3 ms·
> This is how this is supposed to work in a healthy and well-functioning society/community -- it moderates itself with internal deliberation about what the norm
by lelanthran 3y ago
> This is how this is supposed to work in a healthy and well-functioning society/community -- it moderates itself with internal deliberation about what the norms are and with reflection and awareness of how things are changing, with self-assigned community leaders and adults!
I'd like to think that it's a good idea, but don't you think that it will quickly become an echo chamber?
Think of current communities known for being intolerant of outside ideas (The very religious communities, the hard left/right communities) - the only way they can do so is because they police themselves against new ideas.
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoMaybe. So what? Humans are wired to form small communities. That was the world before the internet. Now everyone is connected on these massive platforms and people are miserable. Maybe that older model was the right one after all, and the trade-off--less contact between those communities--is worth it, so long as people can freely associate with whichever communities they choose.
- lelanthran 3y ago> Maybe. > So what? So ... nothing, I guess? I didn't say whether I thought it was a good or bad thing, I just wanted to point out that there is more nuance than appears at first glance. I'm not advocating for blind "in-group good, out-group bad" policies, nor for the reverse of "new thing good, old thing bad".
- pen2l 3y agoI get and appreciate what you're saying but I disagree because I think when the veil is a little bit lifted for a community of the mechanisms of moderation it is subject to, it both nullifies a component of chaos in its evolution and I think it hastens the path of progression by allowing a more clear-headed internal deliberation. I think it is generally true that things get better and better values win when a community is left alone to their devices (pun unintended), what with the long arc of justice in the universe and all.