3 ms·
>no such right exists; that would be like the right to rob with impunity No, it's the same kind of thing as having your records "sealed", to not let a past dee
by coldtea 3y ago
>no such right exists; that would be like the right to rob with impunity
No, it's the same kind of thing as having your records "sealed", to not let a past deed haunt you.
Not even sure what kind of logic jumps one has to make to equate something like this to "robbing with inpunity". For starters the punishment to robbing isn't remembrance of your robbing, it's jail time or fine etc. And, fun fact, the aforementioned "records being sealed" can even be applied to someone who e.g. did a robbery or other crime as a juvenile.
Now, since a "right to be forgotten" does explicitly exist in EU and other jurisdictions, I'm not sure what denying its existance means.
If you mean "there's no such right" as a thing in itself, outside laws and treaties and jurisdictions, then the same is true for any right.
No right exists by itself, as if handed to us by nature, not even the right to not be murdered. All rights are based on people deciding some kind of assurances are good to have and putting them into laws and treaties and such.
And all rights are only granted and protected based on power relationships and agreement, not based on some (non-existent) natural truths existing independenty of them in the cosmos. We might call some "self-evident" and "natural" but those are just fancy words. In actual history almost all of our so-called "self-evident/natural" rights have been unrecognized (even in quite recent history), and societies considered this just fine. In fact in some cases, actually giving the rights would be considered the violation of the natural law.
>of course clever demagogues and rhetoricians can write such things into legislation
Demagogue is someone who "who seeks support by appealing to the desires and prejudices of ordinary people rather than by using rational argument". Rhetorician is a public speaker who is good in persuading people with words. Neither have much to do with such legislation being passed (nor was it the work of some demagogues).
It's simply about the internet making anything somebody does into a permanent record [1], and this being understood as not always necessarily being for the benefit of society.
E.g. what some edgy/troubled teenager wrote on his social media account in his teens shouldn't necessarily be part of his "permanent record" for employers and others to judge them by decades afterwards. And in the past, it wasn't, unless it made the press (and even then, it was easily lost due to it being in print and ephemeral), or was deemed necessary so by the state (e.g. to register as a sex offender). Just because technology now makes it being a permanent record trivial doesn't mean we should be OK with it. We should be masters of technology, not slaves to it.
[1] Doesn't matter if something like that could be accomplished in the past too - what matters is that it's far more prevalent, has several orders of magnitude more scale of the kind of stuff that can be kept, and is easier to achieve, and trivial to search with the advent of the internet. This changes the impact of this to society a lot.
- kragen 3y agowhile i disagree with what you say, i want to say that i really appreciate you saying something substantial and reasonable, rather than just repeating the vacuous moral-relativist nonsense that is the rest of this thread (i think your comment would be higher-quality if you also deleted your repetition of that vacuous nonsense, though, because it makes it harder to discuss the substantial issues here; there would be no point in discussing ethical issues at all if moral relativism were correct. you wouldn't have bothered to post a comment at all if you were the nihilist you are posing as) remember that lashon hara is by definition truthful; the point of the story is not that it is commendable to say everything that is truthful
- coldtea 3y ago>there would be no point in discussing ethical issues at all if moral relativism were correct (...) you wouldn't have bothered to post a comment at all if you were the nihilist you are posing as This is wrong on several levels, including practical and philosophical (and those aspects of it have been covered a lot in moral philosophy). For starters, whether morality is relative or objective has no bearing at all to whether it exists as a practical force in the human world - and thus whether it makes total practical sense to study it, shape it, apply it, benefit from it, use it to make things work smoother or more to your liking, and so on. (Not to mention how it also makes sense to examine it, document it, and discuss it, from a curiosity or historical interest perspective, even if it doesn't concern one directly as a practical matter. People do study the morality of other historical periods or distant societies, for example, even if it has no impact on their life in their society). Note that there are several other things for which exactly the same thing applies: religion, laws, taboos, and so on, even art and fashion. >you wouldn't have bothered to post a comment at all if you were the nihilist you are posing as Rejecting natural rights and understanding that rights are historical constructions doesn't mean one is disintered in rights. I am very much interested in my right to my property, for example, and will vote, advocate, protest, demonstrate, etc, to maintain it. I don't have to believe there's some inherent natural "right to property" for that. Just that I find the legal enforcement of one beneficial to me, and that I'd rather live in a society where it is enforced, as opposed to one where it's not.