3 ms·
I used to run a torrent site with a very significant user population. I would promote great users to mod positions. On average they would last 6 months before t
by qingcharles 3y ago
I used to run a torrent site with a very significant user population. I would promote great users to mod positions. On average they would last 6 months before they became Hitlerstalins and I would be forced to fire them.
Power corrupts :(
- MichaelZuo 3y agoI wouldn't go as far as to say they are 'corrupted', just that they are extracting their payment in a non-monetary form. i.e. There are no 'unpaid mods', at least for any significant period of time. It's just that typically in real life we try to avoid setting up relationships were the only compensation is payment in social status, petty office maneuvers, etc..., since it's very visibly obvious in person. So we don't think about the different dynamics online. But this is the compensation model for a huge fraction of online communities.
- memefrog 3y agoThat's an interesting theory, actually. Maybe part of the reason that our current economic system has been so successful is that it manages, mostly by chance, to avoid this kind of compensation. People are largely compensated in money. Of course, "toxic" office politics does exist. But it tends (at least where I'm from) to be something people associate with working for the public service, rather than in the commercial world.
- qingcharles 3y agoThat's interesting. How about if I changed the model and paid the mods? I would seemingly be able to increase my control over them, insomuch as I could more easily tell them to "lighten up," but would that work? Paying them definitely balances out the power dynamic a bit, but I still feel that most people are inclined towards dictatorship when given power that is largely unchecked.
- paleotrope 3y agoThe conception of power is what corrupts. They feel like they have become protectors of thing they moderate and that's what leads to the downfall. I must protect/pet this thing that I love and I inadvertently kill it, see Lenny from Of Mice and Men.
- rtpg 3y agoThe adage is that you can either moderate a community or you can be a very active participant in the community, but really you shouldn't be both. Thank your local admins.
- nobodyandproud 3y agoAny long-lasting exceptions? I’m wondering what characteristics/personalities were more resistant to power trips, if any.
- qingcharles 3y agoThat's a great question. I can't remember any exceptions, which is alarming. Except myself, and I was just an absent mod, never mean. And my lackadaisical attention to the forums was what lead to me hiring all these unpaid mods. I'm endlessly fascinated by this subject as I'm about to go down the rabbit hole of opening another series of forums and I have no idea how to protect against this.
- fragmede 3y agoIt's not a "set it and forget it problem". In engineering terms, you've got a steam engine, not a bridge. A bridge you spend a lot of designing and engineering before a single brick is laid. There's upkeep and maintenance required, but it largely just sits there. A steam engine on the other hand, only just sits there if you don't want it to do what it was designed to do - be an engine. It needs a team of people working tirelessly round the clock babysitting it to cajole it into performing. What does that have to do with moderating a forum? It needs to be actively managed. Don't expect to put up a set of rules and then you'll be done. Solved the problem like it was a math problem. No, it's like the dishes, or doing laundry, it's ongoing work. New would be to use an LLM to automate moderation. Give it the code of conduct, and then score the comment on how well it follows those guidelines. Set a bar above which requires manual review.
- qingcharles 3y agoThat's a really good way of putting it. Thank you.
- fragmede 3y agoIf 6 months was the average limit, just set that as the term limit then. People might choose to go mad with power more quickly, but you could always depose them before that term limit was up. Did you ever implement a decision transparency system, or require moderators get reelected or a vote of confidence every N months? These days, I'd go the automation route and use an LLM to mechanize most of the work.
- qingcharles 3y agoThis is my main plan. I've been looking at different AI moderation tools to at least assist and offer advice, if not wholesale do the job. I do like your idea of term limits, though.