2 ms·
This probably works well for Fog Creek, who have a small crew and very talented senior people (who, importantly, did not get recuited out of school). But I vie
by ajross 15y ago
This probably works well for Fog Creek, who have a small crew and very talented senior people (who, importantly, did not get recuited out of school). But I view this as problematic for larger companies. The core problem of course is that students aren't very good programmers yet. They can hack and solve problems, and have a handful of favorite technologies, but they won't have the breadth they need to be really good at things for a few years yet.
The danger is that if you then build a culture where everyone gets recruited out of school, everyone is swimming in the same pool with equally narrow skill sets and no one develops the required breadth. So you get "architects" who know their field really well but can barely write working code on a modern system.
This works great for the true elite who will learn this stuff on their own, of course. But even then recruiting from schools tends to incorrectly bias decisions on things like grades, which correlate at best weakly with hacking talent. You'll miss some of those targets who were slacking off in class working on their own projects.
- eli_gottlieb 15y ago>The danger is that if you then build a culture where everyone gets recruited out of school, everyone is swimming in the same pool with equally narrow skill sets and no one develops the required breadth. So you get "architects" who know their field really well but can barely write working code on a modern system. In my experience, that kind of narrow hyperfocus is exactly what most companies actually want -- including startups. Some may think they want breadth, but they actually just want breadth within the narrow specialty they address.
- tedunangst 15y agoActually, some of the biggest of the big guns at Fog Creek did come straight from school. More than one product was built exclusively by people who never worked anywhere else. The whole point of the internship recruiting process is to correct for the high grades only bias.