4 ms·
It's the tragedy of the commons, but students using AI are only ruining their educational experience. The age of computers has brought easy word processing and
by jeroenhd 3y ago
It's the tragedy of the commons, but students using AI are only ruining their educational experience.
The age of computers has brought easy word processing and portable research tools that give you incredible freedom when writing papers or doing homework. No need to purchase book after book or hang out in the library all day if you're doing research.
Now with AI making automated plagiarism trivial, the system will need to change. I believe this can very well be the start of the return of pen and paper and non-digital essays under the watchful eyes of teachers.
Nobody wants such changes to happen, neither the educational staff nor the students, but I think it's inevitable.
AI is like calculators. They're an amazing tool that's essential for certain tasks, like actually applying higher algebra, but they're not a replacement of the basic skills most course and subjects are trying to teach.
Allowing the use of generative AI on essays is like giving primary school kids calculators to teach them arithmetic: the tool takes the place of the skills you're being taught. You can use all the spell and gammer checking AI you want on an essay (unless you're doing an English essay specifically to test your grammatical skills, of course) but don't grab a calculator when you're being taught how to do basic multiplication!
- MerelyMortal 3y ago> return of pen and paper and non-digital Sounds good to me, we just need to start teaching handwriting better. Have you seen handwriting from kids these days? They can't even read their own writing.
- pests 3y agoI couldn't read my own writing either and I graduated almost 20 years ago.
- JeanMarcS 3y agoIn a world where the grades matters more than knowledge, I'm afraid that it won't happen soon.
- Etherlord87 3y ago> the system will need to change How about requiring less essays but have the essays be better? You know, on the level above GPT. I see the problem of GPT as a hybrid of two problems: 1. The biggest problem here is not GPT - it's that human work has often been so bad, that a system with an intellect of a retarded cockroach (as Michio Kaku puts it) was able to displace it. People are so used to bad writing, that they don't recognize GPT nonsense. 2. GPT is largely another web search engine, and so it's an old problem repackaged: searching the web and copy-pasting what has been already said, which can be of high quality - maybe there is a solution to that, like being more specific?
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoMost people don't require to be writing better than chatgpt though. I wish the answer to this would be to improve education so that it interests people, but it's not gonna happen
- jstarfish 3y ago> the system will need to change. I believe this can very well be the start of the return of pen and paper and non-digital essays under the watchful eyes of teachers. Nah, in reality it'll just result in sales of heavily locked-down test-taking kiosks with all manner of UBA enforcement to school districts by shady vendors. The solution to technological problems is only ever more technology. My solution would be to fuzz the students into producing hallucinated answers. Bullshit the bullshitters-- ask them questions that are impossible to answer and see which ones complete the assignment. Anybody who completed the assignment fails. The ones that couldn't finish, you give partial credit based on their effort, and grade on a curve. We were never supposed to be testing students' ability to regurgitate trivia. They're not training to be Jeopardy contestants.
- runnerup 3y agoCan you explain how this would be a "tragedy of the commons"? I'm not sure I understand how there's a limited resource which each individual is incentivized to extract more than their sustainable share of.
- jeroenhd 3y agoOne student cheating will have an immeasurable advantage. All students cheating makes the whole system worse for everyone.