3 ms·
‘Bored Apes’ investors sue Sotheby’s, Paris Hilton,others as NFT prices collapse
- EA-3167 3y ago"Investors" seems like a remarkably generous, possible dishonest framing of these people. After all if this was really an investment, why was it totally unregulated?
- bell-cot 3y ago> Sotheby’s is among 30 defendants named in the lawsuit, with celebrities like Justin Bieber and Paris Hilton also accused of promoting the NFT collection without disclosing their financial links to it. WTF??? Officially disclosed or not, when was the last time that a bunch of A-list celebrities promoted anything vaguely commercial, without being well-compensated for doing so? This isn't 1637 any more, for speculative bubbles to be a new & mysterious thing. No competent investor believes that NFT's of stuff like "a Tweet" have an underlying cash value. And if you buy an oil painting by Simon Von Sneed from Southeby's - that's an obvious bet on the whims of the art market. If either the current owner or Southeby's actually believed the painting to be a can't-lose investment, then they certainly would not have sold it to you.
- namaria 3y agoThe changes from 1637 to now have been mostly regulations around how to offer financial products to people. Cryptocurrencies and NFTs circumvented those, allowing savvy individuals to target people not prepared to make such decisions. The problem here is precisely that the guardrails were jumped over by malicious actors. Hence the legal action.
- bell-cot 3y agoFor cryptocoins, which (roughly) claim to be financial instruments, the "now we have regulations forbidding...financial products" argument is fairly plausible. For the NFT's mentioned in the article - which are far more akin to ownership titles for signed photos of famous people, minor works of art, etc. - ah, no. I compared them to paintings for a reason. You could easily pay $100,000,000.00 for legal title to a painting by Andy Warhol. It is still a painting, not a financial product. And people telling you that the painting is a "great investment" does not change that.
- namaria 3y ago> It is still a painting, not a financial product. The line is way more blurred than you're implying. See Masterworks app and: https://web.archive.org/web/20230207154040/https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/29/arts/design/one-of-the-worlds-greatest-art-collections-hides-behind-this-fence.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230207154040/https://www.nytim... https://www2.deloitte.com/lu/en/pages/art-finance/articles/art-as-investment.html https://www2.deloitte.com/lu/en/pages/art-finance/articles/a... https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-freeports-operate-margins-global-art-market https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-freeports-oper...
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoNFTs were peak speculation and hype, and this lawsuit feels like a big case of buyers remorse. Someone is upset about losing money and wants to try to pin the blame for their bad bet on the people who facilitated the bet, regardless of how much liability they actually have for selling "bets" like that. My favorite thing about NFTs is how you can own the blockchain address for that NFT, but that doesn't mean there will actually be an NFT there when you load it. 50 years from now, how many NFT links will still work? Compared to a physical print or original painting, I don't consider them robust or timeless...they are tied to a specific technology in a particular era while a properly stored physical work of art will continue to evoke emotion without the need for electricity, even.
- j0hnyl 3y agoThere are many on chain NFTs that are pretty cool.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hindsightbias 3y agoIf we have to bail out David Sacks, why not nft losers?
- churchill 3y agoBail out David Sacks? You mean SVB - the bank that went bust investing in government securities? So, David Sacks should eat that loss simply because the federal reserve won't stop fooling around with interest rates? How does that even connect with NFTs?
- _yb2s 3y agoI still don’t get NFTs, they try to create a fake sense of scarcity for digital files that anyone can access. you “own” an NFT which contains the url of a publicly accessible ape image in the same sense that you can “own” Google by bookmarking it in a web browser
- bell-cot 3y agoI think of it more like "owning" a famous painting...which some major art museum has rights to keep on display for the next 999 years, and to sell images of in their gift shop, and to loan to other museums, etc. Outside of bragging rights with your snobby friends, you don't really "own" anything.
- jfengel 3y agoThe germ of not-stupid was that artists wanted a way to be able to prove their ownership of art. If somebody was using their art they could point to the NFT (which can contain a hash of the artwork) and say, "I own this and I can prove it." It's still up to courts to enforce it, but at least you had genuine proof. And it meant that when they sold the art, they could transfer the NFT, and now you truly own the art -- in a legal sense. That's good for the artist, when the buyer has more confidence that the transaction is binding. The artists were kinda excited for the automated contracts. They wanted to be able to sell a piece and retain a right to a share of future sales. That way if the $10 commission piece blew up like Banksy and sold for $5 million, they could automatically get a piece when the NFT sold. (In Ethereum rather than cash.) That all evaporated really quickly. Partly because of the scams, but also because NFTs aren't free. If you get a $10 commission and you have to pay $10 to make the NFT, you're not making any money. Maybe that wouldn't apply if it were done with a proof-of-stake rather than proof-of-work blockchain, but the entire thing became ridiculous before anybody could begin to work out the actual technical kinks. Plus, the idea of using the courts to enforce your copyright is a waste of time and money. Maybe some day you'd find that some corporation had grabbed your work and used it as a stock photo, but even with crypto-grade proof, it's an uphill battle. Again, it became ridiculous long before an actual enforcement opportunity presented itself. So... the idea wasn't initially completely stupid, just unrealistic. And then completely stupid.