2 ms·
This isn't necessarily super bad in its own right even though it is a very large company and it signals that some of China's big developers are under water. The
by jacquesm 3y ago
This isn't necessarily super bad in its own right even though it is a very large company and it signals that some of China's big developers are under water. The question is whether it is a harbinger or the whole of it. If the former there will be a domino effect just like what happened in 2008, but hopefully more limited to China. I imagine that 'heads will roll' is more than just a figurative expression here, Xi & co will do everything they can to lay the blame with others even though this clearly happened on their watch and is a failure of oversight as much as incompetence at Evergrande.
China real estate is a subject you could write several books on (and it probably has been done) it is a series of houses of cards that are all precariously balanced against each other and that is why the fall-out from this could be substantial.
It will be an interesting number of weeks, the larger questions that will determine some of the outcome are:
Who holds the debt?
Which other companies are overextended in the same way?
What will Xi & co do to deflect blame?
Are the assets valued fairly or are the worth much less in a sale than their book value?
(the bigger the discrepancy the larger the effect will be, for a giant of this size to fall over would have to result in a significant effect on the market)
This could be everything between 'meh' and 'there goes the house' and I have no idea how you'd get to reliable information from inside China to get those questions answered.
- throwaway2990 3y agoThe people are the ones who suffer. Not the banks. Evergrande sold homes that didn’t exist. People got loans from banks to buy those homes. Citizens in China can’t file for bankruptcy. So even if they never get a home. They are in debt for life. This is what you get living under the rule of the CCP.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoPeople associated with Evergrande are very screwed. Yes, the people who bought unfinished homes are screwed, too, and there's more of them. But the whole entire country is screwed when their housing bubble pops. This happened just 15 years ago with 2008 in the US. China and the CCP aren't particularly extraordinary. And they definitely didn't invent incompetence and greed...
- baybal2 3y ago[dead]
- eunos 3y ago> What will Xi & co do to deflect blame? What? All of their issues are explicitly done by Xi via the three red lines.
- jacquesm 3y agoClearly the three red lines failed (as they were wont to do, they were too little and too late). So now someone needs to be blamed. There is no way that the Xi government will accept that they are in part culpable here (besides, there is no way in which the population could vote him out or that the government could fall, such as would happen in functioning democracies).