get and game as well. Google seems to be taking their search into the, Semantic & Social Search approaches which they will probably solve some of these aspects but, everyone is working out (and many have already worked out) how to game social search although, it is a step in at least a decent direction. Currently, Google just provides links and documents etc to the ones which it believes is the most useful based on their Pagerank/keyword approach and even if it can improve search to a much greater degree the issue is also related to Adsense/Adwords. This is because; these two print money for Google. For instance, Adwords really is used for Google Search (yes it does feed into Adsense as well but Advertisers really want their ads on Google Search Results). The last statistic I heard about Google Search, is around 2007 when Google was making $0.12 on average per search – you could probably calculate easily how much Google is making now by looking at their income and dividing it by publicly available search numbers but, I’m going to say it’s more than that because in 2004, they were making $0.09 per search. This is actually an issue for the user because, I believe Google really just want their ad results to be perfect – they don’t really want you to have to click on the result because then Google isn’t making any money – as long as their results are good enough so then they’re Ok with that If you don’t believe me, take a look at [2] that’s a whole lot of ads above the fold. Oh, and if you try and do that be prepared to be punished [3]. Now Adsense, sure it doesn’t make that much of Google’s income but it still is highly profitable – if it wasn’t they wouldn’t be doing it. If Google, really wants to fix search then they need to review every single Adsense site and I mean every single Adsense site since Google only reviews the site which you apply with. This leads of a huge problem as MFA’s aka. Made For Adsense slip through the net afterwards and if you look at their sites, they’re generally have poor content etc and are optimised for the search engine and the user to leave either by clicking the back button. Sure, Google will lose some Adsense income on their balance sheet but if they want to fix search this is also a good place to start. Sure they're trying to solve this issue and get to grips with it but I don't think they will anywhere in the near future. You can argue this fix they have announced will solve some SEO problems but, as I said in my opening sentence I believe this is the wrong approach and some of the above reasons highlight several issues already but there are tons more. In fact, I actually hope you disagree with me because, not only do I value your opinion but am interested in the other aspects you may add to it. [1] https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/paidlinks?pli=1 https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/paidlinks?pli=1 [2] http://searchengineland.com/figz/wp-content/seloads/2012/01/6728099139_d5444820cf_z.jpg http://searchengineland.com/figz/wp-content/seloads/2012/01/... [3] http://searchengineland.com/too-many-ads-above-the-fold-now-penalized-by-googles-page-layout-algo-108613 http://searchengineland.com/too-many-ads-above-the-fold-now-...
- huntaub 15y agoThis is the Laffer Curve for search.
- ktizo 15y agoThe trouble with SEO as a business is that you are always second-guessing the whims of people who's plans and actions are unknown to you other than the fact that they are almost definitely working against you, and furthermore they will usually have much better resources available.
- mark_l_watson 15y agoA little off topic but: the idea of SEO has always bugged me: like a store owner investing in having really clean windows, but crappy products inside the store. Admittedly, that is easy for me to say because I don't need high traffic at my site. I need my web site to have a few high value visitors: people who want to work with me or communicate because we are into the same technology. The way I "optimize" my site is writing about what most interests me, and that attracts people with my interests. Seems pretty straight forward to me.
- davemel37 15y agoactually, the most successful retailers invest more money in their window displays than any other marketing strategy. Regardless, you are taking an overly simplistic view of SEO... SEO works best with quality content backing it up.
- Kiro 15y agoThis is great news. I've always been surprised how the SEO industry can have such legitimacy when it's basically as legit as false advertisement.
- jasonlotito 15y agoDo not confuse black hat SEO with white hat SEO. One is not the other. Creating good, worthwhile content is a key part of SEO. If you write, or create, good, worthwhile content, you are taking part in SEO. If you take your time to write a headline that best reflects your article, and mark it up correctly, that's a part SEO. If your site is using easy to read names, that's SEO. If people link to your content and write about it, that's a part SEO. If you make the description below your page title on Google's search results actually worthwhile then some random piece, that's a part SEO.
- projektx 15y agoI am probably misconstruing things, as I often do and being simple-minded on top of that, but this seems like a circle-jerk and makes me wonder what happened to Tim Berners-Lee's musings about the Semantic Web, and why search hasn't progressed in that direction in some exponentially powerful and revolutionary way.
- im3w1l 15y agoI believe the reason that we see so little of the semantic web is that advertisement is such a dominant business model on the internet. Since it is hard to embed ads in semantic web content, and the will to pay for it isn't there, the sad result is that it is not worth producing.
- Isofarro 15y agoVarious bits of the lowercase semantic web (and its related uppercase Semantic Web cousin) factors show through on Google results - mostly Google Rich Snippets, so reviews metadata. These mostly require human intervention to enable on a site-by-site basis (sometimes by the site owner, sometimes by humans in Google itself). The deeper problem of the semantic web is that it's meta data, which tends not to be visible to visitors. And because of that, it's easy to forget / overlook / incomplete, and nefariously allows SEO over-optimisation invisibly that non-whitehat SEOers do in full view of the human audience. I wish it wasn't true, but Cory Doctorow's portmanteau of metacrap is unfortunately still accurate ( http://www.well.com/~doctorow/metacrap.htm http://www.well.com/~doctorow/metacrap.htm ). We have made several small metadata improvements over the years, but not much progress in substantially overturning Doctorow's original concerns. Human beings are not great sources of accurate and up-to-date metadata. So we rely on scripts and services to fill in the blanks that we don't. (publish times being recorded in WordPress, for example.) Converting human content into metadata ends up being an automated human-hands-off affair which means that those automative tools need to be able to parse and extract information / meaning from human prose. Very much what Google has been doing since inception. It's flawed because it relies on automated interpretation of prose. But there isn't a viable non-flawed method of getting the same information without imposing academic-like constraints to the Web.
- benologist 15y agoI hope this destroys all the scabby blogs that link everything to more of their own garbage - Mashable, Engadget, The Verge etc. Be nice to see them focus on not being shit instead of being rewarded for it.
- espinet 15y agoI wonder how Wikipedia will be ranked with this change since there are litte to no outbound links.
- Drbble 15y ago?? All the references are outbound links. A wikipedia page with no outbound links should likely be deleted for non-encyclopedia content.
- shingen 15y agoThe Google guys are so smart, with enough time they'll get all their algorithms so optimized they'll eventually exclude every site from ranking on the first page of results. It'll just be a blank white page, the ultimate in minimalism and speed. It'll be an engineering feat not rivaled in the 21st century.
- sek 15y agoYou are probably the same guy who complains that Google get's to spammy.
- shingen 15y agoNope, not that guy at all. To clarify for your benefit, I wasn't complaining about Google's optimization or lack-thereof (spammy vs not spammy). I think it's hilarious, watching the endless dance that Google is going through because their fundamental approach to search is broken and they're trying to drag that broken approach into the future. It's like watching Microsoft with each iteration of Windows & Office, trying to figure out how they can cheat death and drag 1980s software into the future. On a business level, I don't care about Google's survival or their optimizations. My product doesn't benefit from SEO, nor from their search engine. I'm indifferent to them. If they make a good product, great; if they don't, someone else will eat their lunch eventually.
- sek 15y agoThere is some truth to it, the approach was never really good. There is just an extreme need for it and they are still the best one around. I wonder what happens 20 years from now on, Google can't win over SEO in the long term. There are just too many people on the other side. As long as they don't develop some AI the results will get worse. I use more often "site:" to get what i want.
- Drbble 15y agoDoes anyone else find that announcement weird? "over -SEO", is just a kind of low quality content, so been a Google target for years. This announcement seems like it's just trying to scare off SEO fanatics, or an admission that Google has been using ridiculously naive linear scoring models for keywords.
- AznHisoka 15y agoThe huge elephant in the room is that Google can kill so many startups and small businesses practically overnight with an algorithm change. People can say "create quality content, don't worry, you can always file reconsideration request if it's an accident" don't realize how Kafka-like Google really is. If an algorithm penalizes your site by accident, and your traffic drops by 99%.. good luck trying to talk to an actual human being working in Google to get your problem fixed!
- jrockway 15y agoDisclaimer: I work for Google, but not on search. These opinions are my own and based only on the linked article. I took a beating on the SEO blogs for calling SEO a bug a few months ago, but I'm glad the rest of the world is finally realizing that I'm right :) Ultimately, Google is trying to rank you highly for providing the best content; you shouldn't be spending your time trying to figure out how to game Google by making superficial changes to the presentation of your content. Want to rank better? Write better! The whole problem is rooted in the fact that Google is a leaky abstraction. It tries to be an omniscient Sherpa, guiding the wary Web traveler with its infinite understanding of the Web and the individual user's needs. The reality, though, is that Google is actually just a computer program. So there is a gap between the user's mental model of Google and what Google actually does, and it's this gap that SEO exploits for its own profit. An infinite amount of exploitation would mean that Google would just return results randomly, and so it makes a lot of sense to detect signs of SEO and penalize the behavior before it further broadens the perfection/reality gap. Gaming the system is currently profitable, since the worst thing that can happen to you is nothing, but the best thing is that you get more traffic. A penalty aligns the risk/reward spectrum to favor "write better content" rather than with "spam a bunch of wikis".
- pantaloons 15y agoThere's a case to be made that detecting and penalizing SEO is making results worse, if, as you suppose, SEO for a sufficiently good search engine is equivalent to producing good content. Obviously Google doesn't think their search is good enough, and I would agree -- piling more "inputs" and arbitrary branches into a ranking algorithm, however, is no solution. This will only devolve into an endless game of cat and mouse until a new search engine comes along and does to Google what Google did to Yahoo.
- john_flintstone 15y ago>Google is trying to rank you highly for providing the best content...Want to rank better? Write better! The real world doesn't always work like that. I do a lot of work for an eCommerce site that sells wholesale. Their customers have little to no interest in reading text, all they want are pictures. Which means, the catalogue pages, which are optimised for actual human visitors and not Google robots, contain little to no text, only pictures. As a result, the catalogue pages (most important part of the site) do not rank anywhere with Google, and never will. Google is unable to handle websites that are - quite correctly - all about the pictures. Competitor sites that outrank this particular site design their catalogue pages for Google, not for humans, and rank well because of it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Ron_wayne 15y agoGoogle and Matt Cutts, in general, have a larger problem. Cutts never acknowledges that Google works primarily on the language, which is one of the most complex things the human race has ever come up to. And though language is always at stake in Google search, I don't see any serious semiotic study in whatever they make. And, apart from that, Google totally sucks on languages that are different than English. They think of a new thing for the English based search and then they'll just propagate it everywhere with no substantial modifications whatsoever. I've got many sites under me, all writing original content. They're not gonna win the Pulitzer, of course, but at least they're edited, accurately followed by teams of human authors that won't even copy PR as a measure to prevent non original contents to appear on the sites. Although all of these things, we got seriously pandalized. The results where we once used to stay atop are filled in many occasions by scraper-sites who steal our contents and rank 2 or 3, sometimes up to 5, positions above us on the SERP. I can't even count the times I filled the anti-scraping form anymore. That's not enough, because many times popular sites rank higher than us just because they're pretty popular, although their contents are horribly written, short, totally uninformative. That happens all the time. You know where we still go pretty strong? On Google News, where the human intervention sometimes really applies. Google should see what's going on everywhere and their insistence on having matt cutts as its only public voice on this huge issue is becoming really frustrating. He ends up looking like a fake good guy, perpetrating the hypocrisy of a corporation too big and too convinced they have the ability to solve all the hyper-complex search problems, laden with human generated unpredictability and the natural human tension towards deception, just with pretty algorithms.