5 ms·
When agriculture uses 70+% of all water in the Colorado River system and California’s Imperial Irrigation District is the largest consumer [0], we should probab
by ethbr1 3y ago
When agriculture uses 70+% of all water in the Colorado River system and California’s Imperial Irrigation District is the largest consumer [0], we should probably start there.
At some point, people need to vote in their own interests.
Farming is important, but it isn't the only thing that's important. Ripping up use-it-or-lose-it and grandfathered water rights (with compensation and phase-out times) should be on the table. It's a vestige of a different world and isn't appropriate for today.
Do we prioritize agriculture or human use, given modern water constraints?
Shifting policy to promote less water-consumptive agriculture and penalize high-consumption agriculture seems like a reasonable bargain.
[0] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/colorado-river-water-cuts-will-ease-in-2024-despite-long-term-challenges https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/colorado-river-water-cut...
- mike_d 3y ago> Ripping up use-it-or-lose-it and grandfathered water rights (with compensation and phase-out times) should be on the table. That is a battle that will be tied up in the courts for 15+ years. What we need to do right now is add a 200% export tax on high water items (alfalfa, almonds, etc) leaving the country. Incentivize farmers to divert water usage to feeding domestic animals or growing crops that feed people domestically.
- trealira 3y ago> That is a battle that will be tied up in the courts for 15+ years. What makes you say this? Is it already being fought in courts? Or is this just educated speculation?
- ceejayoz 3y agoThere's plenty of evidence water rights cases/disputes take a long time. https://www.justice.gov/enrd/arizona-v-california https://www.justice.gov/enrd/arizona-v-california has been running since 1952.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoCases get caught up in court because for the most part government agencies try to rip up contracts without paying and they often lose. Most Farmers have a price that they willingly pay to give up their Perpetual water rights. In general, the US legal system legal system does not allow forced taking without appropriate compensation. Similarly, it looks unfavorably on taxing someone out of business to avoid buying their property. This is because it's essentially a workaround for the former. If the state want's mike_d's house, They cant impose a 200% property tax on to force him to sell
- jjoonathan 3y ago> In general, the US legal system legal system does not allow forced taking without appropriate compensation. For the poor: Civil Asset Forfeiture "We'll take what we want, when we want, without trial." For the rich: "Sorry sir, here's a blank check, how much do you want to get paid to not waste water?"
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI don't like civil asset forfeiture either, but it is the exception not the rule. We should work to get rid of asset forfeiture, not work to normalize arbitrary seizure
- jjoonathan 3y agoNo, you're right, CAF is the exception, the rule is that poor people are too poor to own perpetual exclusive property rights so they have to pay the rich people who do own those rights whatever they can get away with asking.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoAnd your solution is CAF for all people and all assets? What are you trying to say? Do you think a legal system where the government can simply take anything it wants on a whim will end up better or worse for the poor and powerless?
- johnvanommen 3y ago> What we need to do right now is add a 200% export tax on high water items (alfalfa, almonds, etc) leaving the country. Fun fact: California grows rice and exports it to Asia. There isn't an export tax; in fact the rice is taxpayer subsidized. If you drive north of Sacramento on the I5, you'll see the rice paddies all over the place.
- coryrc 3y agoMaybe China could do us a solid and file a WTO case?
- coryrc 3y ago> That is a battle that will be tied up in the courts for 15+ years. All the more reason to get started ASAP.
- codalan 3y agoWouldn't a 200% export tax on high water items incentivize the same foreign investors to purchase more cattle operations in the US, ship their alfalfa to those ranches, then ship the meat abroad?
- LinuxBender 3y agoDo we prioritize agriculture or human use, given modern water constraints? Aren't those basically the same things just at different stages? Where should the food production move to? I ask because there is a strong movement to re-shore everything so moving it off-shore probably won't get much traction. It's probably a different topic all together but I would agree that most things we produce are not required for healthy well nourished people but there would probably be a diverse range of opinions on what foods those might be. My personal preference would be to nix anything that is not Paleolithic, i.e. get rid of anything that is not meat or vegetable or does not contribute to that chain so we keep the things that feed livestock and stop producing the rest
- ethbr1 3y agoFood production should move to where there's sufficient water to grow things economically. About 20-60% of US agricultural value is exported, mostly in unprocessed form, so there's little danger of the US becoming dependent on food imports. https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery/chart-detail/?chartId=58396 https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/chart-gallery/gallery... High-water use crops are only economical to grow in the southwest because water is mispriced. Absent that, farmers would grow something else. They'd probably make less money, but that's something we address via subsidies (gradually phasing out).
- LinuxBender 3y agoI agree with all of this, but They'd probably make less money There is no incentive for farmers that already operate on razor thin margins to make less money. They will produce whatever makes them the most money. How do we incentivize changing behavior without putting farmers out of business? Or I guess another way to put it is, how do we correct the system that got us here without punishing the farmers? AFAIK they are not the bad guys, rather they are the ones feeding us and are subject to operating in the system that was created before they were born. Changing water rights does not feel like it addresses the problem in a way that does not harm innocent people. Maybe that should happen long term when water demands are lower but it feels like the demand should shift first through some incentives. How do we change incentives without harming people so that we can later change the water rights without as much push-back?
- BurningFrog 3y ago> Do we prioritize agriculture or human use? All this water is used by humans. Farmers, and the people who eat the food they make, are all humans.
- Retric 3y agoFirst it’s not all farmers we’re talking about, changing things would be beneficial for far more farmers than get harmed. Anyway, for farmers in CA and you get different results than optimizing for say everyone in the CA or even better everyone in the US. Cheap land + old water rights is profitable for individuals but extremely wasteful or water and results in massive and unneeded infrastructure to move water around. The amount of water wasted due to evaporation is a direct result of subsidizing wasteful use. Such inefficiency is bad for humanity but profitable for a few individuals.
- kolanos 3y ago> Not quite, the problem is water isn’t being used efficiently. Agriculture wastes a great deal of water to evaporation because it’s cheaper not because it’s required. The water evaporates because of the sun. Have you solved the growing crops without a sun problem? Everyone wants to make one of the most efficient crops (alfalfa) the enemy. But alfalfa growers are not subsidized by the government at all. Do you know which crop is? Corn. Corn wastes many times more water per acre than alfalfa, but is rarely mentioned in such HN threads. Gotta keep that "clean" ethanol flowing.
- Retric 3y agoI am not specifically talking about crop choice here. Center pivot irrigation requires very little infrastructure for a farmer, but spraying a light mist is a great way to evaporate water before it even reaches any plants. Similarly, water pooling on the surface evaporates faster than water sitting just an inch below the soil. Alpha doesn’t directly care about this difference, but one is far cheaper than the other if and only if you price that water at close to 0$. Of course if farmers needed to price in water then things like crop choice would change, but that’s simply the market reacting to price signals. Aka the vary basis of our economy.
- kolanos 3y ago> At some point, people need to vote in their own interests. By not eating? Because starvation is what is going to happen when the price of food increases by 10X or 50X. Visit your local food bank and see how many people can't afford food now. You might say, "well, the U.S. will just have to import more food". One problem with that: the U.S. is the largest producer of food by a wide margin. What country is going to pick up the slack? > Do we prioritize agriculture or human use, given modern water constraints? These are one and the same. Almost all agriculture is either directly or indirectly for human use (food).
- johnvanommen 3y agoSeems easy to fix: * take those water thirsty crops in California and start growing them in places like Iowa, where water is plentiful and labor costs are lower * use that freed up land to build more housing, lowering the cost of living in CA win-win
- Dig1t 3y agoA nuclear power plant + desalination plant would fix this situation almost completely. California has the resources (money), and knowhow (tons of engineers) to make this happen if they want. Israel gets 55% of their water this way and California can too. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/israel-proves-the-desalination-era-is-here/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/israel-proves-the...
- berniedurfee 3y agoThat’s really interesting, I didn’t know desalinization was so far along. I’m sure there are downsides, but if we’re going to insist on turning deserts into cities, this seems like a no-brainer.