3 ms·
The name is too cute, and actively misleads. You can't call this a "minimum" anything; it's an opinionated list of controls that several of the most savvy secur
by tptacek 3y ago
The name is too cute, and actively misleads. You can't call this a "minimum" anything; it's an opinionated list of controls that several of the most savvy security teams I know don't uniformly implement.
Just off the top of my head, things that aren't even universally seen by practitioners as good things, let alone things everyone does as a "minimal" baseline:
* On request, enable your customers or their delegates to test the security of your application
* Implement role-specific security training for your personnel that is relevant to their business function
* Comply with all industry security standards relevant to your business such as PCI DSS, HITRUST, ISO27001, and SSAE 18 --- LOL to this whole line item.
* Maintain an up-to-date diagram indicating how sensitive data reaches your systems and where it ends up being stored
There is then a longer list of controls that I think most practitioners would say are good things, but that aren't always P1-prioritized (for good reason, to make way for more important things). CSP headers, SLSA level 1 builds, media sanitization policies; these things are situationally important.
I think an opinionated checklist is a fine thing, but when you call something the "minimal viable" standard, you set yourself up to explain how lots of well-run companies are viable without these things.
- prepend 3y agoThis is about as accurate in naming as a “minimal life list” that includes things like living debt free and having a $1M insurance policy. Or closer to recommended practices. As these are definitely not minimal since there are many products that won’t meet them yet are still viable. It’s also funny how cyber consultants seem more apt to add “required” thing that really tend to increase their bill hours. Like how accounting firms love Sarbanes Oxley and like to add in new rules that they claim are necessary.
- reidjs 3y agoWhat is Sarbanes Oxley and what’s it got to do with accounting firms? Edit: court ruling (shortened SOX) has to do with security compliance for public companies. After Enron and other scams https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarbanes%E2%80%93Oxley_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sarbanes%E2%80%93Oxley_Act
- kemotep 3y ago> Comply with all industry security standards Yeah this should just be the list. But then it wouldn’t be it’s own thing. It would just being SOC2 or NIST-800 certified.
- chunk_waffle 3y ago> * Comply with all industry security standards relevant to your business such as PCI DSS, HITRUST, ISO27001, and SSAE 18 --- LOL to this whole line item. I stopped reading at this point, completely disillusion for anything _minimally viable_ it's 2023 and I've still seen large companies with credentials and passwords committed into their code...
- Terretta 3y agoFor "sensitive" information, as this is scoped to, one shouldn't LOL at the standards line.
- jjav 3y ago> several of the most savvy security teams I mean the list isn't for savvy security teams. Or, I'd say, not even for companies with any kind of security team. For the typical startup with zero people with any security experience, it's something they can do. If they get to a point of hiring a security team, they're past the point of needing such a starter list. > Comply with all industry security standards relevant to your business such as PCI DSS, HITRUST, ISO27001, and SSAE 18 --- LOL to this whole line item. That's silly to say. You must comply with regulations that apply to your industry. Try setting up a bank and just LOL at banking regulations (SBF?). Of course, if none apply to your industry, ignore them all.