3 ms·
How would that relate to CORBA and friends? (I know I could google all this. It’s more fun to chat about it.)
by kstrauser 3y ago
How would that relate to CORBA and friends?
(I know I could google all this. It’s more fun to chat about it.)
- bluGill 3y agoCORBA was another attempt of much the same thing there are dozens at the time. Of course each had slightly different goals and variations, so you can't always compare directly. Some were more to one direction or the other.
- cancerhacker 3y ago(It was not fun times. It was "hey everyone, all our problems will be solved by adopting XXX" which inevitably introduced a new set of problems which could be solved by only adopting half of XXX and all of YYY, repeat. Now that I think about it, I don't think anything has really changed, except that now the XXX has mutated into a XYZZY, we call it technical debt and then we retire to leave it for the next lot.)
- coliveira 3y agoCORBA is a specification to make objects interact across processes and computers. Its main drawback is the complexity, as it has to adjust to the several use cases (local and remote processes/computers) and provide interfaces to all different languages that might want to use objects, all this in a transparent way. Having CORBA specifications working reliably was a big problem to solve, and it was never 100% done, as new problems and specifications would pop up as needed. Finally, web technology solved most (but not all) of these problems by skipping programming language level objects and moving to higher level interaction through HTML/XML interfaces.
- jamesblonde 3y agoAll true, but the real differentiator that enabled SOAP to kill CORBA was the appearance of NATs and firewalls. CORBA assumed objects could talk directly via IP. But NATs appeared at the end of the 1990s when IP addresses were running out, suddenly CORBA wouldn't work in corporate environments. But SOAP could be made to work with http proxies. SOAP, of course, was superceded by REST, because it was too complex and REST was perceived as much simpler.
- coliveira 3y agoWell, I guess that with more specifications thrown in the mix this could be covered too. The problem, as I mentioned, is the incredible complexity of the whole thing. Web technology solves these issues in simpler ways that don't involve messing up with remote objects at the programming level.