3 ms·
It's more efficient to burn hydrogen (or methane) in a combined cycle plant and use that power to drive heat pumps in homes and businesses, than it would be to
by pfdietz 3y ago
It's more efficient to burn hydrogen (or methane) in a combined cycle plant and use that power to drive heat pumps in homes and businesses, than it would be to burn that fuel in furnaces there. As an added bonus, you can often drive those heat pumps directly from renewable sources without the conversion cost of electrolysis (and for methane, DAC and methane synthesis.)
Methane also has the probably unavoidable problem of leaks in the distribution network. It's a strong greenhouse gas; even small leaks are very problematic.
- rgmerk 3y agoYes, I agree, and am of the view that the widespread distribution of piped gas (hydrogen, methane, or blends thereof) to homes and small business is going to be phased out for the reasons you describe. But you can see why some people are trying to make a drop-in, clean-ish (modulo fugitive emissions) replacement for fossil gas.
- angiosperm 3y agoIncidentally, leaked hydrogen is substantially worse, as a greenhouse gas, than methane.
- fomine3 3y agoIs it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential#Values https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential#Value...
- morsch 3y agoIn the atmosphere? No. The GWP of methane is about twice as high as hydrogen, as far as we know. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_potential
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoNope, the GWP of methane is 2x larger than hydrogen, both on 20 and 100 year time scales. And that's on an equal-mass basis. If you consider an equal-energy basis (which is what we actually care about), methane is 5x worse than hydrogen. Finally, hydrogen has wider flammability limits than methane, so from a safety perspective you have to make hydrogen systems even more leak-proof than methane/natural gas systems.
- angiosperm 3y agoThe atmosphere has a limited capacity for turning H2 into H2O. As more H2 is released, each molecule takes longer to be neutralized.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt may be possible to increase this capacity, for example by releasing iron salt aerosols. These would generate additional OH and Cl radicals by photochemical reactions in sunlight. It would be better to use that increase to destroy methane, though. I also wonder if it could be better to make hydrogen by electrolysis of salt water and produce chlorine instead of oxygen. Released into sunlit atmosphere, chlorine is rapidly decomposed to Cl radicals which will rapidly react with methane (or hydrogen). You'd want to release it at sufficiently low dilution that there's enough methane in each air parcel to consume all the chlorine, though.
- pfdietz 3y agoOnly if you presume that considerably larger fraction of the hydrogen would leak, which is not a bad assumption. Anyway, use of hydrogen for grid storage does not require its transmission or distribution in pipelines, especially in the small pipes of local distribution networks for home/small business use where one might expect the most leakage.
- jaclaz 3y ago>It's more efficient to burn hydrogen (or methane) in a combined cycle plant and use that power to drive heat pumps in homes and businesses Well, heat pumps powered by methane do exist since years, the were biggish but there is a trend towards making smaller units suitable for home use, JFYI: http://www.roburheatpumps.co.uk/ http://www.roburheatpumps.co.uk/
- rcme 3y agoIt might be more efficient in terms of raw power inputs, but in cold climates using methane is still way cheaper at current prices.
- ianburrell 3y agoIn any scenario where electricity is cheap enough to make hydrogen or methane, it is cheap enough to run heat pumps. It is cheap enough to use heat strips. It is cheap enough to use the savings to buy everyone with gas furnace a heat pump.