4 ms·
> Something AI might be good at is suggesting new farming techniques and processes for increasing yields. Why do you believe it'd be good at this? I asked Cha
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> Something AI might be good at is suggesting new farming techniques and processes for increasing yields.
Why do you believe it'd be good at this?
I asked ChatGPT for a novel farming idea and it gave me pseudoscientific bullshit. https://chat.openai.com/share/4ba0c013-466e-4bea-ad00-c8ba22dcdde5 https://chat.openai.com/share/4ba0c013-466e-4bea-ad00-c8ba22...
"Bio-Resonance Farming is a cutting-edge approach that harnesses the principles of bio-resonance and plant communication to enhance crop growth, health, and yield. Bio-resonance refers to the idea that living organisms emit unique electromagnetic frequencies, and by understanding and harmonizing with these frequencies, we can optimize plant growth and overall agricultural productivity."
- experimental123 3y agoThe current models were trained on a corpus that is essentially all fiction with no basis in reality. If the training corpus has real world data (like experimental results from agricultural experiments with crops and planting schedules along with their yields) then the neural network should uncover some patterns that wouldn't be obvious simply because finding correlations in large data sets is a hard problem but it is very well suited to analysis by large neural networks.
- ceejayoz 3y agoI mean, you can go try this now; feed some agricultural scientific journals into a model. I suspect it's going to be substantially harder than you expect.
- experimental123 3y agoI agree it is a very easy to do which is why it's surprising someone hasn't already tried it. Most of what I see are toy projects with LoRA for generative models bolted onto existing LLMs for fiction instead of scientific applications. These models already work for software so I see no obvious obstructions why they shouldn't work for agricultural experiments.
- gamblor956 3y agoIt's not very easy to do. LLMs aren't capable of understanding, they can merely regurgitate what they've read based on statistical analysis of what words appear to be linked to each other. That doesn't help you when you need to do something new; at best an LLM can tell you what someone else has already done. There are computer programs that do the kind of thing you're thinking about, for example, for protein structure analysis. They're incredibly complicated and generally require a lot of processing power.
- PaulHoule 3y agoHow about https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpls.2023.1128388/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpls.2023.11283... ? That's a simple application of machine learning algorithms you might find in scikit-learn. Here is a special issue of another alleged "predatory journal" that is full of papers on the subject https://www.mdpi.com/journal/agronomy/special_issues/E18K759IAF https://www.mdpi.com/journal/agronomy/special_issues/E18K759...
- gamblor956 3y agoLLMs are a type of machine learning. The stupidest type of machine learning. The OP did not suggest machine learning in generally, they suggested LLMs specifically, which time and time again have been shown to be incapable of this task as a matter of fundamental design. Worse, because LLMs can't understand the their training data, the output of an LLM must be verified, which in situations like this would probably take more time than simply conducting novel research in the form of random experimentation. Also, you really need to read your citations. The first one found that machine learning was unsuited for the task of agricultural prediction...
- thfuran 3y ago>These models already work for software Do they? You're talking the agricultural equivalent of something like "devise a new sorting algorithm with sota performance on x, y, z", not "write me some crud boilerplate".
- tomrod 3y agoI have my doubts an AI will reliably generate results that are scientifically verifiable. AI interpolates across it's parameter space, but typically performs poorly in extrapolation exercises.
- vkou 3y agoThere's no shortage of ideas for improving real-world processes. Most of those ideas are bunk, and we're constrained by the amount of experiments[1] we are willing to run/fund, and the quality of data[1] that those experiments can collect, and the reproducibility[1] of those experiments. Having an AI shout random ideas is very easy for software people to grok, but isn't going to help. If you want AI to assist with this, you'd need to build an 'AI' that can run the real-world experiments, and that's a few orders of magnitude harder than feeding a text corpus to an LLM. 'Thinking' about this problem isn't the hard part, the hard part is doing it. Even using an LLM for something like a meta-analysis of existing research is unlikely to find many profitable avenues of exploration. [1] Experimental research is incredibly difficult, which is a fact that's highly underappreciated by people working in abstract and theoretical disciplines.
- grokist 3y ago[dead]
- wheelerof4te 3y agoChatGPT is a glorified CTL+V of loosely connected content available on the internet.
- ceejayoz 3y agoYes, but even a model trained on a bunch of scientific papers will lack understanding in the same fashion, until there's some new technological breakthrough.
- agronomicon 3y agoUnderstanding is not necessary for uncovering statistical correlations.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNeither is AI. The parent poster wants it to suggest new farming techniques, which is a little more involved than plotting a trend line.
- agronomicon 3y agoAI is simply about finding correlations in large data sets. Computers don't understand anything, they just shuffle symbols. So training an LLM on agricultural research will likely uncover patterns that would not be obvious to people and these patterns could point to new techniques and processes for increasing yields like scheduled flooding (as explained in the article). LLMs don't understand code but they consistently can complete code fragments which end up being correct more often than not. A model for yield optimization doesn't have to understand farming to suggest techniques and processes for increasing yields just like LLMs do for code fragments.
- gamblor956 3y agoLLMs can complete code fragments because they're just matching them up based on having seen these code fragments paired together in they're database.
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoYou prompted it in exactly the wrong way. It also says: > It's important to note that the concept of Bio-Resonance Farming is speculative
- ceejayoz 3y ago“Speculative” is… charitable.
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoWhy do you expect an LLM would be the tool for this job? There's plenty of “actually smart” AI (well, it's legit, so call it ML) out there that can do mathematical/scientific analysis better than we can.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoWhen all you have is a hammer. (and a hype cycle)