3 ms·
I'm very much worried that this will happen with electric cars as well, that their batteries will just run out and will need to be replaced wholesale, but that
by Cthulhu_ 3y ago
I'm very much worried that this will happen with electric cars as well, that their batteries will just run out and will need to be replaced wholesale, but that it won't be economically viable.
I mean there's a project out there that monitors the battery capacity and lifetime of electric cars, tracking those of Tesla's Model S from over ten years ago now; those seem to be holding up all right.
But it will cause more trash. 100 year old cars can still run today because the parts can be replaced, or worst case, engine components can be machined.
That said, maybe over time there will be new generations of battery tech that will make it viable to replace and even upgrade old electric vehicle batteries. It's not likely in the near future though. And I think it'll be suppressed by existing battery manufacturers, Tesla being foremost - I'm not convinced cars are Tesla's long term goal, it'll be battery tech and charging infrastructure.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago"Dead" batteries from Leafs and Teslas are still quite useful for energy storage and thus quite valuable and unlikely to end in landfill. The recycling rate on lead acid batteries is over 99%. Li ion batteries will likely end up with a similar number.
- WorldMaker 3y ago> That said, maybe over time there will be new generations of battery tech that will make it viable to replace and even upgrade old electric vehicle batteries. That exists in limited capacity today. There are shops that have replaced older Leaf model batteries with upgraded batteries. That's a big deal for some of the earliest Leaf models because they had tiny batteries by today's standards (or Tesla's) and get double or triple range compared to when they were new. There aren't going to be as many models today that will benefit in quite the same way as those early Leafs, but it will probably still be a niche thing once we figure out what the average lifecycle of a car battery is. (As you mention, it is certainly greater than ten years we're seeing from Tesla batteries and others. Based on current data, it seems like it may be close to 20 years or possibly more that batteries last in their "first use" in cars.) Also, there's a bunch of companies working on electrifying old ICE cars today, which uses similar skills. I think it's fun to watch decades old cars with very new life as EVs. Some of those cars drive better than they ever did before.