3 ms·
I'm not at all debating our doubting that individuals can have massive impact. But for something truly global to happen - in appreciable time, too - you need so
by jacquesm 3y ago
I'm not at all debating our doubting that individuals can have massive impact. But for something truly global to happen - in appreciable time, too - you need some form of coordination. An individual might be able to bring about that coordinating instrument, or might be able to convince existing coordinating instruments to act.
But my point, which is a bit muddy, I readily admit, is that if you are faced with a global problem (say, climate change or COVID-19) that individuals can play a very important role in it but individual action by itself won't be enough to achieve the desired global outcome. This is because there are many transnational and super powerful entities that may well be opposed to the change and that there exist several really large organized units that may not play ball in the name of profits or needs or anything else they deem material.
So with starting I was thinking more about the individual doing the thing (say: put solar panels on your roof) to manifest an energy transition. Sure, it helps. But it isn't sufficient and eventually it will fizzle out. And that's one where every little bit helps so it really does make a difference in the aggregate. But meanwhile a single industrial entity (say an aluminum smelter that converts raw bauxite to usable bulk aluminum) will offset the efforts of so many individuals that grassroots efforts won't be sufficient.
But your point about individual contributions and the ability of individuals to galvanize larger entities into action (by shame, an appeal to ethics, by boycott, by protest or by vote) is well taken.
When I was 17 or so (now 41 years ago) I wanted to go work in Petten, NL because I saw the early wind power efforts as very promising. It took decades to get to the point where it made some serious inroads and still we are fighting individuals and large (and wealthy) institutions and lobbying orgs to get those things out there. There were a couple of materials science breakthroughs in that time (notably: Kevlar and Neos) that helped put those out there but technically speaking there wasn't much that stopped us from rolling out windpower on a much larger scale much earlier. This really bugs me.
Some problems need fast and coordinated action at a global level and my general feeling is that we simply do not have the tools in place to do this. The UN is structurally undermined by the parties that hold the most power and international courts are routinely ignored. Einstein at some point advocated for a UN with teeth and I think that would have been a good start.
http://lotoisdumonde.fr/initiatives/FSMAN/Einstein-UN-letter-1947-oct.pdf http://lotoisdumonde.fr/initiatives/FSMAN/Einstein-UN-letter...
- myshpa 3y agoVery good points, thank you. > that if you are faced with a global problem, say, climate change ... The issue with animal agriculture is larger and graver than climate change (it's merely one of the symptoms of overshooting the environment's carrying capacity). The challenges it presents surpass even those of energy transition, imho, given factors like traditions, habits, taste, status, societal pressure, etc. Despite its severity, the problems of animal agriculture remain virtually unknown, even among environmentalists, and are completely ignored by the media. The FAO and IPCC have been influenced to eliminate mentions of animal agriculture and the necessity of plant-based diets. Yet, abolishing it stands as one of the most critical challenges we'll need to address if we hope for a non-dystopian future. > individual action by itself won't be enough to achieve the desired global outcome Yes, but in this case, individual action can — and often does - influence others. There's a reason vegan jokes are so prevalent nowadays :) > fast and coordinated action at a global level and my general feeling is that we simply do not have the tools in place to do this I'm afraid there currently aren't enough people to be "coordinated." In my view, that's the first issue that needs to be addressed.
- jacquesm 3y agoFair enough. Incidentally, I've invested in https://www.goleafside.com/ https://www.goleafside.com/ for exactly that reason. I don't know whether it will make a large difference in the long run but this is the sort of way that I can help leverage the capital I have access to in order to achieve a larger effect. It's been quite successful but it probably did not in and of itself convince many people to switch to a plant based diet, even if there are many good reasons for doing so. So I do agree individuals can make a difference and should try to do what they can. But I just simply think it won't be enough and that is a real pity.