That is very fair. It felt like Gil had some good ideas, had a reasonably good feel for what needed to be done, just didn't have the intuition to execute it wel

That is very fair. It felt like Gil had some good ideas, had a reasonably good feel for what needed to be done, just didn't have the intuition to execute it well. Jobs did. In a way Gil probably would have done very well working under Jobs but once you are in the CEO seat, there is no chance of taking that demotion.