4 ms·
Python 3.3 reintroduces explicit Unicode literals to ease porting
- kibwen 15y agoTL;DR: In Python 3.3, the string 'hello, world!' is synonymous with the string u'hello, world!' to more easily conform to the Python 2.X paradigm. It is not intended for use with new code. It is possible/expected that this feature will be deprecated and dropped in future releases of Python.
- angersock 15y agoso we'll have to change our massive amount of python 3 code? yeah okay sure (j/k nobody uses python 3)
- DasIch 15y agoNot only don't you need to change the code you shouldn't. This change has been introduced purely for code which tries to maintain Python 2 and Python 3 compatibility.
- RayVR 15y agoDasIch is correct. This is meant to expedite the transition for those applications which have had trouble porting to python3 due to lack of developers or just difficulty in transitioning from use of unicode literals.
- pmjordan 15y agoTangent: If the 'reply' link below a comment is missing, please click the 'link' permalink to reply (you may need to wait a minute and reload it for the input box to appear). Please don't post replies as sibling comments as they won't necessarily appear in order.
- sho_hn 15y agoI know, don't feed the troll and all, but for the benefit of interested readers, here are two recent HN threads which largely discussed the current status of the migration: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3696451 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3696451 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3666361 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3666361 TL;DR: The tone of such conversations has changed a lot since last year, IMHO. Python 3 is seeing real use now, those who made the switch seem to often be happy they did, and many who haven't yet can at least see the light at the end of the tunnel now. Generally there's a lot more optimism to be found.
- briancurtin 15y ago> (j/k nobody uses python 3) Only about 450K downloads per month of Python 3 throughout 2011...on Windows, that platform no one uses. [source: the first several slides of my PyCon talk - http://briancurtin.com/PyCon2012Presentation.pdf http://briancurtin.com/PyCon2012Presentation.pdf]
- ma2rten 15y agoI don't want to be overly cynical, but a lot of users download the latest version, before they realize 2.7 is what they really want/need. I for one made that mistake. I know at least of a couple of friends who did this as well.
- briancurtin 15y agoThat is certainly a situation that happens, but I don't think the number of people who actually went on to install and use the interpreter for something is any significant amount lower.
- z0ot 15y agofrom __past__ import unicode_literals
- sho_hn 15y agoMichael Foord's mock lib also made it into the standard lib the other day, but I didn't manage to make the HN front page: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3705923 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3705923 (I'll never figure out what the trick is.)
- simonw 15y agoA lot of it comes down to the title. Your title was "Michael Foord's mock library added to Python 3.3 STL" - there are a couple of problems here. Firstly, most people won't know who Michael Foord is so using his name at the start of the title won't pull in any attention. Secondly, STL isn't a well known acronym for standard library. Something like "Python standard library finally gains a mocking library in Python 3.3" might have worked better.
- VMG 15y agowell, I wouldn't upvote because of the word "finally" - too much editorialization
- sho_hn 15y agoGood points, thanks. I intentionally lead with the name because to me, the news was which of the mocking libs around had been chosen for standard lib inclusion. But that limits the audience to those familiar with the field; your version works much better for a general interest audience indeed. I thought STL to be pretty common though.
- beagle3 15y agoSTL is now a name for the C++ STandard Library, but it's semi backronymed. Originally, STL stood for "Standard Template Library", when it wasn't part of the C++ standard library. So actually, STL refers to the standard library only in the context of C++, and only because of how it came to be.
- kragen 15y agoNo, the STL is the Standard Template Library, in C++, by STepanov and Lee at the HP Software Technology Laboratory. It doesn't mean "standard library", even though some inexperienced C++ programmers get confused between the STL and the rest of the standard library, now that the STL is part of the standard library.
- andrewcooke 15y agothis is great news, but will it be backported? i had to jump through hoops to support 2+3 in a single code base because of this (in case people don't understand u"abc" is a syntax error in python 3.0-2, which makes writing portable code that uses unicode tricky, since that's what it a unicode literal looks like in python 2). if it's not backported to 3.0-2 then we'll have the strange state of libraries that run on 2 and 3.3, but not inbetween.
- kibwen 15y agoWon't be backported (which would be sort of weird in any case... if you were going to actually go to the trouble of upgrading your copy of 3.2 by a minor version, you might as well just upgrade to 3.3), but they do address this in the PEP: There are many existing Python communities that are prepared to put up with the constraints imposed by the existing suite of porting tools, or to update their Python 2 code bases sufficiently that the problems are minimised. This PEP is not for those communities. Instead, it is designed specifically to help people that don't want to put up with those difficulties. However, since the proposal is for a comparatively small tweak to the language syntax with no semantic changes, it is feasible to support it as a third party import hook. While such an import hook imposes some import time overhead, and requires additional steps from each application that needs it to get the hook in place, it allows applications that target Python 3.2 to use libraries and frameworks that would otherwise only run on Python 3.3+ due to their use of unicode literal prefixes. One such import hook project is Vinay Sajip's uprefix [4]. For those that prefer to translate their code in advance rather than converting on the fly at import time, Armin Ronacher is working on a hook that runs at install time rather than during import [5]. Combining the two approaches is of course also possible. For example, the import hook could be used for rapid edit-test cycles during local development, but the install hook for continuous integration tasks and deployment on Python 3.2. The approaches described in this section may prove useful, for example, for applications that wish to target Python 3 on the Ubuntu 12.04 LTS release, which will ship with Python 2.7 and 3.2 as officially supported Python versions.
- maaku 15y ago
- takriz 15y agoSorry for this harsh statement, but Guido should do an internship at Theo of OpenBSD. We can't just decide to move backward to support programmers stupidity.
- mixmastamyk 15y agoIt'll help porting which will get momentum moving behind v3.
- njharman 15y agoI like OpenBSD. But, Python is not OpenBSD, it has a different set of core values. Pragmatism being high up that list. It is written by and for pragmatic programmers. Not purists, not idealists. It is stupid to violate core values.
- batista 15y agoThese Python programmers could potentially run circles in smartness around you or Theo. Or not. But it has nothing to do with the back-porting under discussion. Not desiring to undertake a big code changing effort != stupidity. Especially when you aren't even paid to do it. Actually, considering that you would then have a patched mess of a codebase, or have to support to codebases for users of older Python versions, it's actually the smart thing to do. And it's not like OpenBSD ever got anywhere --if you insist of using it as an example that "not moving backwards ever" is a plus. What's its adoption percentage again?
- icebraining 15y agoIt doesn't actually move backward in any meaningful way, it just makes the parser ignore a (now) extraneous character.
- joeycfan 15y agoI'm using python for the first time right now in my Udacity car course. Hate it. It's Internet BASIC.