5 ms·
> stock compensation is really not to be relied upon at its face value. This is a fantastic realization to have. Getting stock as compensation is a bit like g
by JohnFen 3y ago
> stock compensation is really not to be relied upon at its face value.
This is a fantastic realization to have. Getting stock as compensation is a bit like getting lottery tickets as compensation. This is triply true if they're options rather than actual stock.
I learned decades ago to ignore the stock component of compensation packages when evaluating an offer. I'll never turn stock or options down, but they will also never be something that will "tip the scales" for me.
- 88913527 3y agoIs there a technical difference in considering an RSU to be a stock option with a $0 strike price?
- pxue 3y agoRSU have immediate tax implications, while options may not (and mostly do not) until time of exercise.
- alasdair_ 3y agoYou pay taxes when RSUs vest. You pay taxes on options only when you exercise them. In addition, when the RSUs vest, they are yours when you leave the company, with options you have to exercise within a time period (a short one if it's an ISO, potentially 10 years for NSOs).
- sarchertech 3y agoStock in a large publicly traded company is a lot different than options in startup. I definitely think it makes sense to apply some discount to stock compensation when comparing offers, but if stock in a large publicly traded company is very likely worth something.
- JohnFen 3y agoThe two are definitely different, yes. But I ignore both of them anyway, personally. It's very hard to know what the future value of any stock (even in a large publicly traded company) will be, so it's very hard to figure out how to translate that into value in terms of compensation.
- sarchertech 3y agoJust pick some conservative discount like 50% of the current value. Your average large publicly traded company is unlikely to dip that far and not bounce back.
- JohnFen 3y agoThat's fully reasonable, yes. It's not my style, but there's nothing wrong with it.
- maerF0x0 3y agoTWLO has left the chat. (it was down about 90% from peak to trough) (as have many other names, not to pick on twlo specifically). I actually think (and so far am right) that it was massively undervalued at $45 a share.
- theptip 3y agoI think this is perhaps overly pessimistic. In general if you are getting RSUs and the share price tanks, you’ll get bumped back up with a refresher grant. The big public companies are making sure that your annualized total comp is in the right range, because if it isn’t (so the assumption goes) you’ll just move to another BigCo that will cut you a fresh grant at market rate.
- red-iron-pine 3y agothat is a very California way of looking at it. Non-competes don't work that way in a lot of places, and few companies outside of the largest would deem to throw that kind of compensation at people if the stock falters -- and only for certain tiers of employees. IBM would just fire you. Ditto for most of the other F500 sphere.
- theptip 3y agoFair. Perhaps I should be more specific: if your RSUs are <= 10% of total comp, as you say the employer might not top you up, and so conservative rounding down may be more reasonable. If your RSUs are closer to 50% of comp, rounding to zero will unreasonably hurt your comp comparisons, both by sheer magnitude of the grant, and because employer will definitely be conscious of regrants. Not all CA tech companies give huge RSU grants, but the biggest ones tend to.
- alasdair_ 3y agoI think there needs to be a distinction between options in a series A startup and RSUs in a large (but still private) company. I don't value the latter at zero since the chance of a liquidity event is much higher and RSUs mean there is no need to actually purchase the options when you leave the company (and risk all the tax problems that go along with this). I roughly value RSUs in a late-stage private company (say, Stripe) at 50%-75% of market value when considering an offer, while a very early stage options grant is almost worthless to me, say 5% of its value.
- bilalq 3y agoThis doesn't work for a lot of mature tech companies. RSUs are as good as cash at vest time, but the delay between grant and vest basically leaves you with variable pay. You can't just ignore it though, since the targeted value of your RSU compensation alone will be higher than base pay in many cases.
- JohnFen 3y ago> You can't just ignore it though, since the targeted value of your RSU compensation alone will be higher than base pay in many cases. Sure you can. You just gauge based on the base pay alone. If that's adequate, I'm good to go. If it isn't, then I'm not. That way, I'm not hurt if the stock ends up being worthless. I may be leaving money on the table, of course, but I'm also eliminating unnecessary risk. Other people may have different risk tolerances, naturally. My main point is that counting stock as part of a compensation package is the same as buying stock -- you need to be aware that you're taking on risk.
- sokoloff 3y agoIn using that strategy, you're trading one risk for another risk, not eliminating risk.
- JohnFen 3y agoWhat risk am I taking on?
- sokoloff 3y agoThe risk of foregone upside in expected value (or, alternately, expected utility) to the extent that you are mis-valuing one of your genuine choices. If Netflix is going to pay you $200K/yr and Facebook $180K plus $400K in FB shares vesting over 4 years, IMO, it's an error (IMO) to conclude that Netflix's offer is $20K/yr more than Facebook.
- 3y ago
- marssaxman 3y agoI could have written your comment verbatim!