3 ms·
> By contrast, once you pass the event horizon of a black hole, these properties swap. Sigh. No. They do not. Moreover, nothing special at all happens to you w
by cyberax 3y ago
> By contrast, once you pass the event horizon of a black hole, these properties swap.
Sigh. No. They do not. Moreover, nothing special at all happens to you when you pass the event horizon.
In fact, if you are free-falling then you should not even be able to detect the crossing using only local experiments.
> It's possible to "move freely" in time in the sense that you can find reference frames that appear to move backwards in time.
Nope.
What happens is that your spatial directions become more and more constrained, until they collapse into a single point (the singularity). And then you'll just exist in this single point forever, according to GR.
From your viewpoint, it'll look like the singularity becomes an infinite plane that cuts off most of your field of vision. You'll be falling towards this plane, but until the last moment you'll be able to receive signals from outside of the black hole.
If someone puts a stationary clock outside the black hole's event horizon, you won't see it going faster or slower. And for any realistic black hole, your trip to the singularity will consume only a short time according to that clock.
- Spivak 3y agoAnd to add to this a singularity is predicted by GR, we don't actually know if such a thing exists and there are models where it doesn't like LQG where black holes are just a different kind of star whose collapse is opposed by a repulsive force that is predicted to exist by the uncertainty principle.
- dvt 3y ago> Sigh. No. They do not. Technically, GP is right that they (mathematically) swap, but yeah, it has a meaningless physical effect (the geodesic is always smooth). It's akin to describing the rotation of a kicked ball with imaginary exponentiation and thinking something spooky is going on.
- antognini 3y agoSo I would agree with this for the Schwarzschild metric. The swapping of signs in the space and time components of the metric does not have any real physical consequences. But when you move to a Kerr metric it absolutely does because it permits the construction of closed timelike curves.
- nimish 3y agoIt doesn't happen in Gullstrand-Painleve coordinates which would be a "correct" set of coordinates for a freely falling observer as they enter into a black hole. Or the Lemaitre coordinates work too. Passing the event horizon in Schwarzschild coordinates is meaningless, it never happens.
- codethief 3y ago> From your viewpoint, it'll look like the singularity becomes an infinite plane that cuts off most of your field of vision. You might need to elaborate because the singularity in Schwarzschild is not something you can spoke with a stick, let alone see. It is a spacelike singularity, meaning in this case that it lies in the future of any observer falling into the black hole. It is like death: It is certain you will encounter yet in the future, yet you don't see it.