5 ms·
Yep. There needs to be a REALLY FUCKING STRONG effort to kill all CP AI anything. Full stop. AI should automagically report any attempt at CP.
by samstave 3y ago
Yep.
There needs to be a REALLY FUCKING STRONG effort to kill all CP AI anything. Full stop.
AI should automagically report any attempt at CP.
- colechristensen 3y agoIf you’re running a service you should have automatic filtering, detection, and such. A model by itself though… you might as well ask a pencil to report someone for drawing graffiti. It does not make sense.
- eVeechu7 3y agoModels have been trained on something though. They are not analogous to pencils or brushes.
- GaggiX 3y agoIf you have 4 GB of VRAM, you can finetune a model to whatever you want.
- BHSPitMonkey 3y agoThey are responding specifically to the "AI should automatically report" suggestion. An AI model on its own (without a service built up around it) would not have any mechanisms to use the network, reach out to an FBI hotline, or do anything like this. Protections / limits would have to be added by the operator somehow (or the distributor of models themselves).
- nomel 3y agoI've always assumed this is what will be used to justify the regulation of AI.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThe four horsemen of internet censorship. Money laundering, CSAM, terrorism, drugs.
- samstave 3y agoDefine censorship when something is objectively wrong. Would you prefer an AI of "describe and print in 8k a body pit of objectional political dissidents thrown into a pit after being starved to death in a comical way such that my SV_BubbleTime can laugh at it as ooppsed to being offended by just how horrific this situation was HAHA"
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoYou seem to be having trouble understanding the topic. The censorship isn’t OF those things. It’s in the NAME OF those things.
- obvious_thrwawy 3y agoShould they check the IDs of the models to verify? Imagine getting reported because you generated an image of an anime girl deemed to be only 17. I'd personally rather live in a world where people generate distasteful images with an AI and have that AI unconstrained than the inevitable one where everything gets locked down and run by large corporations who will ultimately create more harm than someone generating some lolicon.
- idiotsecant 3y agoSerious question - Why? Assuming no actual CP was used in the training of the model who is being harmed? Ickiness should not imply illegality unless the ickiness is at the expense of someone else. Swing your fist as much as you want so long as you avoid my nose, and all.
- _6atf 3y ago> Serious question - Why? Assuming no actual CP was used in the training of the model who is being harmed I don't think an AI model could generate realistic CP without being trained on examples, which would mean there is literally no way for this assumption to be true.
- Sunhold 3y agoIf it's trained on pictures of children and adult porn, the model can easily combine the two concepts. Even if you remove one of these from the training set, it can be finetuned back in to the model with very little effort.
- _6atf 3y agoBased on other topic interpolations I don't think this works, especially not easily.
- GaggiX 3y agoIf I can finetune the model on my face and the model will be able to generate my nudes (even if there is no nude of mine in the dataset), then it can works easily with children too.
- _6atf 3y agoDo you understand that adult bodies and child bodies look different? Please show me a model trained on adult humans being fine tuned to generate a child human (fully clothed).
- MarcoZavala 3y ago[dead]